- Foundation
- About 22 min
- 5 practice questions
The consumer's budget and the consumer's optimum
Define the budget set and budget line, find intercepts and slope from p1x1 + p2x2 = M, show how income and price changes move the line, and locate the consumer's optimum where MRS equals the price ratio.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Write the budget constraint and budget line, and find their intercepts and slope.
- Show how the budget line changes when income or one price changes.
- Explain why the optimum lies on the budget line where it is tangent to an indifference curve (MRS = p1/p2).
Indifference curves show what a consumer would like. But what she can actually buy depends on her income and the prices of goods. This lesson describes the set of bundles she can afford, then brings the two together to find her best choice.
Budget constraint, budget set and budget line
Let the consumer's money income be M and the prices of the two goods be p1 and p2. Buying x1 units of good 1 costs p1x1, and buying x2 units of good 2 costs p2x2. She can buy a bundle (x1, x2) only if its cost is not more than her income:
Budget constraint: p1x1 + p2x2 ≤ M. Budget line: p1x1 + p2x2 = M. Horizontal intercept M/p1, vertical intercept M/p2, slope −p1/p2.
The inequality is the budget constraint. The collection of all bundles the consumer can buy with her income at the prevailing prices is the budget set. The bundles that cost exactly M lie on a straight line called the budget line; bundles below it cost less than M, and bundles above it are unaffordable. Rewriting the equation as x2 = M/p2 − (p1/p2)x1 shows that the line has vertical intercept M/p2 (all income spent on good 2), horizontal intercept M/p1 (all income spent on good 1) and slope −p1/p2.
The slope has a clear meaning. On the budget line, one more unit of good 1 costs p1 rupees, which must come out of spending on good 2; p1 rupees would have bought p1/p2 units of good 2. So the absolute value of the slope, p1/p2, is the rate at which the consumer is able to substitute good 1 for good 2 in the market. The line slopes downward because, with all income spent, more of one good means less of the other.
Worked example 1: a budget set with whole units (illustrative)
A made-up student has ₹12. Erasers (good 1) cost ₹3 and pencils (good 2) cost ₹6, sold only in whole units. List the affordable bundles and those costing exactly ₹12. Working: the condition is 3x1 + 6x2 ≤ 12. With x2 = 0, x1 can be 0 to 4; with x2 = 1, 3x1 ≤ 6 so x1 is 0 to 2; with x2 = 2, 3x1 ≤ 0 so x1 = 0. Affordable: (0,0), (1,0), (2,0), (3,0), (4,0), (0,1), (1,1), (2,1), (0,2) - 9 bundles. Costing exactly ₹12: (4,0) = 12, (2,1) = 6 + 6 = 12, (0,2) = 12. A bundle like (2,2) costs 6 + 12 = ₹18 and is not affordable.
Worked example 2: equation, intercepts and slope (illustrative)
Income M = ₹60, price of good 1 p1 = ₹6, price of good 2 p2 = ₹4 (divisible goods). Working: budget line 6x1 + 4x2 = 60. All income on good 1: 60/6 = 10 units. All income on good 2: 60/4 = 15 units. Slope = −p1/p2 = −6/4 = −1.5: to get one more unit of good 1 she must give up 1.5 units of good 2. Check with a point: (4, 9) costs 6×4 + 4×9 = 24 + 36 = ₹60, so it lies on the line.
Changes in the budget set
| Change (other things unchanged) | What happens to the budget line | Illustration with M = 60, p1 = 6, p2 = 4 |
|---|---|---|
| Income rises | Parallel outward shift; slope unchanged | M = 84: intercepts 84/6 = 14 and 84/4 = 21; slope still −1.5 |
| Income falls | Parallel inward shift | M = 48: intercepts 8 and 12 |
| Price of good 1 falls | Pivots outward around the vertical intercept; flatter | p1 = 5: horizontal intercept 60/5 = 12, vertical still 15; slope −1.25 |
| Price of good 1 rises | Pivots inward around the vertical intercept; steeper | p1 = 10: horizontal intercept 6, vertical still 15; slope −2.5 |
A change in the price of good 2 works the same way but pivots the line around the horizontal intercept. If income and both prices all change in the same proportion, for example all double, both intercepts and the slope are unchanged, so the budget set stays the same.
The consumer's optimum
Economics assumes the consumer is rational: she has well-defined preferences, can compare any two bundles, and from the bundles available always chooses the one that gives her maximum satisfaction. Her problem is therefore to reach the highest possible indifference curve given her budget set.
Locating the optimum
- Points above the line are ruled out They cost more than income
- Points below the line are not best With monotonic preferences some point on the line has more of a good and no less of the other
- So the optimum is on the budget line All income is spent
- Best point on the line Where the line just touches (is tangent to) an indifference curve
At the point of tangency, the slope of the indifference curve equals the slope of the budget line, so MRS = p1/p2: the rate at which the consumer is willing to substitute one good for the other equals the rate at which she is able to do so in the market. Every other point on the budget line lies on a lower indifference curve, and indifference curves above the tangent one are unaffordable. (In some situations the optimum is a corner where all income is spent on one good; the book mentions this as a special case.)
Consumer's optimum: on the budget line, where it is tangent to an indifference curve, so that MRS = p1/p2.
Worked example 3: why MRS must equal the price ratio (illustrative)
Let p1 = ₹6 and p2 = ₹4, so p1/p2 = 1.5. Suppose at some bundle on the budget line the consumer's MRS is 3. Working: she is willing to give up 3 units of good 2 for one more unit of good 1, but the market asks her to give up only 1.5 units. If she buys one more unit of good 1 by spending ₹6 less on good 2, she gives up 1.5 units of good 2 instead of the 3 she would have accepted, so she ends up better off by 3 − 1.5 = 1.5 units of good 2 in terms of satisfaction. She will keep buying more of good 1, and her MRS will fall (diminishing MRS) until it reaches 1.5. If instead MRS were below 1.5, she would gain by buying less of good 1 and more of good 2. Only where MRS = 1.5 is there no gain from changing - that is the optimum.
Key takeaways: the budget set is all bundles with p1x1 + p2x2 ≤ M; the budget line has intercepts M/p1 and M/p2 and slope −p1/p2. Income changes shift it parallel; a price change pivots it. A rational consumer chooses the point on the budget line tangent to the highest attainable indifference curve, where MRS = p1/p2.
Check your understanding
-
1. A consumer has ₹40; good 1 costs ₹8 and good 2 costs ₹5. How much of good 2 can she buy if she spends all her income on it?
- 5 units
- 8 units
- 13 units
- 40 units
Show answer
Answer: B. Vertical intercept = M/p2 = 40/5 = 8 units of good 2.
-
2. With M = ₹40, p1 = ₹8 and p2 = ₹5, what is the slope of the budget line?
- −0.625
- −5
- −8
- −1.6
Show answer
Answer: D. Slope = −p1/p2 = −8/5 = −1.6. One more unit of good 1 means giving up 1.6 units of good 2.
-
3. If the price of good 1 falls while income and the price of good 2 stay the same, the budget line:
- Pivots outward around the vertical intercept and becomes flatter
- Shifts parallel outward
- Pivots inward and becomes steeper
- Does not change
Show answer
Answer: A. The vertical intercept M/p2 is unchanged, while the horizontal intercept M/p1 rises. The line pivots outward around the vertical intercept and its slope −p1/p2 becomes smaller in size (flatter).
-
4. Case: A made-up consumer's MRS at her chosen bundle is 2, while p1/p2 = 1. What should she do to raise her satisfaction?
- Buy less of good 1 and more of good 2
- Stay where she is, since she is at the optimum
- Buy more of good 1 and less of good 2
- Spend less than her income
Show answer
Answer: C. She values one more unit of good 1 at 2 units of good 2 but the market charges only 1 unit. Buying more of good 1 makes her better off until MRS falls to equal the price ratio of 1.
-
5. Assertion (A): The consumer's optimum bundle lies on the budget line. Reason (R): For any bundle below the budget line there is an affordable bundle with more of at least one good and no less of the other.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Points above the line are unaffordable, and with monotonic preferences any point below it is beaten by a point on the line that has more of some good. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.