- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Encounters and mutual perceptions in North America
Describe the early trade between Europeans and native peoples, how each saw the other and the goods they exchanged, and how settlers' views of land and forests clashed with native views.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the trade in fish and furs and the goods exchanged between Europeans and natives.
- Compare European and native ideas of civilisation, exchange and nature, with the views of Rousseau, Wordsworth and Washington Irving.
- Explain why settlers came and how their idea of land differed from that of the natives.
First contact between Europeans and North America's native peoples was largely friendly and commercial. But the two sides understood exchange, nature and civilisation in very different ways, and those differences grew into conflict as settlers followed traders.
Trade in fish and furs
When seventeenth-century European traders landed on North America's northern coast after a gruelling two-month crossing, they were relieved to be welcomed by the native peoples. Unlike the Spanish in South America, dazzled by gold, these traders came for fish and furs, and natives, expert hunters, helped them willingly. Along the Mississippi, the French found natives holding regular gatherings to exchange crafts and foods unique to each tribe. In return for local products, Europeans gave blankets, iron vessels (sometimes used in place of clay pots), guns (a useful supplement to bows and arrows for hunting) and alcohol. Natives had not known alcohol and became addicted, which let Europeans dictate the terms of trade; Europeans in turn acquired an addiction to tobacco from the natives.
| Europeans gave | Natives gave | Each side acquired an addiction to |
|---|---|---|
| Blankets and iron vessels | Furs | Natives: alcohol |
| Guns | Fish | Europeans: tobacco |
| Alcohol | Help in hunting | - |
| Year | Event (from the chapter) |
|---|---|
| 1497 | John Cabot reaches Newfoundland |
| 1507 | Amerigo Vespucci's Travels published |
| 1534 | Jacques Cartier travels down the St Lawrence and meets native peoples |
| 1607 | British found the colony of Virginia |
| 1608 | French found the colony of Quebec |
| 1620 | British found Plymouth in Massachusetts |
How each side saw the other
In the eighteenth century, western Europeans defined 'civilised' people by literacy, organised religion and urbanism, so natives appeared 'uncivilised'. Some, like the French philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, admired such people as untouched by the corruptions of civilisation - the popular idea of the 'noble savage'. The English poet William Wordsworth, who had never met a native American, implied that people who lived near to nature had little scope for imagination or refined feeling. The younger writer Washington Irving, who had actually met native people, described them differently: quiet among white men whom they distrusted, but lively mimics who laughed at the whites among themselves, while white men often treated them as little better than animals.
European views of native Americans
-
Rousseau
- Admired natives as untouched by civilisation's corruptions
- The 'noble savage'
- Had never met a native American
-
Wordsworth
- Thought people close to nature had limited imagination and emotion
- Had never met a native American
-
Washington Irving
- Had met native people
- Saw them as lively, humorous mimics among themselves
- Criticised how white men treated them
The two sides also understood exchange differently. For natives, goods exchanged were gifts given in friendship. For Europeans dreaming of wealth, fish and furs were commodities to sell for profit in Europe, their prices varying with supply. Natives, with no sense of a distant market, were puzzled that traders sometimes gave a lot and sometimes very little. They were saddened by European greed: in their haste for furs, traders slaughtered hundreds of beavers, and natives feared the animals would take revenge. Native folk tales mocked Europeans as greedy and deceitful, though Europeans understood the references only much later.
To the natives, exchanged goods were gifts that sealed friendship; to the Europeans, they were commodities to be sold for profit in a distant market.
Settlers and the land
Traders were followed by settlers. From the seventeenth century, groups of Europeans persecuted for their form of Christianity - Protestants in Catholic countries, Catholics in Protestant ones - left for America to begin new lives. While land was vacant this caused no problem, but settlers gradually moved inland near native villages and used iron tools to clear forests for farms. Natives and Europeans saw different things in a forest: natives saw tracks invisible to Europeans, while Europeans imagined the trees replaced by cornfields. Thomas Jefferson, third President of the USA, dreamt of a country of Europeans on small farms. Natives farmed only for their own use, never for the market, and believed land could not rightly be owned; this vision made no sense to them, and that, for Jefferson, proved them 'uncivilised'.
From trade to settlement
- Traders arrive (17th century) Friendly exchange of fish and furs for European goods.
- Alcohol and unequal terms Europeans dictate trade; beavers slaughtered.
- Settlers follow Religious refugees seek new lives in America.
- Forests cleared Settlers move inland near native villages and lay out farms.
- Clash of ideas about land Ownership and profit versus use and sharing.
Worked example 1: two views of one exchange
Question: a native hunter gives a European trader ten beaver pelts and receives a blanket and an iron pot. Describe the exchange from each side. Working: (1) for the native it is a gift exchange that confirms friendship between the two; (2) for the trader the pelts are commodities he will sell in Europe at a price set by supply and demand; (3) next year the trader may offer much less if furs are plentiful in Europe, which the native, knowing nothing of that market, finds puzzling. Answer: the same act meant friendship to one side and profit to the other - a root of later mistrust.
Worked example 2: judging a source by its author
Question: why might a historian trust Washington Irving's description of native Americans more than Wordsworth's? Working: (1) Wordsworth, like Rousseau, had never met a native American, so he wrote from imagination; (2) Irving had actually met native people and reported what he saw, including their humour among themselves; (3) eyewitness accounts can still be biased, so Irving should also be checked. Answer: Irving's account rests on direct observation, while Wordsworth's rests on an idea of people 'close to nature'.
Key takeaways: seventeenth-century traders found natives welcoming and traded blankets, iron vessels, guns and alcohol for fish and furs; alcohol let Europeans dictate terms. Europeans judged civilisation by literacy, religion and towns; Rousseau idealised the 'noble savage', Wordsworth imagined natives as limited, and Irving, who met them, saw them as lively and ill-treated. Natives saw exchange as gift-giving, Europeans as commerce. Settlers, many fleeing religious persecution, cleared forests for farms, and Jefferson's vision of European small farms clashed with natives' refusal to own land.
Check your understanding
-
1. European traders on the north coast of North America in the seventeenth century came mainly to trade in:
- gold and silver
- fish and furs
- spices and silk
- cotton and sugar
Show answer
Answer: B. These traders were after fish and furs, not gold as the Spanish in South America had been, and skilled native hunters helped them.
-
2. Which item obtained from Europeans did natives become addicted to, allowing Europeans to dictate the terms of trade?
- Iron vessels
- Blankets
- Tobacco
- Alcohol
Show answer
Answer: D. Natives had not known alcohol and became addicted to it, which enabled Europeans to dictate terms of trade. Europeans acquired an addiction to tobacco from the natives.
-
3. Eighteenth-century western Europeans judged whether a people was 'civilised' by:
- literacy, organised religion and urbanism
- hunting skill and courage
- the number of horses owned
- the ability to read the land
Show answer
Answer: A. Western Europeans defined civilised people by literacy, an organised religion and urbanism, so the natives of America appeared 'uncivilised' to them.
-
4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'The trader gave us much cloth last spring for our furs, and this spring he gives only half as much for the same furs. Has our friendship grown smaller?' What does this show?
- Natives fully understood European markets
- Natives sold furs only for money
- Natives saw exchange as friendship and had no sense of the distant European market that set prices
- European prices never changed
Show answer
Answer: C. The prices of goods varied from year to year depending on supply in Europe; natives, who saw exchanges as gifts given in friendship, could not understand why traders sometimes gave a lot and sometimes very little.
-
5. Assertion (A): Jefferson regarded the native peoples as 'uncivilised'. Reason (R): Natives farmed for their own use rather than for profit, and believed land should not be owned.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Jefferson dreamt of a country of European small farms; because natives did not farm for profit or own land, he saw them as uncivilised. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.