• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Writing and speaking: diary, article and discussion

Write Andrew's diary entry, an article on how medicine saves lives today, and prepare a discussion on textbook knowledge versus real practice.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Write a diary entry that captures a turning point.
  • Write a factual article without inventing figures.
  • Speak on the difference between textbook learning and practice.
  • Use examples from other fields as well as medicine.

The book's questions ask why Andrew says he has done something real, how textbook medicine differs from practice, and about people saved through medical help and procedures such as organ transplants. Models below are written for this lesson.

Writing 1: Andrew's diary

Model: *Friday, dawn. I am too tired to sleep and too happy to try. Joe Morgan fetched me at midnight. I went with my head full of Christine and of every unhappy marriage I know, and I was no use to anyone for hours. Then the child came, white and still, and Susan collapsed, and everything else vanished. I saved her first; I hardly know how I chose. Then the boy, under the bed. I remembered a case at the hospital and tried what I had seen done there. Half an hour of nothing. The midwife begged me to stop. I did not. And then his chest moved under my hands. I have been a doctor for weeks; tonight I think I became one.*

Writing 2: an article on saving lives

  • Title: Second Chances: How Medicine Saves Lives
  • Emergency care: Trained responders and doctors can restart breathing and circulation; knowing basic first aid lets ordinary people help until they arrive.
  • Organ transplants: When an organ such as a kidney fails, a healthy one from a donor can replace it. Some donations come from people after death; a kidney or part of a liver can also come from a living donor, because a person can live with one kidney and the liver can regrow.
  • Regeneration research: Scientists study how tissues repair themselves, hoping one day to grow replacement tissue. Much of this is still research, not routine treatment.
  • Conclusion: Medical skill, like Andrew's, depends on knowledge, quick judgement and persistence; donors and trained people make second chances possible.

Note: an article like this should not invent numbers. If you use a statistic, take it from a reliable, named source; otherwise, make your point without one.

Speaking: textbook and practice

Points for a discussion

  • Textbook knowledge
    • Gives the facts and methods
    • Learnt in calm conditions
    • Essential: Andrew recalls a case he saw
    • Same for every learner
  • Practice
    • Messy, urgent, under-equipped
    • Needs judgement and choices
    • Needs stamina and courage
    • Each case is different

A strong talk opens with a clear view (knowledge is necessary but not sufficient), gives the extract as evidence, adds an example from another field (a cricketer who knows the coaching manual but must read a real pitch; a pilot trained in simulators facing real weather), and ends by linking back to Andrew.

Worked example: a sharper diary line

Weak: I was very happy the baby lived. Working: show the feeling through the moment itself. Better: When his chest moved under my hands, the room tilted and I had to hold on to the bed. The reader feels the shock of joy.

Diary: feelings at a turning point. Article: facts you can trust, no invented figures. Talk: a view, evidence from the text, an example from life.

Key takeaways: Andrew's diary would capture the night as the moment he truly became a doctor. An article on saving lives must be factual and careful with numbers. In discussion, show that textbook knowledge is necessary but that practice also demands judgement, courage and persistence.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which line best fits Andrew's diary entry?

    1. Dear Sir, I wish to apply for a post.
    2. Notice: surgery closed.
    3. Tonight I think I became a doctor.
    4. Minutes of the meeting.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A diary records personal feelings; this line captures the turning point he experienced.

  2. 2. Why can a living person donate a kidney?

    1. Because kidneys are not needed
    2. Because a person can live with one healthy kidney
    3. Because kidneys regrow in a day
    4. Because donors are always doctors
    Show answer

    Answer: B. People normally have two kidneys and can live a healthy life with one, which makes living donation possible.

  3. 3. What does the article model say about regeneration?

    1. Much of it is still research, not routine treatment
    2. It is routine for all organs
    3. It was invented by Andrew
    4. It is impossible
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The model is careful: scientists study tissue repair, but most of this is still research.

  4. 4. What should you do if you want to use a statistic in an article?

    1. Guess a round number
    2. Copy it from a friend
    3. Make it up to sound convincing
    4. Take it from a reliable, named source, or make the point without it
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Facts must not be invented; use a reliable source or leave the figure out.

  5. 5. Which is the best opening view for a talk on textbook versus practice?

    1. Books are useless.
    2. Practice is easy.
    3. Knowledge from books is necessary but not sufficient; practice also demands judgement and courage.
    4. I have nothing to say.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It states a balanced, arguable view that the extract can support.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Birth

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery