- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Government debt, its burden, deficit reduction and the FRBM Act
Explain how deficits add to debt, the arguments about whether debt burdens future generations (including Ricardian equivalence and crowding out), whether deficits are inflationary, how deficits can be reduced, and the main features of the FRBM Act, 2003.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the relation between deficits (a flow) and debt (a stock) and calculate debt accumulation.
- Present the book's arguments on the burden of debt, Ricardian equivalence, inflation and crowding out.
- Describe ways of reducing deficits and the main features of the FRBM Act, 2003 as given in the book.
Budget deficits must be financed by taxation, borrowing or printing money. Governments have mostly relied on borrowing, which creates government debt. Deficits are a flow that adds to the stock of debt. If the government keeps borrowing year after year, debt accumulates and interest payments grow - and those interest payments themselves add to the deficit and the debt.
Worked example 1: deficits and debt (illustrative)
A made-up government starts with debt of ₹1,000 crore at an interest rate of 8 per cent. Each year its primary deficit (deficit excluding interest) is ₹50 crore, financed by borrowing. Working: year 1 interest = 8 per cent of 1,000 = ₹80 crore, so the fiscal deficit = 50 + 80 = ₹130 crore and debt rises to 1,130. Year 2 interest = 8 per cent of 1,130 = ₹90.4 crore, fiscal deficit = 50 + 90.4 = ₹140.4 crore and debt rises to 1,270.4. Even with the same primary deficit, the fiscal deficit grows because interest grows with debt.
Is government debt a burden?
The book stresses that what is true of one trader's debt may not be true of the government's: unlike a trader, the government can raise resources through taxation and printing money. It sets out several views.
- Burden on future generations: the government may borrow from people today and repay twenty years later by taxing the young who have just started work, reducing their disposable income and consumption. Government borrowing also reduces savings available to the private sector; to the extent this lowers capital formation and growth, debt is a burden on future generations.
- Short-sighted consumers: traditionally it was argued that if the government cuts taxes and runs a deficit, people spend more, not realising - or not caring, if they expect it to fall on later generations - that taxes must rise in future.
- Ricardian equivalence: a counter-argument is that consumers are forward-looking, know that borrowing today means higher taxes later, and care about their children and grandchildren. They save more now, fully offsetting government dissaving, so national saving does not change. Named after David Ricardo, a great nineteenth-century economist, it holds that tax financing and borrowing are equivalent ways to finance spending.
- 'We owe it to ourselves': domestic debt only transfers resources between generations within the nation; but debt owed to foreigners is a burden, since goods must be sent abroad to pay the interest.
Other perspectives on deficits
Two criticisms of deficits and the book's replies
-
Deficits are inflationary
- Higher spending or tax cuts raise aggregate demand
- If firms cannot produce more at current prices, prices rise
- Reply: with unused resources, output rises instead, so deficits need not be inflationary
-
Deficits crowd out private investment
- Government bonds compete with corporate bonds for savings
- Some private borrowers are crowded out
- Reply: if deficits raise output, income and saving rise too, so both can borrow more
Also, if the government invests in infrastructure whose return exceeds the interest rate, future generations may be better off and the debt can be paid off by growth in output. So the growth of debt should be judged against the growth of the economy as a whole. The book's summary puts it simply: public debt is burdensome if it reduces future growth in output.
Deficits are flows that add to the stock of debt. Debt is a burden if it reduces future growth; Ricardian equivalence argues that forward-looking households save more to offset government borrowing.
Reducing the deficit
A deficit can be reduced by raising taxes or cutting expenditure. According to the book, India has tried to raise tax revenue with greater reliance on direct taxes (indirect taxes being regressive, falling on all income groups alike), and to raise receipts through sale of shares in PSUs, but the main thrust has been reducing expenditure - through more efficient government activities, better planning and administration, and in some cases withdrawing from areas where it operated before. Cutting programmes in vital areas such as agriculture, education, health and poverty alleviation, however, would harm the economy.
A larger deficit does not always mean a more expansionary policy: in a recession, GDP falls, so tax revenue falls and the deficit rises even with no change in policy; in a boom, the deficit falls.
Worked example 2: deficit in a recession (illustrative)
A made-up government spends ₹1,000 crore and collects a proportional tax of 20 per cent of GDP. If GDP is ₹4,500 crore, revenue = 0.2 × 4,500 = ₹900 crore and the deficit = 1,000 − 900 = ₹100 crore. In a recession GDP falls to ₹4,000 crore: revenue = ₹800 crore and the deficit = ₹200 crore. The deficit doubled with no change in policy.
The FRBM Act, 2003 (as described in the book)
Arguing that a legal rule binding all governments would be more effective in controlling deficits, Parliament enacted the Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act in August 2003; its rules took effect from July 2004. Main features described in the book:
- Reduce the fiscal deficit to not more than 3 per cent of GDP and eliminate the revenue deficit by 31 March 2009 (later rescheduled, according to the book, to 2009-10), then build up a revenue surplus.
- Reduce the fiscal deficit by 0.3 per cent of GDP each year and the revenue deficit by 0.5 per cent; if taxes do not achieve this, expenditure must be cut.
- Targets may be exceeded only on grounds of national security, natural calamity or similar exceptional grounds.
- The central government shall not borrow from the RBI except through advances to meet temporary cash mismatches; the RBI must not subscribe to primary issues of central government securities from 2006-07.
- Greater transparency; three policy statements laid before Parliament with the budget; quarterly review of receipts and expenditure.
The book records both views: the government regards the Act as an important mechanism for fiscal prudence, while there have been fears that welfare expenditure may be cut to meet the targets.
Key takeaways: deficits are flows that add to the stock of debt, and growing interest raises future deficits. Debt may burden future generations by raising future taxes and crowding out private investment; Ricardian equivalence argues households save more to offset it; foreign debt is a clearer burden. Deficits need not be inflationary with unused resources, and debt is not burdensome if it raises growth. Deficits rise automatically in recessions. The FRBM Act, 2003 set rules to limit deficits and borrowing.
Check your understanding
-
1. Government debt of ₹500 crore carries 10 per cent interest; the primary deficit is ₹30 crore. Next year's fiscal deficit is:
- ₹30 crore
- ₹50 crore
- ₹80 crore
- ₹530 crore
Show answer
Answer: C. Interest = 10 per cent of 500 = ₹50 crore. Fiscal deficit = primary deficit + interest = 30 + 50 = ₹80 crore.
-
2. Ricardian equivalence argues that when the government borrows to cut taxes:
- Households spend all of the tax cut
- Forward-looking households save more, so national saving does not change
- Prices always rise
- Debt owed to foreigners disappears
Show answer
Answer: B. Households expect higher future taxes and care about future generations, so they save more now, offsetting government dissaving. Taxes and borrowing are then equivalent ways of financing.
-
3. 'Crowding out' refers to:
- Government bonds competing with private borrowers for savings, reducing private investment
- Too many people in government offices
- Foreign firms entering the market
- Free riders using public goods
Show answer
Answer: A. When government borrows by selling bonds, it competes with firms for the available savings, so some private borrowers are crowded out of financial markets.
-
4. A government's deficit rises during a recession even though its tax rates and spending are unchanged. Why?
- It has adopted an expansionary discretionary policy
- Interest rates must have fallen
- It has reduced transfers
- Tax revenue falls as incomes fall
Show answer
Answer: D. Firms and households pay less tax when they earn less, so revenue falls and the deficit rises automatically in a recession, without any policy change.
-
5. Assertion (A): Government debt owed to foreigners involves a burden. Reason (R): Goods must be sent abroad to make interest payments on foreign debt.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. Unlike domestic debt, which only transfers resources within the nation, foreign debt requires sending goods abroad, reducing what the nation has. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.