- Foundation
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Balanced, surplus and deficit budgets: revenue, fiscal and primary deficit
Distinguish balanced, surplus and deficit budgets, calculate revenue deficit, fiscal deficit and primary deficit from illustrative budget data, and explain what each deficit implies and how the fiscal deficit is financed.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish balanced, surplus and deficit budgets.
- Calculate revenue, fiscal and primary deficits and the relation between them.
- Explain the implications of each deficit and how the fiscal deficit is financed.
If the government spends exactly what it collects, the budget is balanced. If it collects more than it spends, the budget is in surplus. The most common situation, however, is spending more than it collects - a budget deficit. There are several measures of deficit, each with its own meaning.
Three measures of deficit
Revenue deficit = Revenue expenditure − Revenue receipts. Fiscal deficit = Total expenditure − (Revenue receipts + Non-debt-creating capital receipts) = borrowing requirement. Primary deficit = Fiscal deficit − Net interest liabilities (interest payments − interest receipts).
Non-debt-creating capital receipts are capital receipts that are not borrowings, such as recovery of loans and proceeds from sale of PSU shares. Since the fiscal deficit is what must be borrowed, it indicates the government's total borrowing requirement from all sources. It is also true that fiscal deficit = revenue deficit + capital expenditure − non-debt-creating capital receipts, so the revenue deficit is a part of the fiscal deficit.
Worked example: computing the deficits (illustrative)
A made-up government's budget (₹ crore): tax revenue 700, non-tax revenue 100; revenue expenditure 1,050, of which interest payments 250; capital expenditure 300; recovery of loans 20; disinvestment 30; borrowings 500.
| Item | Working | ₹ crore |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue receipts | 700 + 100 | 800 |
| Revenue deficit | 1,050 − 800 | 250 |
| Non-debt-creating capital receipts | 20 + 30 | 50 |
| Total expenditure | 1,050 + 300 | 1,350 |
| Fiscal deficit | 1,350 − (800 + 50) | 500 |
| Check: RD + capex − non-debt receipts | 250 + 300 − 50 | 500 |
| Primary deficit (no interest receipts assumed) | 500 − 250 | 250 |
Notice the fiscal deficit (₹500 crore) equals borrowings (₹500 crore): the fiscal deficit is exactly what has to be borrowed. Here the revenue deficit is half the fiscal deficit (250 ÷ 500), so half of the borrowing is used to meet current (consumption) spending rather than to build assets.
What the revenue deficit means
A revenue deficit means the government is dissaving: it uses savings of other sectors to finance part of its consumption expenditure. It must borrow not only for investment but also for consumption, which builds up debt and interest liabilities and eventually forces cuts in spending. Since much revenue expenditure is committed (interest, salaries, pensions), cuts often fall on productive capital expenditure or welfare spending, which means lower growth and adverse welfare effects. A large share of revenue deficit in the fiscal deficit shows that much borrowing is being used for consumption rather than investment.
What the fiscal deficit means and how it is financed
The gross fiscal deficit is a key indicator of the financial health of the public sector and the stability of the economy. From the financing side: fiscal deficit = net borrowing at home + borrowing from the RBI + borrowing from abroad. Net borrowing at home includes borrowing directly from the public through debt instruments (such as small savings schemes) and indirectly from commercial banks through the Statutory Liquidity Ratio.
What the primary deficit means
Part of the borrowing requirement is only to pay interest on past debt. The primary deficit removes this to show the present fiscal imbalance - borrowing needed because current expenditures exceed current revenues. A primary deficit of zero means the government is borrowing only to pay interest on past debt.
Measures of government deficit
-
Revenue deficit
- Revenue expenditure − revenue receipts
- Shows dissaving: borrowing for consumption
-
Fiscal deficit
- Total expenditure − revenue receipts − non-debt capital receipts
- Total borrowing requirement
-
Primary deficit
- Fiscal deficit − net interest liabilities
- Current imbalance excluding past debt's interest
Worked example 2: from financing data (illustrative)
A made-up government borrows ₹300 crore at home, ₹40 crore from the central bank and ₹60 crore from abroad; its interest payments are ₹180 crore and interest receipts ₹30 crore. Working: fiscal deficit = 300 + 40 + 60 = ₹400 crore. Net interest liabilities = 180 − 30 = ₹150 crore. Primary deficit = 400 − 150 = ₹250 crore.
The book also notes that the formal measure called 'budget deficit' (total expenditure minus total receipts, including borrowing) has not been shown in India's budgets since 1997-98; the fiscal deficit is the key measure.
Key takeaways: budgets may be balanced, surplus or deficit. Revenue deficit = revenue expenditure − revenue receipts (dissaving); fiscal deficit = total expenditure − revenue receipts − non-debt-creating capital receipts (total borrowing requirement), financed by borrowing at home, from the RBI and from abroad; primary deficit = fiscal deficit − net interest liabilities (current imbalance). Revenue deficit is part of fiscal deficit.
Check your understanding
-
1. Revenue expenditure is ₹900 crore and revenue receipts ₹720 crore (illustrative). Revenue deficit is:
- ₹1,620 crore
- ₹180 crore
- ₹720 crore
- ₹900 crore
Show answer
Answer: B. Revenue deficit = 900 − 720 = ₹180 crore.
-
2. Total expenditure ₹1,500 crore, revenue receipts ₹1,000 crore, recovery of loans ₹40 crore, disinvestment ₹60 crore, borrowings ₹400 crore (illustrative). Fiscal deficit is:
- ₹500 crore
- ₹100 crore
- ₹900 crore
- ₹400 crore
Show answer
Answer: D. Fiscal deficit = 1,500 − (1,000 + 40 + 60) = ₹400 crore, equal to borrowings.
-
3. Fiscal deficit is ₹400 crore, interest payments ₹220 crore, interest receipts ₹20 crore (illustrative). Primary deficit is:
- ₹200 crore
- ₹180 crore
- ₹600 crore
- ₹380 crore
Show answer
Answer: A. Net interest liabilities = 220 − 20 = ₹200 crore. Primary deficit = 400 − 200 = ₹200 crore.
-
4. The fiscal deficit indicates:
- Only the government's consumption expenditure
- The total borrowing requirement of the government from all sources
- The interest paid on past debt
- The surplus of revenue over expenditure
Show answer
Answer: B. Since fiscal deficit is total expenditure minus all non-borrowed receipts, it is what must be borrowed - the total borrowing requirement.
-
5. Assertion (A): A revenue deficit means the government is dissaving. Reason (R): With a revenue deficit, the government uses savings of other sectors to finance part of its consumption expenditure.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Spending more on current needs than current receipts means borrowing others' savings to consume, i.e. dissaving. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.