• Foundation
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

The firm's supply curve, shut-down point, normal profit and break-even

Derive a competitive firm's short run and long run supply curves from its MC, AVC and AC curves, and explain the shut-down point, normal profit, super-normal profit, break-even point and opportunity cost.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define a firm's supply, supply schedule and supply curve.
  • Derive the short run and long run supply curves of a competitive firm, including the shut-down point.
  • Explain normal profit, super-normal profit, break-even point and opportunity cost.

A firm's supply is the quantity it chooses to sell at a given price, given its technology and the prices of factors of production. A table of these quantities at different prices is a supply schedule, and its graph - output on the horizontal axis, price on the vertical axis - is the supply curve, drawn with technology and factor prices unchanged. The previous lesson's three conditions tell us exactly what this curve looks like.

Short run supply curve

Case 1: price at or above minimum AVC. The firm sets price equal to SMC on the rising part of SMC. At that output AVC does not exceed price, so all three conditions hold, and that output is supplied. Case 2: price below minimum AVC. At every positive output AVC exceeds price, so condition 3 fails everywhere and the firm supplies zero.

Short run supply curve of a competitive firm = the rising part of its SMC curve from and above the minimum point of AVC, together with zero output at all prices below minimum AVC.

Worked example 1: a short run supply schedule (illustrative)

Use the cost table from the previous lesson (TFC ₹20; MC 10, 6, 4, 6, 8, 12, 16, 20; minimum AVC ₹6.5 at 4 units). Working: at ₹20, MC = 20 at the 8th unit, so supply 8. At ₹16, the 7th unit: supply 7. At ₹12, the 6th unit: supply 6. At ₹8, the 5th unit (AVC 6.8 < 8): supply 5. At ₹6, price is below minimum AVC (6.5): supply 0. The lowest price at which this firm produces is about ₹6.5, where it would produce 4 units.

Short run supply schedule (illustrative)
Price (₹)Quantity suppliedReason
208p = MC of the 8th unit, MC rising
167p = MC of the 7th unit
126p = MC of the 6th unit
85p = MC of the 5th unit, AVC 6.8 below price
60Price below minimum AVC of 6.5

Long run supply curve

The same reasoning with long run curves gives: the long run supply curve of a firm is the rising part of its LRMC curve from and above the minimum LRAC, together with zero output at all prices below minimum LRAC.

The shut-down point

Moving down the short run supply curve, the last price-output combination with positive output is at the minimum point of AVC, where SMC cuts AVC. Below this price there is no production. This is the short run shut-down point. In the long run, the shut-down point is the minimum of LRAC.

Normal profit, super-normal profit and break-even

Normal profit is the minimum level of profit needed to keep a firm in its existing business. A firm that does not earn it will not continue, so normal profit is treated as part of the firm's total costs - think of it as the opportunity cost of entrepreneurship. Any profit above normal profit is super-normal profit. In the long run a firm does not produce if it earns less than normal profit; in the short run it may continue even with less. The point on the supply curve where the firm earns only normal profit is the break-even point: the point of minimum average cost, where the supply (MC) curve cuts the LRAC curve (in the short run, the SAC curve). At this price TR exactly equals TC (including normal profit).

Two key points on a firm's short run supply curve

  • Shut-down point
    • Minimum of AVC, where SMC cuts AVC
    • Price just covers variable cost
    • Below it the firm produces nothing
    • Loss equals TFC
  • Break-even point
    • Minimum of SAC, where SMC cuts SAC
    • Price just covers average cost
    • Only normal profit is earned
    • Above it: super-normal profit

In the illustrative cost table, minimum AVC is ₹6.5 (shut-down) and minimum SAC is ₹10.8 (break-even). At any price between them the firm produces in the short run while making a loss smaller than its fixed cost; above ₹10.8 it earns super-normal profit.

Opportunity cost

The opportunity cost of an activity is the gain forgone from the second best activity. Example (illustrative): Kavita has ₹50,000 to put into her family shop. Instead, she could keep it at home (zero return), deposit it in a bank paying 6 per cent a year, or in another paying 4 per cent. The best alternative earns 6 per cent of 50,000 = ₹3,000 a year. So the opportunity cost of investing in the shop is ₹3,000 a year - the interest she gives up. Normal profit is this kind of cost for the entrepreneur.

Worked example 2: classifying profit (illustrative)

A made-up firm has TC (including normal profit) of ₹4,000 at its best output of 100 units. Working: AC = 4,000/100 = ₹40. (a) At a price of ₹46, TR = 4,600: super-normal profit = 4,600 − 4,000 = ₹600. (b) At ₹40, TR = ₹4,000 = TC: only normal profit - the break-even point if 40 is the minimum of AC. (c) At ₹35, TR = ₹3,500: less than normal profit by ₹500; it may continue in the short run if price still covers AVC, but in the long run it leaves.

Key takeaways: the short run supply curve is the rising SMC from minimum AVC upward, with zero supply below minimum AVC; the long run supply curve is the rising LRMC from minimum LRAC upward. Minimum AVC is the short run shut-down point; minimum LRAC is the long run shut-down point. Normal profit is part of cost; the break-even point is minimum average cost, where only normal profit is earned. Opportunity cost is the gain from the best alternative forgone.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The short run supply curve of a competitive firm is:

    1. The whole of its SMC curve
    2. Its AVC curve
    3. The rising part of SMC from and above minimum AVC, with zero output below minimum AVC
    4. The rising part of SAC
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The firm produces where p = SMC on the rising part of SMC, and only if p is at least minimum AVC; below that price it supplies nothing.

  2. 2. The short run shut-down point of a firm is at the:

    1. Minimum point of AVC
    2. Minimum point of SAC
    3. Maximum point of MC
    4. Point where TR is zero
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Below the minimum AVC the firm cannot cover variable cost and produces nothing. The last positive output on the supply curve is at minimum AVC, where SMC cuts AVC.

  3. 3. At the break-even point, a firm earns:

    1. Super-normal profit
    2. A loss equal to TFC
    3. Zero revenue
    4. Only normal profit
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The break-even point is the minimum of average cost, where price equals AC and TR = TC including normal profit, so only normal profit is earned.

  4. 4. Raj can earn ₹2,400 a year from a bank, ₹1,800 from another bank or nothing at home on his savings. He invests them in his own business instead. The opportunity cost of this choice is:

    1. ₹4,200
    2. ₹2,400
    3. ₹1,800
    4. Zero
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Opportunity cost is the gain forgone from the best alternative, which is the ₹2,400 interest from the first bank.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Normal profit is included in a firm's total cost. Reason (R): A firm that does not earn normal profit will not continue in business in the long run.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Normal profit is the minimum return needed to keep the entrepreneur in this business - an opportunity cost - so it is counted as part of total cost. R explains why it is treated as a cost.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery