• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

History, science and respect: the dynasty, Carter and modern archaeology

Explain the history behind Tut's reign, why Ray Johnson called Akhenaten wacky, why Carter's methods are criticised, how archaeology and technology have changed, and the debates the chapter raises.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Outline the family history from Amenhotep III to Tutankhamun.
  • List Akhenaten's deeds and explain why Tut changed his name.
  • Give reasons why Carter's handling of the mummy was resented, and why he had little choice.
  • Discuss the chapter's themes: science and mystery, respect for the dead, and the value of the past.

Behind the scientific drama lies a story of religion, power and change in ancient Egypt. Understanding it helps you answer the chapter's reason and list questions, and prepares you for its debates.

The family behind the boy king

The end of a dynasty

  1. Amenhotep III Tut's father or grandfather; ruled almost four decades in a golden age.
  2. Amenhotep IV / Akhenaten Promotes worship of the Aten (sun disk), renames himself and moves the religious capital.
  3. Smenkhkare A mysterious ruler who appears briefly and vanishes.
  4. Tutankhaten becomes Tutankhamun Young king restores the old ways; reigns about nine years.
  5. Tut's death The last of his family line; his funeral marks the end of a dynasty.

Why Akhenaten seemed 'wacky'

  • He promoted the worship of the Aten, the sun disk, above the traditional gods.
  • He changed his name from Amenhotep IV to Akhenaten, meaning servant of the Aten.
  • He moved the religious capital from Thebes to a new city, Akhetaten (now Amarna).
  • He attacked the major god Amun, smashing his images and closing his temples.

Why Tut changed his name: born Tutankhaten (honouring the Aten), the boy king became Tutankhamun, meaning living image of Amun. The new name signalled his return to the old religion and the restoration of Amun's worship.

Carter: criticised, but with little choice

Judging Howard Carter

  • Why he is criticised
    • The mummy is in bad condition because of his work
    • He heated it in the sun to loosen resins
    • His men chiselled it free, removed the head and cut major joints
  • Why he had little choice
    • The hardened resins cemented the mummy to its gold coffin
    • If left, thieves would get past the guards and rip it apart for gold
    • He recorded the treasures carefully for months

How archaeology has changed

In Carter's time, archaeology focused on treasure. Today it focuses more on the details of everyday life and the mysteries of death, and uses medical technology. The chapter shows the steps: the X-ray of 1968 revealed missing ribs; the CT scan of 2005 produced detailed 3-D images and precise data for a forensic reconstruction of Tut's face. The Egyptian Mummy Project, begun in late 2003, had recorded almost 600 mummies and planned to scan them with the same portable machine. That is why the writer says Tut, scanned among the first, moved ahead of his people in death as in life.

What the scan showed (as far as the chapter goes)

The account describes the immediate result: astonishing images on a computer screen of Tut's head, neck vertebrae, a hand, the rib cage and a cross-section of the skull, clear enough to rotate in every direction, along with data for a reconstruction. The specialists in radiology, forensics and anatomy then began their study. The chapter itself does not give their final conclusions about how he died, so do not add them from elsewhere in an answer on this text.

Themes and debates

Points are our own, to start a discussion.
Debate topic from the chapterOne point forOne point against
Scientific intervention is necessary to unearth buried mysteries.Only science can answer questions about disease, age and death.Repeated handling can damage remains and disturb what is sacred.
Advanced technology gives conclusive evidence.Scans give exact, measurable data.Images still need interpretation; experts can disagree.
Traditions and funerary practices must be respected.The dead and their beliefs deserve dignity.Careful study, done respectfully, need not insult tradition.
Knowledge of the past completes our knowledge of the world.History explains who we are today.Present problems may need resources more urgently.

Worked example: explaining a statement

Question: explain the idea that Tut was among the first mummies scanned, in death as in life. Working: as a king he went ahead of his subjects in life; now he is scanned before hundreds of other mummies. Answer: the writer playfully suggests Tut still keeps his royal position, leading the way even in death.

Name the change (Tutankhaten to Tutankhamun), give the reason (return to Amun), and link it to the history (Akhenaten's break with tradition).

Key takeaways: Akhenaten's religious revolution, Tut's restoration of Amun and his early death frame the story. Carter's rough methods damaged the mummy, though he feared thieves. Modern archaeology uses medical technology to study life and death, raising debates about science, respect and the value of the past.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which deed of Akhenaten made Ray Johnson call him 'wacky'?

    1. He attacked the god Amun, smashing images and closing temples.
    2. He discovered the Valley of the Kings.
    3. He reigned for only nine years.
    4. He was buried with no treasure.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Among his strange deeds, Akhenaten attacked Amun, a major god, smashing his images and closing his temples.

  2. 2. Why did the boy king change his name to Tutankhamun?

    1. To honour the sun disk
    2. To please Howard Carter
    3. Because his father ordered it
    4. To show his return to the worship of Amun
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Tutankhamun means living image of Amun; the change marked a restoration of the old religion that Akhenaten had attacked.

  3. 3. Why was Carter's investigation resented?

    1. He refused to open the tomb.
    2. His team damaged the mummy by chiselling it free and cutting it apart.
    3. He sold the treasures.
    4. He kept no records.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The mummy is in very bad condition because Carter's team heated it, chiselled it from the coffin, removed the head and severed joints.

  4. 4. What did the 1968 X-ray reveal?

    1. That the breastbone and front ribs were missing
    2. Tut's exact age
    3. A hidden room
    4. The cause of death
    Show answer

    Answer: A. An anatomy professor X-rayed the mummy in 1968 and found that the breastbone and front ribs were missing beneath the resin.

  5. 5. How has archaeology changed since Carter's time, according to the chapter?

    1. It focuses only on gold.
    2. It no longer studies mummies.
    3. It focuses more on details of life and death and uses medical technology.
    4. It uses only digging tools.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says archaeology now focuses less on treasure and more on life and death, using sophisticated tools such as X-ray and CT.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery