- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The poem: a king, an arch and a melon
Know Vikram Seth and the source of The Tale of Melon City, and narrate the tale in order in your own words, with its key vocabulary.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who Vikram Seth is and where the poem comes from.
- Narrate the tale in your own words, in the right order.
- Explain how the blame passes from person to person.
- Use the poem's key words correctly.
The Tale of Melon City is a narrative poem by Vikram Seth, an Indian poet and novelist born in Calcutta (now Kolkata) in 1952, best known for the long novel A Suitable Boy and the novel in verse The Golden Gate. The poem comes from his collection Mappings, which the book dates to 1981. Seth notes that it is told after Idries Shah, a writer who retold traditional teaching stories; so the poet has turned an old tale into witty English verse.
The tale in our own words
A just and placid king orders a grand arch to be built over the main street to inspire the people. Riding under it, he knocks off his crown, because the arch is too low. He orders the chief builder hanged; the builder blames the workmen; they blame the size of the bricks; the masons blame the architect; the architect reminds the king that he himself changed the plans. Puzzled, the king asks the wisest man in the land, a very old man, who declares that the arch itself must hang. A councillor objects that one cannot shamefully hang what touched the king's head. The crowd grows restless and wants a hanging, so the noose is set up and people are measured. Only one man is tall enough to fit it: the king, who is hanged. By custom, the next person through the city gate must choose the new ruler. An idiot passes, answers 'a melon' as he does to every question, and a melon is crowned. The citizens do not mind, as long as they are left in peace and liberty.
How the blame travels
- Chief of builders Blames the workmen.
- Workmen Blame the wrong size of the bricks.
- Masons Blame the architect.
- Architect Blames the king's own changes to the plans.
- Wisest man Blames the arch.
- Councillor Objects: the arch touched the king's head.
- The crowd Simply wants someone hanged; the king fits the noose.
Words to know
| Word | Meaning | Example sentence (written for this lesson) |
|---|---|---|
| placid | calm, not easily upset | The placid lake reflected the hills. |
| edify | improve someone's mind or character | The exhibition was meant to edify young visitors. |
| thoroughfare | a main road through a town | The parade moved slowly down the thoroughfare. |
| proclaim | announce publicly | Drums proclaimed the start of the festival. |
| ordain | order officially | The council ordained that the market close at sunset. |
| quavering | trembling (of a voice) | In a quavering voice the old man thanked us. |
| scaffold | a platform for executions (also for building work) | Workers stood on the scaffold to paint the wall. |
| herald | an official messenger who announces news | A herald read the king's message in the square. |
| decree | an official order | By decree, the holiday was extended. |
Worked example 1: why is the king hanged?
Working: the crowd wants a hanging at once; the king, afraid of their mood, postpones questions of guilt; the noose is set high and only one man is tall enough to fit it, the king. Answer: not because he is guilty (though his changes to the plans did cause the problem), but because he alone fits the noose and the crowd demands that someone hang immediately.
Worked example 2: how is the melon chosen?
Working: the ministers proclaim the custom that the next man to pass the city gate chooses the ruler. An idiot passes; asked who should be king, he says 'a melon', his answer to every question, because he likes melons. Answer: a meaningless custom followed literally turns a melon into the king.
Everyone passes the blame; the one man who changed the plans ends up in the noose; and a melon ends up on the throne.
Key takeaways: Vikram Seth retells, after Idries Shah, a comic tale of a king whose idea of justice leads to absurdity. The blame passes down and back up the chain until the king himself is hanged, and a melon is crowned by custom.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who wrote The Tale of Melon City?
- Vikram Seth
- William Saroyan
- A.J. Cronin
- J.B. Priestley
Show answer
Answer: A. The poem is by Vikram Seth, from his collection Mappings.
-
2. Why does the king lose his crown?
- A thief steals it
- He throws it at the crowd
- The wind blows it away
- The arch was built too low and knocks it off
Show answer
Answer: D. Riding under the newly built arch, he loses his crown because the arch is too low.
-
3. Whom do the masons blame?
- The king
- The workmen
- The architect
- The bricks
Show answer
Answer: C. The quivering masons say it was the architect's fault.
-
4. What does the architect remind the king of?
- That the king made changes to the plans
- That he never paid
- That the bricks were too big
- That the arch was the wisest man's idea
Show answer
Answer: A. The architect points out that the king himself made amendments to the plans.
-
5. How is the new ruler chosen?
- By a vote of ministers
- By the wisest man
- By a contest
- By the custom that the next person through the city gate chooses
Show answer
Answer: D. The heralds proclaim the custom: the next to pass the city gate will choose the ruler.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.