• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Interview, Part I: Christopher Silvester on the interview

Know Christopher Silvester and his introduction to a book of interviews, and explain the range of opinions - from praise to horror - that writers have held about being interviewed.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Say who Christopher Silvester is and where Part I comes from.
  • List the positive and negative views of the interview.
  • Explain each writer's attitude: Naipaul, Carroll, Kipling, Wells, Bellow and Denis Brian.
  • Explain the expression thumbprints on his windpipe.

The Interview has two parts. Part I is an excerpt from Christopher Silvester's introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews, an anthology of interviews from 1859 to the present. Silvester (born 1959) studied history at Peterhouse, Cambridge, worked for ten years as a reporter for the magazine Private Eye and has written features for Vanity Fair. Part II is an interview with the Italian scholar and novelist Umberto Eco by Mukund Padmanabhan of The Hindu (lesson 2).

The interview: a short history, mixed reputation

In our own words: the interview was invented in the nineteenth century and is now an everyday part of journalism. Almost every literate person has read one, and thousands of celebrities have given them. So opinions differ. Some praise the interview as a source of truth and even an art. Others, especially celebrities who feel like its victims, resent it as an uninvited intrusion on their privacy, or feel it somehow makes them smaller - much as people in some traditional cultures believed that a photograph steals a person's soul.

Two views of the interview

  • For
    • A source of truth
    • An art, at its best
    • A very useful medium of communication
    • Our main source of vivid impressions of famous people
  • Against
    • An intrusion into private life
    • Diminishes the person interviewed
    • Can wound and take away part of oneself
    • Called immoral, even a crime, by some

What famous writers said (in our own words)

Notice the irony: several critics of interviews also gave or conducted them.
WriterAttitude to interviews
V. S. NaipaulFelt some people are hurt by interviews and lose part of themselves.
Lewis CarrollCreator of Alice in Wonderland; dreaded interviewers and never agreed to be interviewed, partly because he hated being made a celebrity.
Rudyard KiplingTold two Boston reporters (in 1892, recorded in his wife Caroline's diary) that interviewing was immoral, a crime like an assault - though he had himself interviewed Mark Twain a few years before.
H. G. WellsSpoke of the interviewing ordeal in 1894, yet was often interviewed, and forty years later interviewed Joseph Stalin.
Saul BellowAgreed to interviews several times, but compared them to thumbprints on his windpipe.
Denis BrianSaid that almost everything important reaches us through one person questioning another, so the interviewer has great power and influence.

Thumbprints on his windpipe

The windpipe carries air to the lungs. Thumbprints on it suggest someone pressing on your throat - being choked or strangled. Bellow meant that interviews made him feel suffocated and under pressure, as if his freedom to breathe and speak naturally were being squeezed.

Worked example 1: a two-sided answer

Question: what are some positive views of interviews, and why do many celebrity writers dislike them? Model answer: supporters see the interview as a source of truth and, at its best, an art; Denis Brian notes that it gives us our most vivid impressions of famous people. Many celebrity writers, however, feel it intrudes on their privacy, makes them feel smaller, and can wound them, as Naipaul suggests; Kipling even called it immoral.

Worked example 2: identifying irony

Question: what is ironic about Kipling's and Wells's attitudes? Working: compare what each said with what each did. Answer: Kipling condemned interviewing as a crime, though he had interviewed Mark Twain; Wells called it an ordeal, though he gave many interviews and later interviewed Stalin. Their actions contradicted their words.

The interview: valued as a source of truth, resented as an intrusion.

Key takeaways: Part I surveys opinions on the interview. Learn each writer's view, the irony in Kipling and Wells, the meaning of Bellow's image and Denis Brian's point about the interviewer's power.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Part I of 'The Interview' is taken from

    1. a novel by Umberto Eco
    2. an article in The Hindu
    3. Christopher Silvester's introduction to The Penguin Book of Interviews
    4. Kipling's diary
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Part I is an excerpt from Silvester's introduction to an anthology of interviews.

  2. 2. What belief from some traditional cultures does Silvester mention?

    1. That taking someone's photograph steals their soul
    2. That interviews bring luck
    3. That writers should not speak
    4. That reporters are magicians
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He compares celebrities' sense of being diminished by interviews to the belief that photographs steal the soul.

  3. 3. Which writer never agreed to be interviewed?

    1. H. G. Wells
    2. Rudyard Kipling
    3. Saul Bellow
    4. Lewis Carroll
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Lewis Carroll dreaded interviewers and never consented to an interview.

  4. 4. What does 'thumbprints on his windpipe' suggest?

    1. Interviews were enjoyable
    2. Interviews felt suffocating, like being choked
    3. Bellow liked fingerprints
    4. Interviews were about crime
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Pressure on the windpipe means choking; Bellow found interviews stifling.

  5. 5. According to Denis Brian, why does the interviewer hold great power?

    1. Interviewers are rich
    2. Almost everything important reaches us through one person questioning another
    3. Interviewers write novels
    4. Celebrities obey interviewers
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Since most of what we learn about important people comes through interviews, the interviewer shapes our impressions.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery