Two views of the interview
-
For
- A source of truth
- An art, at its best
- A very useful medium of communication
- Our main source of vivid impressions of famous people
-
Against
- An intrusion into private life
- Diminishes the person interviewed
- Can wound and take away part of oneself
- Called immoral, even a crime, by some
| Writer | Attitude to interviews |
|---|---|
| V. S. Naipaul | Felt some people are hurt by interviews and lose part of themselves. |
| Lewis Carroll | Creator of Alice in Wonderland; dreaded interviewers and never agreed to be interviewed, partly because he hated being made a celebrity. |
| Rudyard Kipling | Told two Boston reporters (in 1892, recorded in his wife Caroline's diary) that interviewing was immoral, a crime like an assault - though he had himself interviewed Mark Twain a few years before. |
| H. G. Wells | Spoke of the interviewing ordeal in 1894, yet was often interviewed, and forty years later interviewed Joseph Stalin. |
| Saul Bellow | Agreed to interviews several times, but compared them to thumbprints on his windpipe. |
| Denis Brian | Said that almost everything important reaches us through one person questioning another, so the interviewer has great power and influence. |
The interview: valued as a source of truth, resented as an intrusion.
Key takeaways: Part I surveys opinions on the interview. Learn each writer's view, the irony in Kipling and Wells, the meaning of Bellow's image and Denis Brian's point about the interviewer's power.