• Foundation
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ordinal utility: indifference curves, MRS and monotonic preferences

Explain why ordinal analysis ranks bundles instead of measuring utility, define indifference curves, the indifference map and monotonic preferences, calculate MRS, and state the features of indifference curves.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define an indifference curve, an indifference map and monotonic preferences.
  • Calculate the marginal rate of substitution and state the law of diminishing MRS.
  • Explain the three features of indifference curves, including why they cannot intersect.

Cardinal analysis is easy to understand, but it has a major drawback: in real life nobody measures satisfaction in numbers. What a consumer can do is rank bundles - say that one gives more, less or the same satisfaction as another. Ordinal utility analysis starts from this idea of ranking, and its main tool is the indifference curve.

Indifference curves

Bundles of two goods can be shown as points on a diagram, with good 1 on the horizontal axis and good 2 on the vertical axis. Points that give the consumer equal satisfaction can be joined to form a curve. The consumer is said to be indifferent between these bundles. A curve joining all points representing bundles among which the consumer is indifferent is called an indifference curve.

If the consumer gets one more unit of good 1 and is to stay equally satisfied, she must give up some of good 2. That is why an indifference curve slopes downward from left to right.

Marginal rate of substitution (MRS)

The amount of good 2 a consumer is willing to give up to get one more unit of good 1, keeping her satisfaction unchanged, is the marginal rate of substitution (MRS). It is the rate at which she will substitute good 1 for good 2 while staying on the same indifference curve. Written with changes: MRS = |ΔX2 / ΔX1|, the absolute value (size, ignoring the minus sign) of the change in good 2 per unit change in good 1. For example, if ΔX2/ΔX1 = −3/1, then MRS = 3.

Worked example 1: diminishing MRS (illustrative)

A made-up consumer, Asha, is indifferent among the bundles of apples and oranges below. Find the MRS between each pair. Working: A to B, she gives up 20 − 14 = 6 oranges for 1 apple, so MRS = 6:1. B to C: 14 − 10 = 4, MRS = 4:1. C to D: 10 − 8 = 2, MRS = 2:1. D to E: 8 − 7 = 1, MRS = 1:1.

Asha's indifference schedule (illustrative)
BundleApples (x1)Oranges (x2)MRS of apples for oranges
A120-
B2146:1
C3104:1
D482:1
E571:1

As Asha gets more apples, she is willing to give up fewer and fewer oranges for each extra apple. The reason is marginal utility: with more apples, the MU of an extra apple falls, and with fewer oranges, the MU of each remaining orange rises. This tendency is the law of diminishing marginal rate of substitution. It makes the indifference curve convex to the origin - steep at first and flatter later - which is its most common shape.

MRS = |ΔX2 / ΔX1| = the units of good 2 a consumer is willing to give up for one more unit of good 1 while staying equally satisfied. Diminishing MRS makes an indifference curve convex to the origin.

An exception: perfect substitutes

Perfect substitutes are goods that can be used in place of each other and give exactly the same utility. For most people, a ten-rupee coin and a ten-rupee note are perfect substitutes: what matters is only the total number of ten-rupee pieces. Such a consumer always gives up exactly one coin for one more note, however many notes she has, so the MRS stays constant and the indifference curve is a straight line.

Perfect substitutes: constant MRS (illustrative)
BundleTen-rupee notesTen-rupee coinsMRS
A19-
B281:1
C371:1
D461:1

Monotonic preferences and the indifference map

Preferences are monotonic if, between any two bundles, the consumer prefers the one that has more of at least one good and no less of the other. For example, with monotonic preferences (6, 9) is preferred to (6, 7) and to (5, 9). A consumer's preferences over all bundles can be shown by a family of indifference curves called an indifference map. Monotonicity implies that bundles on a higher indifference curve (further from the origin) are preferred to bundles on a lower one.

Features of indifference curves

Features of indifference curves

  • Slopes downward from left to right
    • More of good 1 must be balanced by less of good 2
    • Otherwise the consumer would move to a higher curve
  • A higher curve gives higher satisfaction
    • Follows from monotonic preferences
    • Holds as long as marginal utility is positive
  • Two indifference curves never intersect
    • Crossing would make two unequal bundles equally good
    • That contradicts monotonic preferences
Usually also convex to the origin because of diminishing MRS.

Worked example 2: why two indifference curves cannot cross

Suppose, wrongly, that curves IC1 and IC2 cross at bundle P = (5, 9). On IC1 there is also Q = (8, 6), and on IC2 there is R = (8, 4). Working: P and Q are on IC1, so P is as good as Q. P and R are on IC2, so P is as good as R. Then Q must be as good as R. But Q = (8, 6) has the same apples as R = (8, 4) and 6 − 4 = 2 more oranges, so with monotonic preferences Q must be strictly preferred to R. The two conclusions contradict each other, so the curves cannot intersect.

Worked example 3: higher curve, higher satisfaction

Bundles X = (2, 10), Y = (3, 10) and Z = (4, 10) all have 10 oranges but 2, 3 and 4 apples. With monotonic preferences, Y is preferred to X and Z to Y, so they lie on successively higher indifference curves. Any bundle with more of one good and no less of the other always lies on a higher curve.

Key takeaways: ordinal analysis ranks bundles instead of measuring utility. An indifference curve joins bundles giving equal satisfaction; MRS = |ΔX2/ΔX1| usually diminishes, making the curve convex, except for perfect substitutes (straight line, constant MRS). With monotonic preferences, indifference curves slope downward, higher curves are preferred and two curves never intersect.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. On an indifference curve, a consumer moves from (2 pens, 15 pencils) to (3 pens, 11 pencils). The MRS of pens for pencils is:

    1. 11
    2. 3
    3. 4
    4. 15
    Show answer

    Answer: C. MRS = |ΔX2/ΔX1| = |(11 − 15)/(3 − 2)| = 4. She gives up 4 pencils for 1 more pen.

  2. 2. Which bundle does a consumer with monotonic preferences definitely prefer to (6, 8)?

    1. (6, 9)
    2. (5, 9)
    3. (7, 7)
    4. (6, 7)
    Show answer

    Answer: A. (6, 9) has the same amount of good 1 and more of good 2, so with monotonic preferences it is preferred. (5, 9) and (7, 7) have more of one good but less of the other, so we cannot rank them without more information; (6, 7) has less.

  3. 3. For perfect substitutes, the indifference curve is:

    1. Convex to the origin
    2. A straight line, because MRS is constant
    3. Concave to the origin
    4. Vertical
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Perfect substitutes are always exchanged at the same rate (for example one coin for one note), so MRS does not diminish and the indifference curve is a straight downward-sloping line.

  4. 4. The law of diminishing MRS explains why an indifference curve is usually:

    1. Upward sloping
    2. A straight line
    3. Horizontal
    4. Convex to the origin
    Show answer

    Answer: D. As more of good 1 is obtained, the consumer gives up less and less of good 2 for each extra unit, so the curve gets flatter: it is convex to the origin.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Two indifference curves cannot intersect. Reason (R): If they did, a bundle with more of one good and no less of the other would be equally preferred to a bundle with less, contradicting monotonic preferences.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true, and R is exactly the argument that proves A: intersection would make two bundles equal even though one has more of a good, which monotonic preferences rule out.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery