- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Naturalisation of humans and humanisation of nature
Understand how technology shapes human interaction with nature, and compare environmental determinism, where nature dictates, with possibilism, where people create possibilities and leave a cultural landscape.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why technology is the key to human interaction with the physical environment.
- Describe environmental determinism and the idea of the naturalised human.
- Describe possibilism, the cultural landscape and the humanisation of nature.
Why does a forest-dwelling community revere a river spirit while a city-dweller in a cold country eats tropical fruit flown in from far away? The chapter answers with one word: technology. How much a society depends on nature depends largely on the tools and techniques it has.
Technology as the link between people and nature
Human beings interact with their physical environment through technology. The book stresses that what people produce is less important than with the help of what tools and techniques they produce it. Technology indicates the level of cultural development of a society.
People could develop technology only after they understood natural laws better. The chapter's examples: understanding friction and heat helped humans discover fire; understanding DNA and genetics helped conquer many diseases; the laws of aerodynamics are used to build faster planes. So knowledge of nature leads to technology, and technology loosens the shackles of the environment on human beings.
From knowledge of nature to freedom from it
- Observe nature People study how natural forces behave.
- Understand natural laws Friction and heat, genetics, aerodynamics.
- Develop technology Fire, medicines, aircraft.
- Loosen environmental limits People depend less directly on their immediate surroundings.
Environmental determinism: the naturalised human
In the early stages of interaction, humans were greatly influenced by their natural environment and adapted to the dictates of nature, because their technology was very low and their social development was primitive. This kind of interaction between primitive human society and strong natural forces was termed environmental determinism. At this stage we can imagine a naturalised human who listened to nature, feared its fury and worshipped it.
The chapter illustrates this with a story of a boy of a forest community in the Abujh Maad area of central India. In our own summary: his people practise shifting cultivation, burning small forest patches and using the ash to enrich the soil; they gather herbs and plants from the forest for their own use and to barter at a tribal fair; and they thank the spirit of the forest before drinking from a stream. For such economically primitive societies, the dependence on nature for resources is direct, nature is worshipped, revered and conserved, and the physical environment becomes Mother Nature.
Possibilism: the humanisation of nature
With time, people understand their environment better. With social and cultural development they build better and more efficient technology and move from a state of necessity to a state of freedom. They create possibilities with the resources the environment offers. Human activities create a cultural landscape, and the imprints of human work are seen everywhere: health resorts on highlands, huge urban sprawls, fields, orchards and pastures in plains and rolling hills, ports on coasts, routes across the oceans and satellites in space. Earlier scholars called this possibilism: nature provides opportunities, people use them, and nature slowly gets humanised.
The chapter's second story, again in our own summary, describes a woman working in Trondheim, a Norwegian town of long dark winters, heavy snow and fierce winds. Winter tyres, a heated office, a university campus under a glass dome, tropical fruit flown in from warmer lands, instant computer links with colleagues in New Delhi and same-day flights to London all show technology overcoming the constraints of nature.
| Point | Environmental determinism | Possibilism |
|---|---|---|
| Level of technology | Very low | High and improving |
| Who dominates | Nature dictates; people adapt | People use the opportunities nature offers |
| State of society | Necessity | Freedom |
| Typical image | The naturalised human who fears and worships nature | Humanised nature bearing the imprints of human effort |
| Chapter's illustration | Forest community of Abujh Maad | Life in Trondheim |
Environmental determinism: with little technology, nature dictates and people adapt. Possibilism: as technology improves, nature offers opportunities that people use, leaving a cultural landscape on a humanised nature.
Worked example 1: which idea fits?
Case A (made up): a desert herding group moves its camels between fixed wells as the seasons dictate and has no way to store water. Case B (made up): a desert city pumps groundwater, desalinates seawater and grows vegetables in climate-controlled greenhouses.
In Case A the community has little technology and must follow the dictates of nature, so it illustrates environmental determinism and the naturalised human. In Case B technology has turned a dry environment into a place of possibilities, so it illustrates possibilism and the humanisation of nature.
Worked example 2: reading a cultural landscape
List evidence of humanised nature you could see on a made-up train journey from a plain to a hill station.
Step 1: think of what people have added to each landscape. Plains: irrigated fields, orchards, canals, towns. Slopes: terraced fields, a railway cut into the hillside, tunnels. Hill top: hotels and a health resort. Step 2: each is an imprint of human effort on nature, which together form a cultural landscape, the evidence the book uses for possibilism.
Key takeaways: technology, based on understanding natural laws, decides how people interact with nature. With little technology, people adapted to nature's dictates; this is environmental determinism and the naturalised human. With better technology, people moved from necessity to freedom and created possibilities, leaving a cultural landscape; this is possibilism and the humanisation of nature.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the chapter, what is most important in the interaction between people and the environment?
- What people produce
- Human brotherhood
- People's religion
- The tools and techniques with which people produce
Show answer
Answer: D. The book says it is not important what people produce but with the help of what tools and techniques, that is technology, they produce and create.
-
2. The understanding of friction and heat helped human beings to:
- discover fire
- build faster planes
- conquer diseases
- launch satellites
Show answer
Answer: A. The chapter links friction and heat to the discovery of fire; genetics is linked to medicine and aerodynamics to faster planes.
-
3. Source: 'A family burns a small patch of forest, uses the ash to enrich the soil, and thanks the forest spirit for every meal it gathers.' Which concept does this source best illustrate?
- Possibilism
- Environmental determinism
- Neo-determinism
- Quantitative revolution
Show answer
Answer: B. Low technology and direct, reverent dependence on nature describe the naturalised human of environmental determinism.
-
4. Assertion (A): Under possibilism, nature bears the imprints of human endeavour.
Reason (R): With better technology, people move from a state of necessity to a state of freedom and use the opportunities nature provides.- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
- A is true but R is false.
- A is false but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: A. Because technology lets people use nature's opportunities, they create a cultural landscape, which is the imprint on nature; R explains A.
-
5. Which of the following is NOT one of the imprints of human activity listed as part of the cultural landscape?
- Health resorts on highlands
- Ports on the coasts
- Fold mountains formed by plate collision
- Satellites in space
Show answer
Answer: C. Fold mountains are formed by natural tectonic forces. Resorts, ports and satellites are human imprints that the chapter gives as examples of the cultural landscape.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.