• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Human geography within geography: nature, people and the dualism debates

See how human geography grows out of geography as a discipline, why nature and human beings are studied together, which debates divided geographers, and why the book treats the physical-human split as not very valid.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe geography as integrative, empirical and practical, and name its two major components.
  • State what physical geography and human geography each study.
  • Explain the dualisms in geography and why the book says nature and humans should be seen holistically.

This is the opening chapter of Fundamentals of Human Geography. In Class 11 you met geography as a discipline and its branches. Now the focus shifts to one great branch: the study of human beings on the surface of the earth. Before learning about population, economic activities, transport and trade, you need a clear idea of what human geography is, what it is not, and the arguments that shaped it.

Geography: integrative, empirical and practical

The book reminds you that geography as a field of study is integrative (it brings together knowledge from many fields), empirical (it rests on observation of the real world) and practical (it is useful for solving problems). Because of this, its reach is very wide: any event or phenomenon that varies over space and time can be studied geographically. Rainfall varies over space, and so do literacy, the price of land, the number of buses on a road and the crops in a field.

Look at the earth's surface and you will find two major components. One is nature, the physical environment of landforms, soils, climate, water, natural vegetation, plants and animals. The other is life forms, including human beings, together with everything people have built. Physical geography studies the physical environment. Human geography studies the relationship between the natural and human worlds, how human phenomena are spread over space and how those patterns come about, and the social and economic differences between different parts of the world.

Geography and its two major components

  • Physical geography Studies the physical environment.
    • Landforms
    • Soils
    • Climate
    • Water
    • Natural vegetation, flora and fauna
  • Human geography Studies people in relation to the earth's surface.
    • Relationship between natural and human worlds
    • Spatial distribution of human phenomena
    • Social and economic differences between regions
Both branches belong to one discipline whose core concern is the earth as the home of human beings.

The core concern and the debates it caused

The core concern of geography is to understand the earth as the home of human beings and to study all the elements that have sustained them. Because the discipline looks at both nature and people, it became subject to dualism: a series of either-or debates. The book lists three of them.

The three dualisms named in the chapter
DebateOne sideOther side
What kind of knowledge should geography produce?Law-making or theorising (nomothetic)Descriptive (idiographic)
How should subject matter be organised and studied?Regional approachSystematic approach
How should geographical phenomena be interpreted?TheoreticallyThrough a historic-institutional approach

These questions were useful intellectual exercises, but the book concludes that the dichotomy between physical and human is not a very valid one, because nature and human beings are inseparable and should be seen holistically. A flood is a physical event, yet its damage depends on where people have built houses; a city is a human creation, yet it changes local temperature and drainage.

Human geography studies how the natural and human worlds are related, how human phenomena are distributed over space and why, and how parts of the world differ socially and economically. Nature and people are inseparable and are best seen as one whole.

Nature described in human terms

A neat sign of how closely people link the two worlds is the language we use. Physical features are often described with words taken from the human body: the face of the earth, the eye of a storm, the mouth of a river, the snout of a glacier, the neck of an isthmus and the profile of a soil. Human creations, in turn, are described as living things: regions, villages and towns have been called organisms, German geographers described the state as a living organism, and networks of roads, railways and waterways are called arteries of circulation. If we speak of nature as if it were a body, and of our settlements as if they were alive, it becomes hard to separate the two.

ExpressionPart of the body usedWhat it describes
Mouth of a riverMouthWhere a river meets a sea or lake
Snout of a glacierNoseThe front end of a glacier
Neck of an isthmusNeckThe narrow strip of land joining two larger land masses
Eye of a stormEyeThe calm centre of a cyclone
Arteries of circulationBlood vesselsRoad, rail and water networks that carry people and goods

Worked example 1: physical or human component?

Classify these features of a made-up hill town: a river valley, a terraced tea garden, a pine forest, a bus stand, a landslide scar, a hydroelectric dam.

Step 1: ask whether the feature exists without human effort. Step 2: if people made or shaped it, it belongs to the human (cultural) side. Answer: physical components are the river valley, the pine forest and the landslide scar; human components are the tea garden, the bus stand and the dam. Notice that the tea garden is built on a physical slope and the dam uses a physical river, which is exactly why the book says the two cannot really be separated.

Worked example 2: spotting the dualism

Two made-up researchers study the same district. Researcher X describes its villages, crops and festivals in rich detail to show what makes it unique. Researcher Y collects data from fifty districts to find a general rule linking rainfall and crop choice. Which side of the nomothetic-idiographic debate does each take?

X describes the unique character of one place, which is the idiographic (descriptive) approach. Y looks for a general law that applies to many places, which is the nomothetic (law-making) approach. The book's point is that geography needs both: rules help explain, and description keeps the uniqueness of places in view.

Key takeaways: geography is integrative, empirical and practical, and anything varying over space and time can be studied geographically. The earth has two major components, nature and life forms including human beings. Human geography studies their relationship, the spatial distribution of human phenomena and the differences between regions. Debates over nomothetic versus idiographic, regional versus systematic and theoretical versus historic-institutional approaches created dualism, but nature and humans are inseparable and should be seen holistically, as even our everyday metaphors show.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A geographer describes geography as integrative, empirical and practical. Which feature does 'empirical' refer to?

    1. It combines many fields of knowledge
    2. It is based on observation of the real world
    3. It is used to solve everyday problems
    4. It produces only general laws
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Empirical knowledge rests on observation and evidence from the real world. Combining fields is the integrative quality and solving problems is the practical quality.

  2. 2. A geographer who aims to frame general laws that apply to many places follows which approach?

    1. Idiographic
    2. Historic-institutional
    3. Nomothetic
    4. Descriptive
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Nomothetic means law-making or theorising. Idiographic, which is the same as descriptive, concentrates on the unique features of particular places.

  3. 3. Which expression describes a human creation as if it were part of a living body?

    1. Snout of a glacier
    2. Mouth of a river
    3. Eye of a storm
    4. Arteries of circulation
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Arteries of circulation describes road, rail and water networks, which are human creations, as blood vessels. The other three use body words for natural features.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): The book says the dichotomy between physical and human geography is not a very valid one.
    Reason (R): Nature and human beings are inseparable elements that should be seen holistically.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true but R is false.
    4. A is false but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter rejects a sharp physical-human split precisely because nature and humans are intertwined, so R correctly explains A.

  5. 5. Which of these is studied by human geography according to the chapter?

    1. The social and economic differences between different parts of the world
    2. Only the landforms of the earth
    3. Only the history of ancient empires
    4. The chemical composition of rocks
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says human geography studies the relationship between the natural and human worlds, the spatial distribution of human phenomena and the social and economic differences between parts of the world.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery