• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Market equilibrium with free entry and exit

Explain why free entry and exit make the equilibrium price equal to minimum average cost, find the equilibrium quantity and number of firms, and compare the effect of a demand shift with that under a fixed number of firms.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why, with free entry and exit, every firm earns only normal profit and p = min AC.
  • Calculate the equilibrium price, quantity and number of firms n0 = q0/q0f.
  • Explain how a demand shift changes quantity and the number of firms but not price, and compare with a fixed number of firms.

So far the number of firms was fixed. Now suppose firms can enter and exit freely, and for simplicity all firms are identical (same cost structure). This one assumption changes the result dramatically.

Why price must equal minimum average cost

Recall from Chapter 4: a firm earns super-normal profit when price is above its minimum average cost and less than normal profit when price is below it. Now follow what free entry and exit do.

Entry when firms earn super-normal profit

  1. Price above min AC Firms earn super-normal profit
  2. New firms enter Attracted by the profit
  3. Market supply shifts right Demand unchanged, so price falls
  4. Price reaches min AC Only normal profit; entry stops

Similarly, if price is below minimum AC, firms earn less than normal profit, some exit, market supply shifts left, price rises, and exit stops once price is back at minimum AC. At a price equal to minimum AC, every firm earns exactly normal profit: no new firm wants to enter and no existing firm wants to leave. So with free entry and exit:

Free entry and exit: equilibrium price p0 = minimum average cost of the (identical) firms; equilibrium quantity q0 = market demand at p0; equilibrium number of firms n0 = q0 / q0f, where q0f is each firm's output at p0.

On a diagram, the market is in equilibrium where the demand curve DD meets the horizontal line p = min AC. Each firm produces the same amount q0f at that price, and the number of firms is whatever is needed to supply the quantity demanded.

Worked example 1: price, quantity and number of firms (illustrative)

In a made-up market for clay lamps, market demand is qD = 520 − 4p (p in ₹ per box). All firms are identical, with minimum average cost ₹30 and supply qf = p − 10 for p ≥ 30 (zero below ₹30). Working: p0 = min AC = ₹30. Quantity demanded at ₹30: q0 = 520 − 4 × 30 = 520 − 120 = 400 boxes. Each firm supplies q0f = 30 − 10 = 20 boxes. Number of firms n0 = 400 ÷ 20 = 20 firms.

Demand shifts with free entry and exit

Suppose demand shifts right. At p0 there is excess demand, price tends to rise, and firms start earning super-normal profit. This attracts new firms, whose entry pushes price back down to p0. The new equilibrium has the same price p0, a larger quantity, and more firms. If demand shifts left, at p0 there is excess supply, price tends to fall, some firms exit, and price returns to p0 with a smaller quantity and fewer firms.

Worked example 2: a rightward demand shift (illustrative)

In the clay-lamp market, demand rises to qD = 640 − 4p. Working: price stays at p0 = ₹30. New quantity = 640 − 120 = 520 boxes. Each firm still supplies 20 boxes, so the number of firms = 520 ÷ 20 = 26 firms, i.e. 26 − 20 = 6 new firms enter. Quantity rose by 520 − 400 = 120 boxes while price did not change.

Comparing the two cases

Effect of a rightward demand shift
Rightward demand shiftFixed number of firmsFree entry and exit
Equilibrium priceRisesUnchanged at min AC
Equilibrium quantityRisesRises by more
Number of firmsUnchangedRises
Profit of each firm after adjustmentMay be super-normalOnly normal profit

As the book points out, with free entry and exit a shift in demand has a larger effect on quantity than with a fixed number of firms, but no effect on price at all. With a fixed number of firms, part of the increase in demand is absorbed by a higher price, which chokes off some of the extra quantity; with free entry, new firms supply the extra quantity at the unchanged price.

Worked example 3: a leftward demand shift (illustrative)

If demand in the clay-lamp market falls to qD = 440 − 4p, then at ₹30 quantity = 440 − 120 = 320 boxes and the number of firms = 320 ÷ 20 = 16. So 20 − 16 = 4 firms leave, and the price is still ₹30.

Key takeaways: with free entry and exit of identical firms, super-normal profits attract entry and losses cause exit until p = min AC and every firm earns only normal profit. Quantity is read off the demand curve at that price, and the number of firms is q0/q0f. A demand shift changes quantity and the number of firms but leaves price unchanged, and changes quantity by more than with a fixed number of firms.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. With free entry and exit of identical firms, the equilibrium price equals:

    1. Maximum average cost
    2. Minimum average variable cost
    3. Minimum average cost
    4. Marginal revenue at zero output
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Entry removes super-normal profit and exit removes losses, so price settles where firms earn only normal profit - at minimum average cost.

  2. 2. Illustrative demand qD = 300 − 5p; identical firms have min AC ₹20 and each supplies 10 units at that price. How many firms are there in equilibrium?

    1. 10
    2. 20
    3. 30
    4. 200
    Show answer

    Answer: B. p0 = ₹20. q0 = 300 − 5 × 20 = 200. Number of firms = 200 ÷ 10 = 20.

  3. 3. With free entry and exit, a rightward shift of demand leads to:

    1. Higher price and the same number of firms
    2. Lower price and fewer firms
    3. No change in quantity
    4. The same price, a larger quantity and more firms
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Super-normal profit at the higher price attracts new firms until price returns to min AC. The extra quantity demanded is supplied by more firms at the same price.

  4. 4. Case: In a made-up market with free entry and exit, firms are earning less than normal profit. What will happen?

    1. Some firms will exit, supply will fall and price will rise to min AC
    2. New firms will enter
    3. Price will fall further
    4. Every firm will earn super-normal profit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. With profit below normal, some firms leave. Market supply shifts left, price rises, and exit stops once price is back at min AC with normal profit.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): With free entry and exit, a demand shift has no effect on the equilibrium price. Reason (R): With free entry and exit, the number of firms cannot change.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is true: price always returns to minimum AC. R is false: the whole point of free entry and exit is that the number of firms changes - it is entry and exit that keep the price at min AC.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery