Revision notes

Chapter 5 The Tale of Melon City: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

The poem: a king, an arch and a melon

How the blame travels

  1. Chief of builders Blames the workmen.
  2. Workmen Blame the wrong size of the bricks.
  3. Masons Blame the architect.
  4. Architect Blames the king's own changes to the plans.
  5. Wisest man Blames the arch.
  6. Councillor Objects: the arch touched the king's head.
  7. The crowd Simply wants someone hanged; the king fits the noose.
WordMeaningExample sentence (written for this lesson)
placidcalm, not easily upsetThe placid lake reflected the hills.
edifyimprove someone's mind or characterThe exhibition was meant to edify young visitors.
thoroughfarea main road through a townThe parade moved slowly down the thoroughfare.
proclaimannounce publiclyDrums proclaimed the start of the festival.
ordainorder officiallyThe council ordained that the market close at sunset.
quaveringtrembling (of a voice)In a quavering voice the old man thanked us.
scaffolda platform for executions (also for building work)Workers stood on the scaffold to paint the wall.
heraldan official messenger who announces newsA herald read the king's message in the square.
decreean official orderBy decree, the holiday was extended.

Everyone passes the blame; the one man who changed the plans ends up in the noose; and a melon ends up on the throne.

Key takeaways: Vikram Seth retells, after Idries Shah, a comic tale of a king whose idea of justice leads to absurdity. The blame passes down and back up the chain until the king himself is hanged, and a melon is crowned by custom.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Characters and what they show about power

Character or groupQualitiesEvidence (in our own words)
The KingCalled just and calm, but vain, hasty, easily swayed and afraid of the crowdOrders hangings at once; keeps changing the target; postpones questions of guilt to please the crowd
Workmen, masons, architectSelf-protectiveEach shifts blame to someone else to save their own neck
The wisest manVery old, blind and lame, absurdly 'wise'Is carried to court; declares the arch must be hanged
The councillorFlattering, protocol-mindedObjects to hanging what touched the king's head
The ministersPractical, self-servingRelieved someone was hanged; at once arrange a new ruler by custom
The crowdRestless, hungry for spectacleMutters aloud until a hanging is arranged
The citizensContent as long as they are left aloneDo not mind a melon king if they keep peace and liberty

What the king is called and what he does

  • Called
    • Just
    • Placid
    • Wise enough to seek counsel
  • Does
    • Sentences before investigating
    • Flies into rage
    • Follows absurd advice and fears the mob

A ruler is judged by what he does, not by what he is called: the 'just and placid' king is neither.

Key takeaways: the king's justice is hasty and absurd; officials pass the blame; the 'wisest' man is foolish; ministers are practical and self-serving; the crowd wants spectacle; and the citizens want only peace and liberty, even under a melon.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Themes, humour and irony, and an unseen passage

Themes of The Tale of Melon City

  • Justice gone wrong
    • Punishment before inquiry
    • Guilt set aside for a show
  • Passing the blame
    • Each group blames the next
    • No one accepts responsibility
  • Power and the crowd
    • The ruler fears the mob
    • The ministers fear unrest
  • Blind custom
    • The idiot's word followed literally
    • A melon crowned with ceremony
  • Peace and liberty
    • People want to be left alone
    • Laissez-faire
Instance (described in our words)Why it is humorous or ironic
The arch meant to inspire people humiliates the kingSituational irony: the opposite of its purpose
The 'just and placid' king keeps ordering hangingsVerbal irony: the description contradicts the actions
The king nearly loses his head in angerPun: he later literally dies by hanging
The wisest man is chosen for his great age and proposes hanging an archAbsurd reasoning mocks false wisdom
The king, who changed the plans, alone fits the noosePoetic justice delivered by chance
The ministers cry both that the king is dead and long live the kingDark comedy from a traditional formula
A melon is crowned and carried reverently to the throneAbsurdity treated with solemn ceremony

Satire laughs at power: the arch humbles the king, the blame circles back to him, and a melon proves the easiest ruler of all.

Key takeaways: the poem satirises hasty justice, the passing of blame, rulers who fear crowds, and blind custom. Its humour comes from irony, puns and absurd logic delivered in a solemn tone. Laissez-faire is the ironic last word.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Language work: rhyming couplets, rhythm, passive voice and diction

How the verse form creates comedy

  • Rhyme
    • Predictable pairs make grim events sound jolly
    • Rhyme sometimes forced for fun
  • Rhythm
    • Quick four-beat lines
    • The tale rushes on like the hasty king
  • Brackets
    • Asides add sly comments
    • e.g. the wise man was carried, not walked
  • Repetition
    • Being just and placid repeated
    • Each repetition sounds more ironic
ActivePassive
The workmen built the arch.The arch was built by the workmen.
The guards measured each man.Each man was measured by the guards.
The ministers crowned a melon.A melon was crowned by the ministers.
The heralds will announce the custom.The custom will be announced by the heralds.

Rhyming couplets, a quick four-beat rhythm and solemn words for silly events: that is how Seth makes an old tale charming.

Key takeaways: the poem uses rhyming couplets in a brisk four-beat rhythm, bracketed asides and ironic repetition. Its formal diction applied to absurd events creates mock-solemn humour. The passive voice reports actions and can hide responsibility; people are hanged, things are hung.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Writing and speaking: narrating the tale, a speech and a verse tale

Prose tale and verse tale

  • Prose tale
    • Free sentences
    • Detail and description
    • Easier to add explanation
  • Verse tale
    • Rhyme and rhythm
    • Easy to remember and recite
    • Extra charm and humour
    • Many Indian languages have such traditions

Narrate in order with an ironic tone; speak with clear points and a close; write couplets that rhyme, run quickly and end with a twist.

Key takeaways: retell the tale in past-tense prose with reported speech. A speech on peace and liberty can draw on the king's mistakes. Your own couplets should rhyme in pairs, keep a quick rhythm and end with a twist that echoes the poem's irony.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery