- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Themes, humour and irony, and an unseen passage
Explain the poem's themes (justice, blame, power, custom, liberty), find instances of humour and irony, and practise an original passage in the same satirical style.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the poem's main themes with evidence.
- Find instances of humour and irony, as the book asks.
- Explain 'laissez-faire' and its use at the end.
- Answer questions on an original satirical passage.
Themes
Themes of The Tale of Melon City
-
Justice gone wrong
- Punishment before inquiry
- Guilt set aside for a show
-
Passing the blame
- Each group blames the next
- No one accepts responsibility
-
Power and the crowd
- The ruler fears the mob
- The ministers fear unrest
-
Blind custom
- The idiot's word followed literally
- A melon crowned with ceremony
-
Peace and liberty
- People want to be left alone
- Laissez-faire
Humour and irony
| Instance (described in our words) | Why it is humorous or ironic |
|---|---|
| The arch meant to inspire people humiliates the king | Situational irony: the opposite of its purpose |
| The 'just and placid' king keeps ordering hangings | Verbal irony: the description contradicts the actions |
| The king nearly loses his head in anger | Pun: he later literally dies by hanging |
| The wisest man is chosen for his great age and proposes hanging an arch | Absurd reasoning mocks false wisdom |
| The king, who changed the plans, alone fits the noose | Poetic justice delivered by chance |
| The ministers cry both that the king is dead and long live the king | Dark comedy from a traditional formula |
| A melon is crowned and carried reverently to the throne | Absurdity treated with solemn ceremony |
Laissez-faire
The poem ends by saying that the principles of laissez-faire seem well established in Melon City. The French phrase means roughly 'let (people) do', the idea that rulers should interfere as little as possible. The joke is that a melon is the perfect laissez-faire ruler: it does nothing at all. The citizens' contentment raises a real question the book asks: how can peace and liberty be maintained in a state? Perhaps less by dramatic rulers than by fair laws and freedom from needless interference.
Practice passage: The Minister's Ring (written for this lesson)
In a certain kingdom, the story goes (this version is written for this lesson), a minister lost a gold ring in the palace garden. He ordered the gardener to find it. The gardener said the ring must have been carried off by a crow, so the minister ordered all the crows in the kingdom to be caught. The bird-catchers said that crows could not be caught without nets, and that the net-makers were too slow. The net-makers said the ropes were weak because the farmers had grown poor hemp. The farmers said there had been no rain. The minister sent a messenger to order the clouds to appear before him. While the messenger was on the road, a small boy, picking flowers in the garden, found the ring beside the path where the minister had stopped to tie his shoe. The boy brought it to the palace. The minister rewarded him, and then, to save face, announced that his orders had been a test of the kingdom's loyalty. Everyone praised his wisdom. The clouds, it is said, never answered.
Worked example 1: a comprehension answer
Question: how was the ring really found? Working: look for the boy: he found it beside the path where the minister had stopped to tie his shoe. Answer: A small boy picking flowers found it beside the path where the minister himself had stopped. The irony: the minister lost it himself, while blaming crows, nets, farmers and clouds.
Worked example 2: comparing the passage and the poem
Question: what do the minister and the king have in common? Working: both act before inquiring, both create a chain of blame that moves further from the truth, and both are themselves the cause of the problem (the king's plan changes; the minister's shoe-tying stop). Difference: the king pays with his life; the minister saves face and is praised. Answer: Both blame others for their own mistakes; the poem punishes its ruler by chance, while the passage shows a ruler escaping through a clever excuse.
Satire laughs at power: the arch humbles the king, the blame circles back to him, and a melon proves the easiest ruler of all.
Key takeaways: the poem satirises hasty justice, the passing of blame, rulers who fear crowds, and blind custom. Its humour comes from irony, puns and absurd logic delivered in a solemn tone. Laissez-faire is the ironic last word.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the situational irony of the arch?
- It is made of gold
- It falls down
- It is never built
- Built to inspire people, it humiliates the king by knocking off his crown
Show answer
Answer: D. The arch was meant to edify spectators, but its first effect is to make the king lose his crown.
-
2. What does 'laissez-faire' mean?
- Strict control by the ruler
- The idea that rulers should interfere as little as possible
- A French dish
- A kind of arch
Show answer
Answer: B. It means letting people act freely, with minimal interference; a melon, doing nothing, fits perfectly.
-
3. Which line of action contains a pun about the king?
- He nearly lost his head in anger, and later is hanged
- He rode down the thoroughfare
- He summoned the masons
- He asked for counsel
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Lost his head' means lost his temper, and also foreshadows his death, which is a pun.
-
4. In the passage written for this lesson, whom does the minister first blame for the lost ring?
- A small boy
- The farmers
- The gardener's explanation leads him to blame a crow
- Himself
Show answer
Answer: C. The gardener says a crow must have taken it, and the minister orders all crows caught.
-
5. How does the minister save face at the end of the passage?
- He resigns
- He says his orders were a test of loyalty
- He blames the boy
- He leaves the kingdom
Show answer
Answer: B. He rewards the boy and then claims his orders were a test, and everyone praises him.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.