• Foundation
  • About 22 min
  • 5 practice questions

Profit maximisation: the three conditions

Define profit, explain why a profit-maximising competitive firm produces where price equals marginal cost on the rising part of MC, and why price must cover AVC in the short run and AC in the long run.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the three conditions for the profit-maximising output of a competitive firm.
  • Explain each condition using MR and MC, and the shut-down comparison with fixed cost.
  • Find the profit-maximising output and profit from a cost schedule.

A firm's profit, written π (the Greek letter pi, as is the convention), is the difference between total revenue and total cost: π = TR − TC. The firm wants to find the output q0 at which π is greatest. The book gives three conditions that must hold at q0 when the firm produces a positive output.

Profit-maximising output of a competitive firm: (1) p = MC; (2) MC is not falling at that output; (3) p ≥ AVC in the short run, and p ≥ AC in the long run.

Condition 1: price equals marginal cost

As output rises, both TR and TC rise. If the extra revenue from one more unit (MR) is larger than the extra cost (MC), producing it adds to profit, so profit keeps rising while MR > MC. If MR < MC, producing the unit lowers profit. So profit is greatest where MR = MC. For a competitive firm MR = p, so the condition becomes p = MC.

Condition 2: MC must not be falling

The MC curve is U-shaped, so a given price may equal MC at two outputs - one on the falling part and one on the rising part. The point on the falling part cannot be the best. Just to the left of it MC is above price, so cutting output slightly would raise profit; just to the right MC is below price, so expanding would raise profit too. Profit is at a minimum, not a maximum, there. The firm's output must be where MC is non-decreasing.

Condition 3: price must cover AVC (short run) or AC (long run)

Short run. If the firm produces nothing, TR and TVC are zero, but it must still pay TFC, so its profit is −TFC. If it produces q where p < AVC, then TR = p × q is less than TVC = AVC × q, and its profit is (TR − TVC) − TFC, which is worse than −TFC. So it is better to produce nothing: in the short run the firm produces only if p ≥ AVC.

Long run. All costs are variable and a firm that shuts down has zero profit. If p < AC at the chosen output, TR < TC and the firm makes a loss, which is worse than zero. So in the long run the firm produces only if p ≥ AC; otherwise it exits.

Worked example 1: price ₹12 (illustrative)

A made-up firm's costs are shown below (TFC = ₹20). The market price is ₹12. Working: MC equals 12 at the 6th unit, where MC is rising (8, 12, 16). AVC at 6 units = 7.67, below 12, so condition 3 holds. Output = 6 units. Profit = TR − TC = 12 × 6 − 66 = 72 − 66 = ₹6. Check by listing profits: at 4 units 48 − 46 = 2; at 5 units 60 − 54 = 6; at 6 units 72 − 66 = 6; at 7 units 84 − 82 = 2. Profit is highest (₹6) at 5 and 6 units; the 6th unit adds exactly as much revenue (₹12) as cost (MC ₹12), and the rule p = MC picks 6 units. The 7th unit would cost ₹16 but bring only ₹12, so it lowers profit.

Costs of an imaginary firm, TFC = ₹20 (illustrative)
Output (q)TC (₹)TVC (₹)MC (₹)AVC (₹)SAC (₹)
0200---
13010101030
236166818
3402046.6713.33
4462666.511.5
5543486.810.8
66646127.6711
78262168.8611.71
8102822010.2512.75

Worked example 2: price ₹6 and the shut-down decision (illustrative)

Now suppose the price falls to ₹6. Working: MC = 6 at two outputs, the 2nd unit (MC falling from 10 to 6) and the 4th unit (MC rising from 4 to 6). The 2nd-unit point fails condition 2. At 4 units MC is rising, but AVC at 4 units is ₹6.5, which is above the price of ₹6, so condition 3 fails. Compare: producing 4 units gives profit = 6 × 4 − 46 = 24 − 46 = −₹22, whereas producing nothing gives −TFC = −₹20. Producing loses ₹2 more than shutting down, because revenue (₹24) does not even cover TVC (₹26). The firm produces zero at this price.

Profit as an area

At the chosen output q0, TR is the rectangle formed by price and quantity (p × q0), and TC is the rectangle formed by SAC and quantity (SAC × q0). Profit is the difference, a rectangle of height (p − SAC) and width q0. In example 1: (12 − 11) × 6 = ₹6, matching the direct calculation.

Finding the profit-maximising output

  1. Find outputs where price equals MC There may be two
  2. Keep the one where MC is rising Condition 2
  3. Check price against AVC (short run) or AC (long run) Condition 3
  4. Produce there, or produce nothing Profit = (p − SAC) × q

Key takeaways: π = TR − TC. Profit rises while MR > MC and falls while MR < MC, so it peaks where MR = MC, i.e. p = MC for a competitive firm. The point must be on the rising part of MC. In the short run the firm produces only if p ≥ AVC, since otherwise it loses more than its fixed cost; in the long run only if p ≥ AC.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. For a perfectly competitive firm, the first condition for maximum profit is:

    1. p = AVC
    2. p = MC
    3. TR = TC
    4. AR = AC
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Profit is maximised where MR = MC, and for a competitive firm MR = p, so the condition is p = MC.

  2. 2. Price equals MC at two outputs, one where MC is falling and one where it is rising. The firm should choose:

    1. The output where MC is falling
    2. Either output, since profits are equal
    3. The output where MC is rising, provided price covers AVC
    4. Zero output in all cases
    Show answer

    Answer: C. At the falling-MC point profit is at a minimum: moving a little either way raises profit. The profit-maximising point is on the rising part of MC, provided condition 3 (p ≥ AVC) also holds.

  3. 3. A made-up firm has TFC ₹50. At its best positive output, TR is ₹300 and TVC is ₹320. What should it do in the short run?

    1. Produce, because TR is positive
    2. Produce, because the loss is less than TFC
    3. Raise its price above the market price
    4. Shut down, because producing loses ₹70, more than the ₹50 loss from shutting down
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Producing: profit = 300 − 320 − 50 = −₹70. Shutting down: profit = −TFC = −₹50. Since TR does not cover TVC (p < AVC), shutting down loses less.

  4. 4. At a market price of ₹20, a firm produces 30 units with SAC ₹16. Its profit is:

    1. ₹120
    2. ₹480
    3. ₹600
    4. ₹4
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Profit = (p − SAC) × q = (20 − 16) × 30 = 4 × 30 = ₹120. Equivalently TR = 600 and TC = 480, so profit = 600 − 480 = ₹120.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): In the long run, a competitive firm produces nothing if the price is below its minimum long run average cost. Reason (R): In the long run a firm that shuts down earns zero profit, while producing at p < AC gives a loss.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. With no fixed costs in the long run, shutting down gives zero profit, which beats the loss from producing when price is below AC. R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery