- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
The Interview, Part II: Umberto Eco on writing, time and success
Follow Mukund Padmanabhan's interview with Umberto Eco and explain Eco's ideas about interstices, his narrative style of scholarship, how he sees himself and why The Name of the Rose succeeded.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Say who Umberto Eco was and who interviewed him.
- Explain how Eco finds time to write so much.
- Describe his distinctive academic style and its origin.
- Explain whether he sees himself as a novelist or a scholar, and his view of the novel's success.
Part II is an extract from an interview of Umberto Eco by Mukund Padmanabhan of The Hindu. Eco was a professor at the University of Bologna in Italy, already famous for scholarship on semiotics (how signs carry meaning), on how texts are interpreted and on the art and ideas of the Middle Ages; only later did he write fiction. His first novel, The Name of the Rose (1980), made him an intellectual superstar.
1. Always doing the same thing
The interviewer mentions the novelist David Lodge's wonder at how much Eco does. Eco replies that he only seems to do many things: through academic work, novels and even children's books (which deal with peace and non-violence) he pursues the same set of philosophical and ethical interests.
2. The secret: interstices
Eco explains with an image: remove all the empty space from the universe and it would shrink to the size of a fist. Our lives, too, contain many empty spaces, which he calls interstices - moments of waiting. He works in them: in the time a guest's lift takes to rise a couple of floors, he says jokingly, he has already written an article.
How Eco uses interstices
- A gap appears Waiting for a lift, a guest, a meeting.
- He uses it Thinks, drafts, writes.
- Small pieces add up Articles, chapters, books.
- More gaps noticed The habit grows.
Then back to step 1: A gap appears
3. Scholarship as a story
Eco's non-fiction is playful and personal, unlike the usual dry, impersonal academic style. He traces this to his doctoral dissertation: a professor observed that, instead of presenting only conclusions, Eco had told the story of his research, trials and errors included - and still published it as a book. At 22, Eco decided scholarly books should be written that way. This narrative habit, he says, may explain why he began writing novels so late, at about 50: his essays already satisfied his love of storytelling. Unlike his friend Roland Barthes, who wished to be a novelist but died before he could, Eco felt no frustration; he began novels almost by accident.
4. Professor first
Eco has written five novels and over forty scholarly works, including an important one on semiotics, but most people know him as a novelist. This bothers him: he sees himself as a professor first, who writes fiction only on Sundays, attends academic conferences rather than writers' meetings, and identifies with the academic community. Still, he accepts that novels reach a far larger audience than books on semiotics.
5. Why did The Name of the Rose succeed?
- The novel is serious: a detective story that also explores metaphysics, theology and medieval history.
- Eco is not puzzled by its success; journalists and publishers are, because they assume people want only easy reading.
- He argues that among the world's billions there are millions of readers who do not always want easy experiences - though he himself enjoys light television after dinner, just not all day.
- His American publisher expected about 3,000 copies; it sold two to three million in the US.
- Finally he calls its success a mystery: the timing mattered; ten years earlier or later, it might not have worked.
Worked example 1: does Eco like being interviewed?
Model answer: yes, he appears to. He answers at length, tells stories and anecdotes, jokes about writing an article while a lift comes up, laughs and shrugs, and even corrects the interviewer's figures ('over 40'). His relaxed, frank replies suggest he is comfortable and enjoys the conversation.
Worked example 2: novelist or scholar?
Model answer: Eco considered himself first an academic. He described himself as a professor first, who wrote fiction only on Sundays, preferred academic conferences to writers' meetings and identified with the academic community. Being known mainly as a novelist bothered him, though he accepted that novels brought him a wider readership.
Interstices: the empty spaces of a day, filled with work.
Key takeaways: Eco pursues the same philosophical interests in all his work, writes in life's interstices, tells the story of his research, sees himself as a professor first, and calls his novel's success a mystery of timing.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who interviewed Umberto Eco?
- Christopher Silvester
- Mukund Padmanabhan of The Hindu
- David Lodge
- Roland Barthes
Show answer
Answer: B. The interviewer in Part II is Mukund Padmanabhan of The Hindu.
-
2. What does Eco mean by 'interstices'?
- Long holidays
- Empty spaces or waiting moments in daily life that he uses for work
- Chapters of a novel
- Gaps in an argument
Show answer
Answer: B. He uses the short empty spaces in his day - such as waiting for a lift - to write.
-
3. How was Eco's scholarly writing different from the usual academic style?
- It was dry and impersonal
- It was in verse
- It had no conclusions
- It told the story of his research, including trials and errors
Show answer
Answer: D. A professor noted he narrated his research process; Eco adopted this narrative style.
-
4. At about what age did Eco begin writing novels?
- 50
- 30
- 22
- 70
Show answer
Answer: A. He says he started writing novels late, at around 50.
-
5. How did Eco finally explain the success of The Name of the Rose?
- Clever advertising
- Its low price
- As a mystery that depended partly on timing
- Its simple language
Show answer
Answer: C. He said nobody could predict it; written ten years earlier or later, it might not have succeeded.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.