- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
The first order: clergy, monks and the Church in society
Describe the power of the Catholic Church, who could become a priest, the tithe, the borrowing of feudal customs, monastic life and its critics, and how Christian practice blended with older beliefs.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why the Church was powerful and describe the rules and income of the clergy.
- Describe monasteries, monastic rules, nuns and friars, and the criticism of monasticism.
- Explain how Christian festivals, parishes and pilgrimage fitted into older customs.
The clergy placed themselves in the first order. This lesson explains why the Church was so powerful, how monks and nuns lived, and how Christianity shaped - and was shaped by - everyday life.
A powerful Church
With laws of its own, land granted by rulers and the right to tax, the Catholic Church was a mighty institution independent of the king. The Pope, in Rome, headed the western Church. Christians were guided by bishops and clerics, who made up the first order. Most villages had a church where people gathered every Sunday for the priest's sermon and prayers.
Not everyone could become a priest: serfs were barred, as were the physically challenged, and women could not become priests. Priests could not marry. Bishops formed a religious aristocracy, enjoying huge estates and splendid palaces just as lords did. The Church could claim the tithe - one-tenth of a peasant's yearly produce - and also received endowments from wealthy people seeking spiritual benefit for themselves and their dead relatives.
Sources of the Church's power
- Its own laws The Church had its own legal system.
- Land Lands given by rulers; bishops used vast estates.
- Taxes and income The tithe (a tenth of peasants' produce) and endowments from the rich.
- Independence Did not depend on the king; headed by the Pope in Rome.
Church ceremonies copied feudal customs. Kneeling to pray with hands clasped and head bowed was an exact replica of a knight taking his vow of loyalty to his lord, and God came to be called 'lord'. The religious and lay worlds of feudalism shared many customs and symbols.
Monks and nuns
Some deeply religious people chose isolated lives in religious communities called abbeys or monasteries, often far from human habitation, unlike clerics who lived among people. ('Monastery' comes from the Greek monos, one who lives alone; 'abbey' from the Syriac abba, father; an abbey was governed by an abbot or abbess.) Among the best known were St Benedict's monastery in Italy (529) and Cluny in Burgundy (910). A monk vowed to remain in his abbey for life, dividing his days between prayer, study and physical work such as farming. Unlike the priesthood, this life was open to both men and women - monks and nuns - in separate single-sex abbeys, except in a few cases; like priests, they did not marry.
Benedictine monasteries followed a manuscript of 73 chapters of rules for centuries. Among them: monks should rarely be allowed to speak; humility means obedience; no monk should own private property; idleness is the enemy of the soul, so time should be divided between manual labour and sacred reading; and the monastery should contain all necessities - water, mill, garden, workshops - within its bounds.
From small groups of 10 or 20, monasteries grew to communities of several hundred, with large buildings, estates, schools or colleges and hospitals. They contributed to the arts: Abbess Hildegard was a gifted musician who helped develop community singing of prayers. From the thirteenth century some monks, called friars, chose to move from place to place, preaching and living on charity. By the fourteenth century people had begun to doubt the worth of monastic life. In England, Langland's Piers Plowman (c. 1360-70) set the easy living of some monks against the sincere faith of ploughmen and labourers, while Chaucer's Canterbury Tales poked fun at a nun, a monk and a friar.
Priests, monks and friars
-
Priests (clerics)
- Lived among people in towns and villages
- Only men; could not marry
- Serfs and the physically challenged barred
-
Monks and nuns
- Lived in abbeys, often far from people
- Open to men and women, in separate abbeys
- Vows of prayer, study and manual labour
-
Friars (from 13th century)
- Not based in a monastery
- Moved from place to place preaching
- Lived on charity
The Church and society
Europeans became Christian but kept some older beliefs in magic and folk traditions. From the fourth century Christmas and Easter grew in importance. Christmas, on 25 December, took the place of an older pre-Roman festival whose date followed the solar calendar. Easter, marking Christ's crucifixion and resurrection, had no fixed date because it replaced an older spring festival dated by the lunar calendar. On that day villagers had traditionally toured their village lands; they continued to do so, but now called the village the parish (the area supervised by one priest). Overworked peasants welcomed holy days (holidays), meant for prayer but often spent feasting and having fun. Pilgrimage to shrines of martyrs or great churches was an important part of Christian life - Chaucer's tales follow pilgrims to Canterbury.
Worked example 1: calculating the tithe (made-up figures)
Question (illustrative numbers): a peasant family harvests 60 sacks of wheat, 20 sacks of barley and 10 barrels of cider in a year. What does the Church claim as tithe? Working: a tithe is one-tenth of produce. Wheat: 60 ÷ 10 = 6 sacks; barley: 20 ÷ 10 = 2 sacks; cider: 10 ÷ 10 = 1 barrel. Answer: 6 sacks of wheat, 2 sacks of barley and 1 barrel of cider - before any dues to the lord, which shows how heavily peasants were burdened.
Worked example 2: why does Easter move?
Question: why does Christmas fall on a fixed date but Easter does not? Working: (1) Christmas replaced a pre-Roman festival whose date was calculated by the solar calendar, which matches the solar year, so the date stays fixed at 25 December; (2) Easter replaced a spring festival dated by the lunar calendar, and lunar months do not line up with the solar year, so its date changes each year. Answer: each Christian festival inherited the calendar of the older festival it replaced.
The Church: its own laws, its own land, the right to tax (the tithe, a tenth of produce), and independence from the king. Monks and nuns vowed prayer, study and manual labour; friars preached and lived on charity.
Key takeaways: the Catholic Church, headed by the Pope, had its own laws, lands and taxes and did not depend on the king. Priesthood was closed to serfs and women, priests could not marry, and bishops lived like nobles; the Church took the tithe and endowments, and borrowed feudal rituals. Monasteries such as St Benedict's (529) and Cluny (910) followed strict rules, grew large and supported the arts; friars appeared in the thirteenth century; critics such as Langland and Chaucer questioned monasticism by the fourteenth. Christian festivals absorbed older ones, and pilgrimage was important.
Check your understanding
-
1. The 'tithe' was:
- a tax paid by nobles to the king
- a tenth share of what peasants produced, paid to the Church
- a fee paid by knights to lords
- the rent paid by townspeople
Show answer
Answer: B. The Church was entitled to a tenth share of whatever peasants produced from their land over the year, called a tithe.
-
2. Which practice of the Church was an exact replica of the way a knight took vows of loyalty to his lord?
- Kneeling to pray with hands clasped and head bowed
- Going on pilgrimage
- Celebrating Christmas on 25 December
- Ringing church bells
Show answer
Answer: A. Praying on one's knees with joined hands and lowered head reproduced exactly the posture of a knight swearing loyalty to his lord.
-
3. Monasteries were established by St Benedict in Italy and at Cluny in Burgundy in, respectively:
- 910 and 529
- 800 and 1066
- 529 and 910
- 1100 and 1200
Show answer
Answer: C. St Benedict established a monastery in Italy in 529, and the monastery of Cluny in Burgundy was founded in 910.
-
4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'The brothers of the poor road own nothing. They walk from village to village, preach in the market square, and eat whatever bread is given them.' Which group does this describe?
- Bishops
- Benedictine monks
- Knights
- Friars
Show answer
Answer: D. From the thirteenth century, friars were monks who did not live in a monastery; they wandered from place to place, preaching and depending on alms.
-
5. Assertion (A): The date of Easter was not fixed. Reason (R): Easter replaced an older spring festival that was dated by the lunar calendar.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Because Easter took the place of an older festival calculated by the lunar calendar, its date changes every year. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.