- Foundation
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Writing: a report on a roadside business and a debate on balanced development
Write a newspaper or magazine report after a visit to a roadside eatery, using a worked model, prepare a debate on balanced development of villages and cities, and plan long answers on the poem.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Use report format: heading, byline, place and date, body in the past tense.
- Present observations objectively.
- Structure debate points for or against a motion.
- Plan long answers on the poem's criticism of 'help'.
The textbook suggests observing a roadside eatery and discussing whether a country's well-being depends on balanced development of villages and cities. Both lead to standard writing tasks: a report and a debate.
Format of a report
| Part | What to write |
|---|---|
| Heading | Short and informative. |
| Byline | By ... (a made-up name). |
| Place and date line | Begins the first paragraph, e.g. Rampur, 10 January. |
| Opening paragraph | What, who, when, where - the key facts. |
| Body | Details and observations, in the past tense, objective. |
| Closing | Outcome, a quote or the way forward. |
Model report (original; names and places are made up)
Students Study Life at a Highway Dhaba
By Tanvi Joshi, Class XII
Rampur, 10 January: Twenty students of Class XII of Sunrise Public School (a made-up school) visited a family-run dhaba on the national highway outside town on Saturday as part of a project on rural livelihoods. The visit was guided by their English teacher.
The students spent three hours at the dhaba and kept a simple record. They noted that most of the customers were truck drivers who ate full meals, while several private cars stopped only to ask for directions. The owners described their long working day, which starts before sunrise, and explained that they buy vegetables from small farmers nearby. They said they wanted better signboards and more customers, not handouts.
The students later presented their findings in the school assembly. Their teacher said the visit had helped them see a roadside business as a source of livelihood for many people. The class plans to write to the local authority suggesting clearer signboards for small roadside businesses.
(The visit, people and observations in this model are invented for practice; a real report would use your own records.)
Debate: balanced development
Motion (for practice): A country prospers only when its villages develop along with its cities. A debate has a greeting, a clear statement of your side, three points with reasons and examples, a rebuttal of the other side, and a strong conclusion.
Possible points
-
For the motion
- Villages supply food and raw materials to cities
- Unbalanced growth pushes people to crowded cities
- Fair markets for rural produce strengthen the whole economy
- Dignity: rural people want to earn, not to be pitied
-
Against the motion (to rebut)
- Cities create most new jobs and industry
- Investment should go where returns are fastest
- Rural people can move to cities for work
Worked example 1: a rebuttal
Opponent: People can simply move to the cities. Rebuttal: My opponent forgets that cities are already crowded, and that moving breaks families and destroys rural skills. Development should reach people where they live, not force them to leave.
Worked example 2: long answer on 'help'
Question (in our words): how does the poet show that official help does the poor no good? Plan: (1) the people are to be bought out and moved without being asked; (2) oxymorons for the helpers, such as greedy good-doers and the beasts of prey called beneficent; (3) benefits are enforced and dull their minds; (4) they lose their natural way of life. Conclude: Frost exposes help that serves the helpers and robs the poor of independence.
Report = what, who, when, where, in the past tense, without personal opinion.
Key takeaways: a report gives facts objectively in the past tense with a heading, byline and place-date line. A debate argues one side with reasons, examples and rebuttal. Long answers on the poem should explain how irony and oxymoron expose false help.
Check your understanding
-
1. In which tense is a report usually written?
- Future
- Past
- Present continuous only
- Conditional
Show answer
Answer: B. A report describes an event that has happened, so it is written mainly in the past tense.
-
2. What belongs in the opening paragraph of a report?
- The writer's personal feelings
- A poem
- The key facts: what, who, when and where
- A question to the reader
Show answer
Answer: C. The opening paragraph gives the essential facts; details follow in the body.
-
3. Which is a rebuttal?
- My opponent forgets that cities are already crowded.
- Good morning to all.
- Thank you for listening.
- My first point is that villages matter.
Show answer
Answer: A. A rebuttal answers the opponent's argument directly.
-
4. Which point supports the motion that villages must develop along with cities?
- Cities have tall buildings.
- Investment should go only to cities.
- Rural people do not need markets.
- Villages supply food and raw materials on which cities depend.
Show answer
Answer: D. This shows cities and villages are linked, supporting balanced development.
-
5. Which phrase from the poem would best support an answer about false help?
- Wild berries in wooden boxes
- Greedy good-doers
- The squeal of brakes
- A little new shed
Show answer
Answer: B. Greedy good-doers is an oxymoron showing that the helpers are self-interested - evidence of false help.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.