• Foundation
  • About 22 min
  • 5 practice questions

Expenditure and income methods; factor cost, basic prices and market prices

Derive GDP = C + I + G + X − M by the expenditure method and GDP = W + P + In + R by the income method, show with an example that all three methods agree, and relate GVA at factor cost, basic prices and market prices.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Calculate GDP by the expenditure method and explain each component, including why imports are subtracted.
  • Calculate GDP by the income method and verify that the three methods agree.
  • Distinguish production taxes from product taxes and convert GVA between factor cost, basic prices and market prices.

The product method measured national income at the point of production. The expenditure and income methods measure the same flow at the points of disposition (who buys final output) and distribution (who receives the income).

The expenditure method

This method adds up final expenditures - spending not made for intermediate purposes. A firm can receive final expenditure from four sources: (a) final consumption expenditure (C), mostly by households; (b) final investment expenditure (I) by other firms on its capital goods - included, because investment goods remain with the buyer, unlike intermediate goods that are used up; (c) government final expenditure (G), both consumption and investment; and (d) exports (X), spending by foreigners.

Part of the economy's total C, I and G is spent on imports (Cm, Im, Gm), which is revenue for foreign firms, not domestic ones. So domestic firms receive (C − Cm) + (I − Im) + (G − Gm) + X. Writing M = Cm + Im + Gm for total imports:

Expenditure method: GDP ≡ C + I + G + X − M. Income method: GDP ≡ W + P + In + R (wages, profits, interest, rent). Product method: GDP ≡ sum of GVA of all firms. All three are identical.

Of the components on the right-hand side, the book notes that investment expenditure (I) is the most unstable. In the identity, I includes both planned and unplanned investment (such as unplanned inventory changes).

Worked example 1: the expenditure method (illustrative)

A made-up economy's annual data (₹ crore): private consumption C = 600, investment I = 200, government expenditure G = 150, exports X = 80, imports M = 100. Working: GDP = 600 + 200 + 150 + 80 − 100 = ₹930 crore. If imports had been ignored, GDP would be overstated by ₹100 crore of spending that went to foreign producers.

The income method

The revenue that firms receive from final sales is distributed among factors of production as wages and salaries, profits, interest and rents. Summing these over all households gives GDP = W + P + In + R. (After wages are paid, the remainder of value added - rent, interest and profit together - is called the operating surplus.)

Worked example 2: all three methods agree (illustrative)

Two made-up firms: P, a rubber plantation, uses no inputs and produces latex worth ₹80, all sold to Q. Q makes tyres from the latex and sells them to households for ₹260. P pays ₹30 wages and ₹10 rent and keeps ₹40 profit. Q pays ₹100 wages and ₹20 interest and keeps ₹60 profit.

Three methods, one answer (illustrative)
MethodCalculationGDP (₹)
Product (value added)P: 80 − 0 = 80; Q: 260 − 80 = 180; 80 + 180260
ExpenditureOnly final spending: households buy tyres for 260260
IncomeWages 30 + 100 = 130; rent 10; interest 20; profit 40 + 60 = 100; total260

Check each firm: P's factor incomes 30 + 10 + 40 = 80 = its value added; Q's 100 + 20 + 60 = 180 = its value added. The latex (₹80) is intermediate, so it is not counted as final expenditure.

Three methods of measuring GDP

  • Product method
    • Phase of production
    • Sum of gross value added
    • Deduct intermediate goods
  • Expenditure method
    • Phase of disposition
    • C + I + G + X − M
    • Count only final expenditure
  • Income method
    • Phase of distribution
    • W + P + In + R
    • Sum of factor incomes

Factor cost, basic prices and market prices

The same output can be valued at three kinds of prices, depending on which taxes and subsidies are included. The distinction rests on two kinds of taxes:

  • Production taxes and subsidies are paid or received in relation to production and do not depend on the volume produced - for example land revenue, stamp and registration fees.
  • Product taxes and subsidies are paid or received per unit of product - for example excise duty, service tax, and export and import duties.
Three valuations
ValuationWhat it includesHow to get it
Factor costOnly payments to factors of production; no taxes-
Basic pricesFactor cost plus net production taxesGVA at factor cost + (production taxes − production subsidies)
Market pricesBasic prices plus net product taxes (prices as paid by buyers)GVA at basic prices + (product taxes − product subsidies)

According to the textbook, India's most highlighted measure used to be GDP at factor cost; in its January 2015 revision, the Central Statistics Office replaced it with GVA at basic prices, and GDP at market prices, now simply called GDP, became the most highlighted measure.

Worked example 3: converting between valuations (illustrative)

A made-up economy's GVA at factor cost is ₹1,000 crore. Production taxes are ₹50 crore and production subsidies ₹10 crore; product taxes are ₹140 crore and product subsidies ₹30 crore. Working: net production taxes = 50 − 10 = 40, so GVA at basic prices = 1,000 + 40 = ₹1,040 crore. Net product taxes = 140 − 30 = 110, so GVA at market prices = 1,040 + 110 = ₹1,150 crore.

Key takeaways: GDP ≡ C + I + G + X − M (expenditure) ≡ W + P + In + R (income) ≡ ΣGVA (product); investment is the most unstable component, and imports are subtracted because they are spending on foreign output. Production taxes do not depend on volume; product taxes are per unit. Factor cost + net production taxes = basic prices; basic prices + net product taxes = market prices.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the expenditure method, why are imports subtracted?

    1. Because imports are intermediate goods
    2. Because part of C, I and G is spent on foreign output, which is not domestic production
    3. Because imports are taxed
    4. Because imports are always larger than exports
    Show answer

    Answer: B. C, I and G include spending on imported goods. That spending is revenue for foreign firms, so M is subtracted to leave only spending on domestic output.

  2. 2. Illustrative data (₹ crore): C = 400, I = 120, G = 90, X = 60, M = 70. GDP is:

    1. ₹740 crore
    2. ₹670 crore
    3. ₹600 crore
    4. ₹540 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: C. GDP = C + I + G + X − M = 400 + 120 + 90 + 60 − 70 = ₹600 crore.

  3. 3. Which component of GDP does the book describe as the most unstable?

    1. Investment expenditure
    2. Consumption expenditure
    3. Government expenditure
    4. Wages
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The book notes that among C, I, G, X and M, investment expenditure is the most unstable.

  4. 4. GVA at basic prices is ₹2,000 crore; product taxes are ₹180 crore and product subsidies ₹40 crore (illustrative). GVA at market prices is:

    1. ₹2,180 crore
    2. ₹1,860 crore
    3. ₹2,220 crore
    4. ₹2,140 crore
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Net product taxes = 180 − 40 = ₹140 crore. GVA at market prices = 2,000 + 140 = ₹2,140 crore.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): A firm's purchase of a new machine from another firm is included in GDP by the expenditure method. Reason (R): Investment goods remain with the buyer and are not used up as intermediate goods in the year.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Unlike intermediate goods, investment goods stay with the firm and add to capital, so spending on them is final expenditure. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery