• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Towns, the crisis of the fourteenth century and new monarchies

Explain the growth of population, towns and guilds as a 'fourth order', describe cathedral-towns, analyse the fourteenth-century crisis and the peasant revolts, and explain the rise of the new monarchies in France and England.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why towns grew from the eleventh century and why townspeople can be called a fourth order.
  • Analyse the three causes of the fourteenth-century crisis and the consequences of the Black Death.
  • Explain the new monarchies and the different political paths of France and England.

Agricultural expansion brought growth in population, trade and towns, and a new group that fitted none of the three orders. Then, in the fourteenth century, crisis struck. This lesson follows both, and ends with the rise of powerful new monarchies.

A fourth order? Towns and townspeople

Europe's population grew from about 42 million in 1000 to 62 million around 1200 and 73 million in 1300. Because people ate better, they lived longer: the book says that by the thirteenth century an ordinary European lived about ten more years than in the eighth century - though women and girls died younger than men, who got the better food. Roman towns had decayed after Rome's fall, but from the eleventh century towns grew again. Peasants with surplus grain needed places to sell and to buy tools and cloth, so periodic fairs and small markets developed town-like features: a square, a church, merchants' shops and homes, and an office for the town's governors. Other towns grew around large castles, bishops' estates or big churches.

In towns people paid a tax to the lord who owned the land instead of services. Towns offered paid work and freedom from the lord's control - hence the saying 'town air makes free'. A serf who hid in a town for one year and one day without being discovered became free. Townspeople included free peasants and escaped serfs who did unskilled work, many shopkeepers and merchants, and later specialists such as bankers and lawyers. The bigger towns had about 30,000 people. They could be said to form a 'fourth' order.

Economic life was organised through the guild: each craft or industry had an association that controlled the quality, price and sale of its product. Every town had a guild-hall for ceremonies and meetings of guild heads. By the eleventh century new trade routes to West Asia were developing; Scandinavian merchants exchanged furs and hunting-hawks for cloth, and English traders sold tin. Craftsmen who once travelled between manors now settled in towns, and rich merchants came to rival the nobility.

Rich merchants donated to churches. From the twelfth century large churches called cathedrals were built in France. They belonged to monasteries, but many groups contributed labour, materials or money; built of stone over many years, they drew people around them and became pilgrimage centres, so small cathedral-towns grew up. They were designed so that the priest's voice and monks' singing carried well and bells could be heard far away, and their stained-glass windows told Bible stories in pictures that illiterate people could 'read'.

Europe's population, 1000-1400
YearPopulation of Europe (according to the textbook)
1000About 42 million
About 120062 million
130073 million
140045 million (after the Black Death and later plagues)

The crisis of the fourteenth century

By the early fourteenth century Europe's expansion slowed, for three reasons. First, climate and soil: after three centuries of warm summers, northern Europe had very cold summers by the late thirteenth century; the season for crops became a month shorter, high ground could no longer be farmed well, and storms and sea floods wrecked farms. Earlier land clearance without soil conservation had exhausted the soil despite the three-field system, and loss of pasture reduced cattle. Population outstripped resources: severe famines in 1315-17 were followed by massive cattle deaths in the 1320s. Second, money: the silver mines of Austria and Serbia produced less, so coins ran short and governments put less silver into them, adding cheaper metals. Third, plague: ships arriving from distant lands brought rats carrying bubonic plague (the Black Death), which struck western Europe in 1347-50. A modern estimate is that 20 per cent of Europe's people died, some places losing 40 per cent.

Causes of the fourteenth-century crisis

  • Environment and soil
    • Bitterly cold summers; growing season cut by a month
    • Soil exhausted by intensive ploughing
    • Famines 1315-17; cattle deaths in the 1320s
  • Shortage of money
    • Less silver from mines in Austria and Serbia
    • Coins debased with cheaper metals
  • Black Death
    • Plague brought by rats on trading ships
    • 1347-50; about 20 per cent of Europe died
    • Further outbreaks in the 1360s and 1370s

Cities, as trade centres, were hit hardest; in closed communities such as monasteries, plague often killed everyone. It struck infants, the young and the old worst. After further outbreaks in the 1360s and 1370s, Europe's population fell from 73 million in 1300 to 45 million in 1400. Depopulation caused a labour shortage: farm prices fell because there were fewer buyers, while wages rose - in England the demand for agricultural labour rose by as much as 250 per cent, and surviving workers could demand twice their earlier wages.

Social unrest

Lords' incomes fell as prices dropped and wages rose. In desperation they tried to abandon money-contracts and revive labour-services, which peasants - especially the better-educated and more prosperous - violently opposed. Peasants revolted in Flanders (1323), France (1358) and England (1381). The revolts were ruthlessly crushed, but they were most intense where people had prospered in the expansion, showing that peasants were defending earlier gains. The money economy was too advanced to reverse, so the old feudal relations could not be reimposed.

Political changes: the new monarchs

During the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries rulers built up their armies and finances; historians call them 'the new monarchs'. Examples include Louis XI (France), Maximilian (Austria), Henry VII (England) and Isabelle and Ferdinand (Spain). These absolute rulers started building permanent armies, a permanent civil service and taxes for the whole kingdom; Spain and Portugal also began to expand overseas. The decline of lordship and vassalage gave them their chance: they dropped feudal levies for professional infantry with guns and siege artillery under their own control. Higher taxes paid for larger armies, but taxation provoked opposition: England saw risings in 1497, 1536, 1547, 1549 and 1553, all put down; in France Louis XI (1461-83) spent years struggling with dukes and princes, and sixteenth-century religious wars were partly a contest between royal privilege and regional liberties.

The nobility survived by turning from opponents into loyalists, so royal absolutism has been called a modified form of feudalism: the same lords dominated politics, now with permanent administrative posts. But the king now sat at the centre of a courtier society and a network of patron-client relationships, and since patronage could be bought, merchants and bankers who lent kings money gained access to court. France and England then diverged. The French Estates-General, with three houses for clergy, nobility and the rest, met in 1614 under the child-king Louis XIII and was not summoned again until 1789. In England, the Anglo-Saxon Great Council grew into Parliament (House of Lords and House of Commons). Charles I ruled for 11 years (1629-40) without it; when forced to call it for money, part of Parliament went to war against him, executed him and set up a republic. Monarchy was soon restored, on condition that Parliament met regularly.

France and England after the new monarchies

  • France
    • Estates-General met in 1614
    • Not summoned again until 1789
    • Kings would not share power with the three orders
  • England
    • Great Council developed into Parliament
    • Charles I ruled without it, 1629-40
    • Civil war, execution, republic; monarchy restored with regular Parliaments

Worked example 1: measuring population change

Question: Europe's population was 73 million in 1300 and 45 million in 1400. By what percentage did it fall? Working: fall = 73 − 45 = 28 million; percentage = (28 ÷ 73) × 100 ≈ 38.4 per cent. Answer: a fall of about 38 per cent in a century - larger than the 20 per cent estimate for the Black Death alone, because of famine and later outbreaks in the 1360s and 1370s.

Worked example 2: why did wages rise after the Black Death?

Question: explain, step by step, why wages rose and farm prices fell after 1350. Working: (1) the plague killed a large share of the population; (2) fewer workers meant employers competed for labour, so wages rose (workers could demand twice their earlier wages); (3) fewer people also meant fewer buyers of food, so agricultural prices fell; (4) lords, squeezed between falling income and rising costs, tried to revive labour-services, provoking revolts. Answer: a labour shortage pushed wages up and weak demand pushed prices down, which hurt lords and set off social conflict.

Fourteenth-century crisis = colder climate and exhausted soil + shortage of silver money + Black Death (1347-50). Result: labour shortage, higher wages, lower prices, failed attempts to restore labour-services, and peasant revolts.

Key takeaways: better farming raised Europe's population to 73 million by 1300, and towns grew as markets, offering freedom ('town air makes free') to a 'fourth order' organised in guilds; cathedral-towns grew around great churches. Cold, exhausted soil, a silver shortage and the Black Death caused a crisis; population fell to 45 million by 1400. Wages rose, prices fell, and revolts in 1323, 1358 and 1381 stopped the return of feudal services. New monarchs built standing armies, bureaucracies and taxes; France's Estates-General lapsed after 1614, while England's Parliament checked its kings.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A serf who hid in a town without being discovered by his lord became free after:

    1. one month
    2. forty days
    3. one year and one day
    4. seven years
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 'Town air makes free' was a popular saying; a serf who stayed in a town for one year and one day without his lord discovering him became a free man.

  2. 2. Severe famines hit Europe in:

    1. 1347-50
    2. 1315-17
    3. 1381
    4. 1066
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Severe famines struck Europe between 1315 and 1317, followed by massive cattle deaths in the 1320s. 1347-50 was the Black Death.

  3. 3. Which of the following was NOT one of the causes of the fourteenth-century crisis described in the chapter?

    1. Bitterly cold summers and exhausted soil
    2. Shortage of silver from mines in Austria and Serbia
    3. The bubonic plague
    4. The invention of the three-field system
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The crisis came from climate change and soil exhaustion, a shortage of metal money, and the Black Death. The three-field system was an earlier improvement that had raised food production.

  4. 4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'Half the reapers in our parish are in the churchyard. Those who are left will not cut the lord's corn for the old penny; they ask two, and the lord must pay or let the crop rot.' Which consequence of the Black Death does it illustrate?

    1. Labour shortage led to higher wages
    2. Agricultural prices rose sharply
    3. Lords easily revived labour-services
    4. Population grew rapidly
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Depopulation created a major shortage of labour; demand for agricultural labour rose sharply and surviving workers could demand twice their earlier wages.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Royal absolutism in Europe has been called a modified form of feudalism. Reason (R): The same class of lords who had ruled under feudalism continued to dominate politics, now as loyalists holding permanent administrative positions.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. The nobility shifted from opposing the new regimes to serving them, so the old ruling class stayed dominant - which is why absolutism is called a modified feudalism. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery