- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Nominal and real GDP, price indices, and GDP as a measure of welfare
Distinguish nominal from real GDP, calculate the GDP deflator and a consumer price index, explain how CPI and WPI differ from the GDP deflator, and give three reasons why GDP may not measure welfare.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Calculate nominal GDP, real GDP and the GDP deflator.
- Calculate a CPI and explain why CPI, WPI and the GDP deflator differ.
- Explain distribution, non-monetary exchanges and externalities as limits of GDP as a welfare index.
So far we assumed prices do not change. If GDP doubles in a year, has production doubled? Not necessarily: prices may have doubled while output stayed the same. To compare GDP across years or countries we need to separate changes in quantities from changes in prices.
Nominal and real GDP
Nominal GDP is GDP valued at the current prices of each year. Real GDP values each year's goods and services at a constant set of prices, those of a chosen base year. Since prices are held fixed, a change in real GDP reflects only a change in the volume of production.
GDP deflator = Nominal GDP ÷ Real GDP (or × 100 to express it as a percentage). Real GDP = quantities of the current year × prices of the base year.
Worked example 1: real GDP and the deflator (illustrative)
A made-up country produces only notebooks. In the base year it made 500 notebooks at ₹20 each; in the current year 540 notebooks at ₹25 each. Working: nominal GDP (base year) = 500 × 20 = ₹10,000. Nominal GDP (current year) = 540 × 25 = ₹13,500. Real GDP (current year, base-year prices) = 540 × 20 = ₹10,800. GDP deflator = 13,500 ÷ 10,800 = 1.25, or 125 per cent - prices are 1.25 times the base level, which matches ₹25 ÷ ₹20. Real growth = (10,800 − 10,000)/10,000 × 100 = 8 per cent, while nominal GDP grew 35 per cent; the difference is price rise.
Consumer Price Index
The Consumer Price Index (CPI) is the index of prices of a given basket of commodities bought by a representative consumer. We find the cost of the basket at base-year prices and at current-year prices, and express the second as a percentage of the first.
Worked example 2: a CPI (illustrative)
A representative consumer in a made-up economy buys 40 kg of wheat and 10 litres of cooking oil a year. Base-year prices: wheat ₹30 per kg, oil ₹150 per litre. Current-year prices: wheat ₹36, oil ₹165. Working: base-year cost = 40 × 30 + 10 × 150 = 1,200 + 1,500 = ₹2,700. Current-year cost = 40 × 36 + 10 × 165 = 1,440 + 1,650 = ₹3,090. CPI = 3,090 ÷ 2,700 × 100 ≈ 114.44: the same basket costs about 14.44 per cent more.
Wholesale prices and how the indices differ
Many goods have a retail price paid by consumers and a wholesale price at which goods are traded in bulk; they differ because of traders' margins. Goods traded in bulk, such as raw materials and semi-finished goods, are not bought by ordinary consumers. The index of wholesale prices is the Wholesale Price Index (WPI); in countries like the USA a similar index is called the Producer Price Index (PPI).
| Basis | CPI | GDP deflator |
|---|---|---|
| Goods covered | Only goods bought by the representative consumer | All goods and services produced in the country |
| Imported goods | Included if consumers buy them | Not included |
| Weights | Constant (fixed basket) | Change with each good's production level |
Is GDP a good index of welfare?
More income lets a person buy more, so it is tempting to treat higher (real) GDP as greater well-being. The book gives at least three reasons for caution.
Why GDP may not measure welfare
-
Distribution of GDP
- A rise may go to a few people
- Most may be worse off even as GDP rises
-
Non-monetary exchanges
- Unpaid domestic work is not counted
- Barter in the informal sector is not counted
- GDP is underestimated
-
Externalities
- Harms or benefits not paid for
- Negative: pollution - GDP overstates welfare
- Positive: GDP understates welfare
Worked example 3: GDP up, most people worse off (illustrative)
A made-up village has 50 people each earning ₹20, so GDP (income method) = 50 × 20 = ₹1,000. Next year, with prices unchanged, 40 people earn ₹18 and 10 earn ₹30. Working: GDP = 40 × 18 + 10 × 30 = 720 + 300 = ₹1,020, up 2 per cent. Yet 40 of 50 people - 80 per cent - saw income fall by (20 − 18)/20 × 100 = 10 per cent, while 10 people gained (30 − 20)/20 × 100 = 50 per cent. If welfare depends on how many people are better off, GDP has misled us.
Non-monetary exchanges and externalities
Many activities are not valued in money: domestic work done at home is unpaid, and in the informal sector goods and services may be exchanged directly (barter). Such activities are not recorded, so GDP underestimates productive activity, especially in developing countries with remote regions. Externalities are benefits or harms that one firm or person causes another without being paid or penalised; there is no market for them. A made-up factory whose value added is counted in GDP may also pollute a river, harming people who use its water and fishermen whose catch declines. GDP ignores this cost, so treating GDP as welfare overestimates it. With positive externalities, GDP underestimates welfare.
Key takeaways: nominal GDP uses current prices; real GDP uses base-year prices and shows volume changes; GDP deflator = nominal ÷ real. CPI is the cost of a fixed consumer basket now as a percentage of its base-year cost; WPI uses wholesale prices. CPI differs from the deflator in coverage, imports and weights. GDP may not reflect welfare because of unequal distribution, unrecorded non-monetary activity and externalities.
Check your understanding
-
1. Nominal GDP is ₹1,800 crore and real GDP is ₹1,500 crore (illustrative). The GDP deflator is:
- 0.83
- 300
- 1.2
- 3.3
Show answer
Answer: C. GDP deflator = nominal ÷ real = 1,800 ÷ 1,500 = 1.2, or 120 per cent.
-
2. A made-up country made 200 chairs at ₹500 in the base year and 220 chairs at ₹600 in the current year. Real GDP in the current year (at base-year prices) is:
- ₹1,10,000
- ₹1,32,000
- ₹1,00,000
- ₹1,20,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Real GDP = current quantity × base-year price = 220 × 500 = ₹1,10,000. Nominal GDP would be 220 × 600 = ₹1,32,000.
-
3. Which statement about CPI and the GDP deflator is correct?
- Both include only consumer goods
- The GDP deflator includes imported goods but CPI does not
- CPI has changing weights while the deflator has constant weights
- CPI can include imported consumer goods, while the GDP deflator does not include imports
Show answer
Answer: D. CPI prices a consumer basket, which can include imports; the GDP deflator covers domestic production only. CPI weights are constant; the deflator's change with production.
-
4. A refinery's output adds to GDP, but its waste kills fish in a river used by fishermen, who are not compensated. This shows that GDP:
- Overestimates welfare because of a negative externality
- Underestimates welfare because of barter
- Measures welfare accurately
- Excludes the refinery's value added
Show answer
Answer: A. The harm to fishermen is a negative externality not reflected in GDP. Counting the refinery's output without this cost overstates welfare.
-
5. Assertion (A): A rise in nominal GDP always means more goods and services were produced. Reason (R): Nominal GDP is valued at current prices, so it can rise because of price increases alone.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: D. A is false: nominal GDP can rise just because prices rose, with output unchanged. R is true and explains why A is false. Real GDP is needed to measure volume.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.