- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Fayol's 14 principles and a comparison with Taylor
Explain Henri Fayol's fourteen principles of management with examples, distinguish unity of command from unity of direction, and compare the contributions of Fayol and Taylor.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State and explain Fayol's 14 principles of management.
- Distinguish unity of command from unity of direction, and explain scalar chain and gang plank.
- Compare Fayol and Taylor on perspective, focus, basis and applicability.
Henri Fayol (1841-1925) was a French mining engineer who served as managing director of a large mining company from 1888 to 1918. While Taylor improved the shop floor, Fayol explained what a manager's work is and what principles should guide it. He named the functions of management as plan, organise, command, coordinate and control, divided the activities of an industrial undertaking into technical, commercial, financial, security, accounting and managerial, and listed the qualities a manager needs (physical, moral, education, knowledge and experience). His book was published in English as General and Industrial Management in 1949, and he is called the Father of General Management.
The 14 principles
| Principle | Meaning in brief |
|---|---|
| 1. Division of work | Divide work into small tasks done by trained specialists; produces more and better work for the same effort |
| 2. Authority and responsibility | Authority (the right to give orders and get obedience) must match responsibility; guard against abuse of power |
| 3. Discipline | Obedience to organisational rules and the employment agreement; needs good superiors, clear and fair agreements and fair penalties |
| 4. Unity of command | Each employee receives orders from and is responsible to only one superior |
| 5. Unity of direction | Each group of activities with the same objective has one head and one plan |
| 6. Subordination of individual interest to general interest | The organisation's interest comes before any one person's interest |
| 7. Remuneration of employees | Pay fair to employees (a reasonable standard of living) and within the firm's capacity to pay |
| 8. Centralisation and decentralisation | Balance concentration of decision-making with its dispersal, as circumstances require |
| 9. Scalar chain | The formal line of authority and communication from the highest to the lowest rank |
| 10. Order | A place for everything and everyone, and everything and everyone in its place |
| 11. Equity | Kindliness and justice to all; no discrimination by gender, religion, language, caste, belief or nationality |
| 12. Stability of personnel | Minimise employee turnover; give staff a reasonable tenure to show results |
| 13. Initiative | Encourage workers to develop and carry out plans for improvement, e.g. through a suggestion system |
| 14. Esprit de corps | Promote team spirit, unity and harmony; say 'we' rather than 'I' |
A few points need more explanation. Under unity of command, Fayol warned that if an employee has two bosses, authority is undermined, discipline suffers, order is disturbed and stability is threatened; dual subordination should be avoided. Centralisation and decentralisation must be balanced: in general, large organisations have more decentralisation than small ones. Under equity, Fayol did not rule out firmness: lazy staff should be dealt with sternly so that all see they are treated equally. Under stability of personnel, frequent turnover raises the cost of recruitment, selection and training. Initiative does not mean going against established practice just to be different.
Unity of command and unity of direction
Unity of command and unity of direction
-
Unity of command
- Meaning: one subordinate gets orders from and reports to only one superior
- Aim: prevents dual subordination
- Affects an individual employee
-
Unity of direction
- Meaning: each group of activities with the same objective has one head and one plan
- Aim: prevents overlapping of activities
- Affects the entire organisation
Scalar chain and gang plank
Suppose head A has two lines of authority under her: B-C-D-E-F and L-M-N-O-P. If E must communicate with O, who is at the same level, the scalar chain route is E-D-C-B-A-L-M-N-O. Normally this chain should not be broken. In an emergency, Fayol allowed E to contact O directly through a gang plank, a shorter route so that communication is not delayed.
Fayol compared with Taylor
| Basis | Henri Fayol | F.W. Taylor |
|---|---|---|
| Perspective | Top level of management | Shop floor of a factory |
| Unity of command | Staunch supporter | Did not consider it important; under functional foremanship a worker had eight bosses |
| Applicability | Universal | Specialised situations |
| Basis of formation | Personal experience | Observation and experimentation |
| Focus | Improving overall administration | Increasing productivity |
| Personality | Practitioner | Scientist |
| Expression | General theory of administration | Scientific management |
The textbook stresses that their contributions are complementary: both form a basis for managers' practice.
Unity of command: one boss for each employee. Unity of direction: one head and one plan for each group of activities with the same objective. Gang plank: a direct link between equals in an emergency.
Worked example 1: identify the violated principle
Case (made up): at Sapphire Motors, a salesperson is told by the marketing manager that she may give up to 10 per cent discount, while the finance manager tells her not to exceed 5 per cent. She is confused and loses the deal. Reasoning: she is receiving conflicting orders from two superiors. Principle violated: unity of command.
Worked example 2: one head, one plan
Case (made up): a made-up company makes both bicycles and electric scooters, but one marketing plan and one manager handle both, so promotions overlap and clash. Advice: create two divisions, each with its own head, plan and resources. Principle: unity of direction.
Worked example 3: authority and responsibility
Case (made up): a sales manager of a made-up firm is responsible for winning a large order. The buyer wants 60 days' credit, but she is allowed to offer only 40 days, so the deal is at risk. Reasoning: she has responsibility for the deal without the matching authority. Principle at issue: authority and responsibility must be balanced.
Worked example 4: name the principle
(a) A manager is promoted, and she stops calling the team 'my staff' and starts saying 'our team'. (b) Tools in a workshop are kept on marked racks so no time is lost searching. (c) A supervisor in a made-up factory uses the gang plank to reach a supervisor of another department directly during a fire. Answer: (a) esprit de corps, (b) order, (c) scalar chain with the gang plank exception.
Key takeaways: Fayol's 14 principles are division of work, authority and responsibility, discipline, unity of command, unity of direction, subordination of individual interest, remuneration, centralisation and decentralisation, scalar chain, order, equity, stability of personnel, initiative and esprit de corps. Fayol looked at management from the top and Taylor from the shop floor; their contributions complement each other.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Each group of activities having the same objective must have one head and one plan.' This is the principle of:
- unity of command
- unity of direction
- scalar chain
- order
Show answer
Answer: B. Unity of direction requires one head and one plan for each group of activities with the same objective; it prevents overlapping of activities.
-
2. In Fayol's scalar chain, a gang plank is used to:
- replace the chain permanently
- let workers contact the CEO for any reason
- increase the number of levels
- allow direct communication between employees at the same level in an emergency
Show answer
Answer: D. The scalar chain should normally be followed, but in an emergency an employee may contact an equal in another line directly through the gang plank so that communication is not delayed.
-
3. Which statement correctly compares Fayol and Taylor?
- Fayol's principles were based on experiments; Taylor's on personal experience
- Fayol viewed management from the top level; Taylor from the shop floor
- Taylor was a staunch supporter of unity of command
- Both had the same focus: increasing shop-floor productivity
Show answer
Answer: B. Fayol's perspective was top management and his principles came from personal experience; Taylor's was the shop floor and his principles came from observation and experiment. Taylor did not consider unity of command important.
-
4. Case: a made-up company keeps changing its store managers every few months, so each new manager leaves before showing results, and recruitment and training costs rise. Which principle is violated?
- Stability of personnel
- Equity
- Initiative
- Discipline
Show answer
Answer: A. Stability of personnel says turnover should be minimised and staff given reasonable tenure to show results; frequent changes create insecurity and raise recruitment, selection and training costs.
-
5. Assertion (A): Fayol was a staunch supporter of unity of command. Reason (R): Fayol held that if an employee has two bosses, authority is undermined, discipline suffers, order is disturbed and stability is threatened.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because Fayol believed dual subordination causes these harms, he gave great importance to unity of command.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.