- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Applications: price ceiling and price floor
Explain why governments impose price ceilings and price floors, show how a ceiling below equilibrium creates excess demand (with rationing and black markets) and a floor above it creates excess supply, and calculate their size from illustrative data.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a price ceiling and explain its effects, including rationing, queues and black markets.
- Define a price floor and explain its effects through agricultural price support and minimum wages.
- Calculate the shortage or surplus created by a ceiling or floor, and the cost of buying a surplus.
Demand and supply analysis is a powerful way to study government intervention in markets. Sometimes a government regulates the price of a good because the market price is thought to be too high or too low compared with a desired level. The book looks at two such price controls within the framework of perfect competition.
Price ceiling
A price ceiling is a government-imposed upper limit on the price of a good or service. It is usually placed on necessary items such as wheat, rice, kerosene and sugar, and it is set below the market-determined price, because at the market price some sections of the population could not afford these goods. At the ceiling price, consumers want to buy more than firms want to sell, so there is excess demand - a shortage.
Though the intention is to help consumers, the ceiling can end up creating a shortage. How is the limited quantity shared out? One way is rationing: ration coupons are issued so that no one can buy more than a set amount, and the good is sold through ration shops, also called fair price shops.
Possible adverse consequences of a price ceiling with rationing
-
Long queues
- Each consumer has to stand in line at ration shops
-
Black market
- The quantity from the fair price shop does not satisfy everyone
- Some consumers are willing to pay more
- Illegal sales at higher prices can arise
Worked example 1: a price ceiling (illustrative)
Use the tomato market from lesson 1: qD = 260 − 3p, qS = 20 + 2p, equilibrium ₹48 and 116 kg. The government sets a ceiling of ₹40. Working: qD = 260 − 120 = 140 kg; qS = 20 + 80 = 100 kg. Shortage (excess demand) = 140 − 100 = 40 kg. Only 100 kg is actually bought and sold - less than the 116 kg traded at equilibrium - even though the price is lower. If each of 50 households is entitled by ration to 2 kg, the ration needs 50 × 2 = 100 kg, exactly what is supplied; buyers who want more may turn to a black market.
Price floor
A price floor is a government-imposed lower limit on the price that may be charged for a good or service. It is used where a fall in price below some level is considered undesirable, and it is set above the market-determined price. The best-known examples are agricultural price support programmes, which set a lower limit on the purchase price of some farm goods, and minimum wage legislation, which keeps the wage rate of labourers from falling below a set level. At the floor price, firms want to sell more than consumers want to buy, so there is excess supply - a surplus.
For agricultural price support, to stop the excess supply from pulling the price down, the government has to buy the surplus at the predetermined price.
Worked example 2: a price floor (illustrative)
In the same tomato market, suppose a support price of ₹56 is fixed. Working: qD = 260 − 168 = 92 kg; qS = 20 + 112 = 132 kg. Surplus (excess supply) = 132 − 92 = 40 kg. To hold the price at ₹56, the government buys the 40 kg surplus at a cost of 40 × 56 = ₹2,240. Consumers buy 92 kg, less than the equilibrium 116 kg, and pay more per kg.
Worked example 3: a minimum wage (illustrative)
In the delivery-labour market of lesson 2 (LD = 900 − 3w, LS = 100 + 5w, equilibrium wage ₹100 and 600 hours), suppose a minimum wage of ₹120 an hour is set. Working: LD = 900 − 360 = 540 hours; LS = 100 + 600 = 700 hours. Excess supply of labour = 700 − 540 = 160 hours: people want to work more hours than firms want to hire at that wage. Hours actually worked fall from 600 to 540.
Price ceiling and price floor
-
Price ceiling
- Upper limit on price
- Set below the equilibrium price
- Creates excess demand (shortage)
- Often with rationing; queues and black markets possible
- Examples: essential foods, kerosene
-
Price floor
- Lower limit on price
- Set above the equilibrium price
- Creates excess supply (surplus)
- Government may buy the surplus
- Examples: farm price support, minimum wage
A ceiling below equilibrium causes a shortage equal to qD − qS at the ceiling price; a floor above equilibrium causes a surplus equal to qS − qD at the floor price. A ceiling above, or a floor below, the equilibrium price has no effect.
The last point in the quote follows from the logic: a ceiling set above p* does not stop the market reaching p*, and a floor below p* does not bind either. That is why ceilings meant to help buyers are set below p*, and floors meant to help sellers are set above it.
Key takeaways: a price ceiling is a maximum price set below equilibrium on necessities; it creates excess demand, which may be handled by rationing through fair price shops, with queues and black markets as possible side-effects. A price floor is a minimum price set above equilibrium, as in farm price support and minimum wages; it creates excess supply, which the government may have to buy.
Check your understanding
-
1. A price ceiling is usually set:
- Above the equilibrium price, to help producers
- Below the equilibrium price, so that necessities are affordable
- Exactly at the equilibrium price
- Only on luxury goods
Show answer
Answer: B. A price ceiling is an upper limit placed on necessary items and fixed below the market-determined price so that more people can afford them.
-
2. Illustrative demand qD = 180 − 2p and supply qS = 30 + 3p (equilibrium ₹30). A ceiling of ₹24 creates:
- A surplus of 30 units
- A shortage of 18 units
- A shortage of 30 units
- No effect
Show answer
Answer: C. At ₹24: qD = 180 − 48 = 132 and qS = 30 + 72 = 102. Shortage = 132 − 102 = 30 units.
-
3. Which is an example of a price floor given in the textbook?
- Ration coupons
- Fair price shops
- A ceiling on kerosene prices
- Minimum wage legislation
Show answer
Answer: D. Minimum wage legislation keeps the wage from falling below a set level, so it is a price floor. Ration coupons and fair price shops go with a price ceiling.
-
4. Under an agricultural price support of ₹50 per kg, farmers supply 900 kg and buyers demand 700 kg (illustrative). If the government buys the surplus, it spends:
- ₹10,000
- ₹35,000
- ₹45,000
- ₹200
Show answer
Answer: A. Surplus = 900 − 700 = 200 kg. Cost = 200 × 50 = ₹10,000.
-
5. Assertion (A): A price ceiling below the equilibrium price may lead to a black market. Reason (R): At the ceiling, some consumers cannot get as much as they want and are willing to pay a higher price.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true. The ceiling creates excess demand; unsatisfied consumers are willing to pay more, which can give rise to illegal sales at higher prices. R explains A.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.