• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Expansion of the USA and Canada and the loss of native lands

Explain how the USA and Canada expanded, how native peoples lost their lands and were confined to reservations, how gold, railways and industry transformed North America, and how native rights were later partly restored.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the territorial expansion of the USA and Canada, immigration, slavery and the Civil War.
  • Explain how native peoples lost their land, including the Cherokee case and the Trail of Tears, and how land-taking was justified.
  • Describe the Gold Rush, industrial growth and the later changes in native rights from the 1920s to 1982.

At the end of the eighteenth century, Canada and the USA covered only a fraction of their present area. In the next hundred years they expanded across the continent - and as the frontier moved west, native peoples were forced back.

A moving frontier

The USA acquired large areas by purchase - land in the south from France (the Louisiana Purchase, 1803) and Alaska from Russia - and by war, winning much of the south from Mexico. No one thought of asking the consent of the natives living there. The western frontier kept shifting, and natives were pushed back with it.

Landscapes changed drastically. Some British and French migrants were younger sons who would not inherit land at home; later waves from Germany, Sweden and Italy had lost their land to big farmers; Poles were glad to work the prairies, which reminded them of their steppes, and to buy huge properties cheaply. They cleared land and grew crops such as rice and cotton that could not grow in Europe and could be sold there. Wolves and mountain lions were hunted to extinction to protect farms, and settlers felt fully secure only after barbed wire was invented in 1873.

The south was too hot for Europeans to work outdoors, and enslaved natives in South America had died in large numbers, so plantation owners bought slaves in Africa. The slave trade was banned after protests, but Africans already in the USA, and their children, remained slaves. The northern states, not dependent on plantations, condemned slavery; in 1861-65 a war between the states was won by those supporting abolition. Slavery ended, though African Americans won civil liberties and an end to segregation in schools and transport only in the twentieth century. Canada's urgent problem was different: won by Britain from France in 1763, its French settlers demanded autonomy, a problem solved only in 1867 by making Canada a Confederation of autonomous states.

The native peoples lose their land

As settlement spread, natives were induced or forced to sign treaties selling their land at very low prices, and were sometimes cheated of more land or less money than promised. Even high officials saw nothing wrong in this. In Georgia, officials argued that the Cherokee were governed by state laws but could not enjoy citizens' rights - although the Cherokees had made the greatest effort of any native people to learn English and the American way of life. In 1832, US Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that the Cherokees were a distinct community with their own territory where Georgia's laws had no force, and had sovereignty in certain matters. But President Andrew Jackson, known for fighting privilege, refused to honour the judgment and ordered the army to evict the Cherokees to the 'Great American Desert'. Of the 15,000 forced to go, over a quarter died on the 'Trail of Tears'.

Those who took native land justified it by saying natives did not use land to the maximum, were 'lazy' because they did not produce crafts for the market, and would not learn English or dress 'correctly' - so they deserved to 'die out'. Prairies were cleared and bison killed off. Natives were pushed west onto land promised as theirs 'in perpetuity', and moved again if lead, gold or oil was found. Several tribes were forced to share one tribe's land, causing quarrels, and were locked into small areas called reservations, often land with which they had no connection. They fought back: the US army crushed rebellions from 1865 to 1890, and in Canada the Metis (people of mixed native-European descent) revolted between 1869 and 1885. In this period, from the 1840s, anthropology was introduced in North America to study 'primitive' communities, and some anthropologists predicted that natives would 'die out'. In 1854, Chief Seattle, asked to sign a treaty giving up land, replied that his people could not understand how the sky, air and water could be bought or sold, because every part of the earth was sacred to them.

How native peoples lost their land

  1. Treaties Land sold at very low prices; natives sometimes cheated.
  2. Legal rights ignored Marshall's 1832 judgment for the Cherokee refused by President Jackson.
  3. Forced removal Trail of Tears: over a quarter of 15,000 Cherokee died.
  4. Reservations Tribes confined to small areas, moved again if minerals were found.
  5. Resistance crushed US army ends rebellions (1865-90); Metis revolts in Canada (1869-85).

Gold, railways and industry

In the 1840s traces of gold were found in California, setting off the Gold Rush as thousands of Europeans hurried to make a quick fortune. Railways were built across the continent with thousands of Chinese workers: the USA's railway was completed by 1870 and Canada's by 1885. The Scottish-born industrialist Andrew Carnegie boasted that the American republic moved at express speed while old nations crept. In England, industry grew partly because small peasants lost land and moved to factories; in North America, industries grew to make railway equipment and farm machinery for large-scale agriculture. In 1860 the USA was an undeveloped economy; by 1890 it was the leading industrial power in the world. By 1890 the bison had almost been exterminated, ending the natives' hunting life, and by 1892 the USA's continental expansion was complete - there was no longer a 'frontier'. Soon afterwards the USA took Hawaii and the Philippines, becoming an imperial power itself.

Constitutional rights and the winds of change

The 'democratic spirit' of the independence struggle of the 1770s defined the USA against Old World monarchies, and its constitution protected the individual's 'right to property'. But democratic rights and property rights were only for white men. A Canadian native writer, Daniel Paul, argued in 2000 that Thomas Paine had used native societies as models of how society might be organised.

Things began to improve only from the 1920s. A survey directed by Lewis Meriam, published in 1928, showed the very poor health and education facilities on reservations. White sympathy for the natives produced the Indian Reorganisation Act of 1934, which let people on reservations purchase land and borrow money. In the 1950s and 1960s both the US and Canadian governments wanted to scrap special arrangements and make natives 'join the mainstream'; the natives rejected this. In the 1954 'Declaration of Indian Rights', several native peoples accepted US citizenship on condition that their reservations and traditions were not touched. In Canada, the government announced in 1969 that it would not recognise aboriginal rights; after well-organised native opposition, the Constitution Act of 1982 accepted existing aboriginal and treaty rights.

The winds of change
YearStep towards native rights (North America)
1928Meriam survey reveals poor health and education on reservations
1934Indian Reorganisation Act: natives on reservations may buy land and take loans
1954Declaration of Indian Rights: citizenship accepted on condition reservations and traditions are kept
1969Canadian government says it will not recognise aboriginal rights; natives organise opposition
1982Canada's Constitution Act accepts existing aboriginal and treaty rights

Worked example 1: the Trail of Tears

Question: of 15,000 Cherokees forced to leave, the chapter says over a quarter died. What is the minimum number of deaths this implies? Working: one quarter of 15,000 = 15,000 ÷ 4 = 3,750. 'Over a quarter' means more than 3,750. Answer: more than 3,750 people died - the human cost of a removal ordered in defiance of the Chief Justice's judgment.

Worked example 2: how fast did the USA industrialise?

Question: the chapter says the USA was an undeveloped economy in 1860 and the leading industrial power in the world in 1890. How long did this take, and what drove it? Working: 1890 − 1860 = 30 years. Drivers named in the chapter: (1) railways across the continent, completed by 1870, which created demand for railway equipment; (2) machinery for large-scale farming on cleared prairies; (3) labour from immigrants, including Chinese railway workers. Answer: about 30 years, driven by railways, farm machinery and immigrant labour - at the cost of native lands and the bison.

As the frontier moved west, natives were moved off their land by treaties, force and law ignored (the Trail of Tears, 1838 in the timeline), and confined to reservations. Rights began to return only with the 1934 Act in the USA and the 1982 Constitution Act in Canada.

Key takeaways: the USA expanded by purchase (Louisiana, Alaska) and war (Mexico), with no thought for native consent; immigrants turned prairies into farms, and the south relied on African slaves until the Civil War of 1861-65. Canada became a Confederation in 1867. Natives lost land through unfair treaties and force; President Jackson ignored Marshall's 1832 ruling, and over a quarter of 15,000 Cherokee died on the Trail of Tears. Reservations, the destruction of the bison and crushed rebellions followed. The Gold Rush and railways made the USA the leading industrial power by 1890. Native rights improved only from 1928-34 and, in Canada, 1982.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which US Chief Justice ruled in 1832 that the Cherokees were a distinct community in whose territory the laws of Georgia had no force?

    1. Andrew Jackson
    2. John Marshall
    3. Thomas Jefferson
    4. Lewis Meriam
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In 1832 Chief Justice John Marshall ruled that the Cherokees were a distinct community with sovereignty in certain matters; President Andrew Jackson refused to honour the judgment.

  2. 2. 'Reservations' in North America were:

    1. land set aside for European immigrants
    2. national parks for bison
    3. small areas, often unfamiliar to them, into which native tribes were confined
    4. military camps of the US army
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Natives were locked off in small areas called reservations, often land with which they had no earlier connection, and were moved again if minerals or oil were found.

  3. 3. By which year had the USA become the leading industrial power in the world, according to the chapter?

    1. 1860
    2. 1803
    3. 1934
    4. 1890
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In 1860 the USA had been an undeveloped economy; by 1890 it was the leading industrial power in the world.

  4. 4. Read this source, written for this lesson: 'We will become citizens of your country, but the land of our reservation stays ours, and no one will forbid our ceremonies.' Which development does it resemble?

    1. The Declaration of Indian Rights of 1954
    2. The Louisiana Purchase
    3. The Trail of Tears
    4. The Gold Rush
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Through the 1954 Declaration of Indian Rights, native peoples agreed to become US citizens only if their reservations and their traditions were left alone.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): In North America, industries developed to make railway equipment and farm machinery. Reason (R): Small peasants in North America were losing their land to big farmers and moving to factories.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: industries grew to manufacture railway equipment and machinery for large-scale farming. R is false for North America: the chapter gives peasants losing land to big farmers as a reason for industrialisation in England, and says North American industry developed for very different reasons.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery