• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Characters and the doctor's dilemma

Describe Andrew, Joe, Susan's mother and the midwife with evidence, and explain the dilemma Andrew faces and how he resolves it.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe Andrew's character at the start and at the climax.
  • Explain the roles of the minor characters.
  • Explain the dilemma between mother and child.
  • Support each point with evidence in your own words.
CharacterQualitiesEvidence (in our own words)
Andrew MansonConscientious, determined, quick-thinking, emotionally tornStays all night instead of going home; recalls a hospital case; keeps working after everyone has given up
Joe MorganAnxious, trusting, devoted husbandWaits an hour for the doctor; paces the street all night; trusts Andrew to do well for them
Susan's motherWise, watchful, deeply hopefulOffers tea fearing the doctor will leave; watches his face; reports Susan's wish to protect the baby; prays at the end
The midwifeExperienced but resignedPuts the baby under the bed; begs Andrew to stop, saying the child is stillborn
Susan MorganDetermined to have her childAsks that no anaesthetic be given if it would harm the baby

Andrew: two states of mind

Andrew before and during the crisis

  • Before
    • Dull, listless, distracted
    • Brooding over unhappy marriages and Christine
    • Mind doubting, heart overflowing, resentful and confused
  • During
    • Alert and decisive
    • Acts instinctively to save the mother
    • Persists against all hope to revive the child

Cronin shows Andrew's inner conflict: his reason, looking at the failed marriages of colleagues, doubts that marriage can be happy, while his love for Christine wants to believe it can. That private confusion fades when a life is at stake; the crisis pulls him out of himself.

The dilemma

When the child is born lifeless, the mother is also in danger: collapsed, almost without a pulse, still under the anaesthetic. Andrew must choose whom to treat first. He does not decide consciously; he acts by instinct and saves the mother, whose life can clearly be saved. Only then does he turn to the child. Both lives are finally saved because he first secured one and then refused to abandon the other.

How Andrew handles the crisis

  1. Two lives in danger Lifeless child; collapsing mother.
  2. Instinctive priority Treat the mother first: injection, effort until her heart strengthens.
  3. Turn to the child Find it, recognise the condition, recall treatment seen in hospital.
  4. Persist Keep going though everyone else has given up.
  5. Success The child breathes, turns pink and cries.

Worked example 1: the grandmother's role

Question: why is the old woman important to the story? Working: she watches Andrew throughout, fears he will leave, carries the family's longing for the child, stands silently against the wall during the struggle, and prays when the child cries. Answer: she embodies the family's hope; her silent, watching presence raises the stakes for Andrew and the reader, and her prayer marks the emotional climax.

Worked example 2: why does the midwife give up?

Working: she is experienced; the child shows no sign of life; to her it is clearly stillborn, so she puts it aside and later begs Andrew to stop. Answer: her experience tells her the child is dead; she lacks Andrew's knowledge of the special treatment and his refusal to accept defeat. The contrast shows the value of both knowledge and persistence.

Andrew's greatness lies in two things: knowing what to do, and refusing to stop doing it when everyone else has given up.

Key takeaways: Andrew moves from distracted brooding to decisive action. The anxious husband, the hopeful grandmother and the resigned midwife frame his struggle. Faced with two lives at risk, he saves the mother first and then fights for the child until it breathes.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. What was Andrew thinking about while waiting in the kitchen?

    1. His medical exams
    2. The miners' wages
    3. Unhappy marriages he knew of, and Christine
    4. Dr Page's car
    Show answer

    Answer: C. He broods over colleagues' failed marriages and his feelings for Christine, a conflict between his doubting mind and his heart.

  2. 2. What request had Susan made, according to her mother?

    1. Not to be given chloroform if it would harm the baby
    2. To be taken to hospital
    3. To see Joe at once
    4. To name the baby Andrew
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Her mother reports that Susan asked not to be given the anaesthetic if it would harm the child.

  3. 3. Why did Andrew attend to the mother before the child?

    1. He thought the child was a girl
    2. The midwife told him to
    3. Joe asked him to
    4. He acted instinctively to save the mother, who was in a desperate state
    Show answer

    Answer: D. He did not decide consciously; instinctively he handed the child to the nurse and worked to save the collapsing mother.

  4. 4. Which word best describes the midwife's attitude when Andrew works on the baby?

    1. Hopeful
    2. Resigned
    3. Joyful
    4. Angry
    Show answer

    Answer: B. She believes the child is stillborn and begs the doctor to stop: she has given up.

  5. 5. What helped Andrew know how to treat the baby?

    1. Memory of a case he had once seen treated at a hospital
    2. A book he carried
    3. Advice from the grandmother
    4. A phone call to Dr Page
    Show answer

    Answer: A. His mind raced back to a similar case he had seen at the hospital, and he used the treatment he had seen there.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery