- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing and speaking: a debate on science and the past
Prepare and deliver a debate on whether scientific study of ancient remains is necessary, using a correct format, rebuttals and evidence, with a worked model for each side.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Use the format of a debate: address, stand, arguments, rebuttal, conclusion.
- Build arguments with reasons and examples.
- Rebut an opponent politely and logically.
- Write a short formal paragraph giving a balanced view.
The chapter asks students to discuss four topics in pairs taking opposite sides. A debate is a formal speech either for or against a motion. Below we model both sides of the first motion. The speakers are made up.
Debate format
Parts of a debate speech
- Address Greet the chair, judges, opponents and audience.
- Motion and stand State the motion and whether you are for or against it.
- Arguments Two or three points, each with a reason and example.
- Rebuttal Answer the other side's strongest point.
- Conclusion Restate your stand forcefully and thank the audience.
Worked example 1: speaking FOR the motion (written for this lesson)
*Respected chairperson, honourable judges, my worthy opponents and dear friends, I am Meher (a made-up speaker), and I stand firmly in favour of the motion: Scientific intervention is necessary to unearth buried mysteries. / First, science gives answers that guesses cannot. For decades people imagined murder, curses and poison around a boy king's death. Only careful imaging could test those stories against evidence. / Second, modern methods are gentler than the old ones. A scanner looks inside a body without cutting it; in Tutankhamun's case the mummy was out of its tomb for under three hours. / Third, knowledge of the past belongs to all humanity. It shows how people lived, fell ill and healed. / My opponents will say this disturbs the dead. But leaving mysteries unsolved does not honour the dead; understanding them does. I urge you to support the motion. Thank you.*
Worked example 2: speaking AGAINST the motion (written for this lesson)
*Respected chairperson, honourable judges, my worthy opponents and dear friends, I am Kabir (a made-up speaker), and I strongly oppose the motion. / First, history shows that intervention can harm. Tutankhamun's mummy was badly damaged in the 1920s by those who wanted to study and strip it. / Second, every culture has beliefs about rest after death. Repeatedly lifting a body from its resting place for tests may offend those beliefs. / Third, science rarely gives the final word: images must be interpreted, and experts often disagree. / My opponents say scanners are gentle. But each new technology brings another excuse to disturb the dead. Some mysteries may be better left with dignity than solved at any cost. I urge you to reject the motion. Thank you.*
| Feature | For | Against |
|---|---|---|
| Main idea | Evidence replaces guesswork | Respect and harm outweigh curiosity |
| Example used | Short, non-invasive CT scan | Damage done in the 1920s |
| Rebuttal | Unsolved mystery does not honour the dead | New tools invite more disturbance |
A balanced paragraph
Sometimes you are asked for your own view rather than one side. Model (written for this lesson): Scientific study of ancient remains can answer questions that legends cannot, and modern scanners do far less harm than the crude methods of the past. Yet the dead were once people with beliefs, and their resting places deserve respect. The best course is careful study by experts, with minimal handling, clear purpose and the consent of the country and community concerned.
Address, stand, arguments with examples, rebuttal, conclusion. Be firm but courteous: attack the argument, never the person.
Key takeaways: a debate speech has a fixed shape; strong arguments pair a reason with an example; a good rebuttal answers the opponent's best point; a balanced paragraph weighs both sides and reaches a judgement.
Check your understanding
-
1. What comes immediately after the address in a debate speech?
- The conclusion
- The motion and your stand
- The rebuttal
- Thanks to the audience
Show answer
Answer: B. After greeting the audience, the speaker states the motion and whether they are for or against it.
-
2. What is a rebuttal?
- A greeting
- A list of sources
- A summary of the motion
- A reply that answers the opponent's argument
Show answer
Answer: D. A rebuttal answers and counters the other side's point, logically and politely.
-
3. Which argument supports the motion that scientific intervention is necessary?
- Science replaces guesswork about the past with evidence.
- The dead should never be disturbed.
- Experts always disagree.
- Old methods damaged mummies.
Show answer
Answer: A. Saying science replaces guesswork supports the motion. The other three are arguments against it.
-
4. Which is the most courteous way to disagree in a debate?
- My opponent knows nothing.
- That is a silly idea.
- My opponent raises a fair point, but the evidence suggests otherwise.
- I refuse to listen.
Show answer
Answer: C. Good debaters acknowledge the opponent and then counter the argument with evidence, without personal attacks.
-
5. A balanced paragraph should ______.
- present only one side
- avoid giving any view
- weigh both sides and reach a reasoned judgement
- use only questions
Show answer
Answer: C. A balanced answer considers both arguments and then gives a reasoned conclusion.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.