• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

Discovering the Harappan civilisation and problems of interpretation

Trace how the civilisation was discovered, from Cunningham to Marshall and Wheeler, explain stratigraphy, and analyse how archaeologists classify finds and the problems in reconstructing Harappan religion.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why Cunningham missed the significance of Harappa and how Sahni, Banerji and Marshall revealed a new civilisation.
  • Define a mound, layers and stratigraphy and compare the methods of Marshall and Wheeler.
  • Explain how finds are classified and why reconstructions of Harappan religion remain speculative.

When the Harappan cities fell into ruin they were forgotten. People living in the area much later found strange objects washed out by floods or turned up by ploughs, without knowing what they were. The story of how archaeologists recognised them is also a lesson in how frameworks of thinking shape what we can see.

Cunningham's confusion

Alexander Cunningham, first Director-General of the ASI, began excavations in the mid-nineteenth century, when archaeologists preferred written texts and inscriptions as guides. His main interest was the Early Historic period (c. sixth century BCE to fourth century CE) and later. He used the accounts of Chinese Buddhist pilgrims who visited between the fourth and seventh centuries CE to locate early settlements, and collected and translated inscriptions. Harappa was not on the pilgrims' routes and was not a known Early Historic city. When an Englishman gave him a Harappan seal, he tried, unsuccessfully, to fit it into the time-frame he knew, because he, like many others, believed Indian history began with the first cities of the Ganga valley.

A new old civilisation

In the early twentieth century Daya Ram Sahni found seals at Harappa in layers much older than Early Historic levels. Rakhal Das Banerji found similar seals at Mohenjodaro, suggesting one archaeological culture. In 1924 John Marshall, Director-General of the ASI, announced a new civilisation in the Indus valley. Similar seals had been found in Mesopotamia, so the world learnt of a civilisation contemporary with Mesopotamia. As one writer put it, Marshall 'left India three thousand years older than he had found her'.

Mounds, layers and stratigraphy

Continuous living at one place builds up occupational debris, called a mound. Occupations show as layers that differ in colour, texture and artefacts; abandonment leaves sterile layers without such traces. Generally the lowest layers are the oldest and the highest the most recent. The study of these layers is stratigraphy, and assigning artefacts to layers gives a site's cultural sequence.

Two Directors-General, two methods

  • John Marshall
    • First professional archaeologist to work in India
    • Brought experience from Greece and Crete
    • Interested in spectacular finds and in patterns of everyday life
    • Dug in uniform horizontal units, ignoring stratigraphy
    • Finds from different layers were grouped together, so context was lost
  • R.E.M. Wheeler
    • Director-General from 1944
    • Followed the stratigraphy of the mound instead of mechanical horizontal digging
    • An ex-army brigadier who brought military precision to archaeology

After 1947 and since the 1980s

Harappan frontiers have little to do with modern borders, but after Partition the major known sites lay in Pakistan. This spurred Indian archaeologists to locate sites in India: surveys in Kutch, Punjab and Haryana added many, and Kalibangan, Lothal, Rakhigarhi and most recently Dholavira were explored and excavated. New questions arose: some seek cultural sequences, others the logic of site locations or the functions of artefacts. Since the 1980s international teams have worked jointly at Harappa and Mohenjodaro with scientific techniques.

Selected landmarks from the textbook's timeline of Harappan archaeology
YearEvent
1875Report of Alexander Cunningham on a Harappan seal
1921Daya Ram Sahni begins excavations at Harappa
1922Excavations begin at Mohenjodaro
1946R.E.M. Wheeler excavates at Harappa
1955S.R. Rao begins excavations at Lothal
1960B.B. Lal and B.K. Thapar begin excavations at Kalibangan
1990R.S. Bisht begins excavations at Dholavira
1997Amrendra Nath starts excavations at Rakhigarhi
2013Vasant Shinde begins archaeogenetic research at Rakhigarhi

Problems of piecing together the past

It is material evidence, not the script, that reconstructs Harappan life. Organic materials (cloth, leather, wood, reeds) usually decay, especially in the tropics; stone, terracotta and metal survive. Only broken or useless things were thrown away; the rest was recycled. So valuable objects found intact were lost or hoarded and never retrieved; such finds are accidental rather than typical.

  1. Classify by material: stone, clay, metal, bone, ivory and so on (the simple principle).
  2. Classify by function: tool, ornament, both, or ritual object (the harder principle).
  3. Use resemblance: beads, querns, blades and pots resemble present-day things.
  4. Use context: was it found in a house, a drain, a grave or a kiln?
  5. Use indirect evidence: for clothing, besides traces of cotton, archaeologists rely on sculpture.
  6. Build frames of reference: the first seal made sense only with a cultural sequence and comparison with Mesopotamian finds.

Reconstructing religion

Early archaeologists gave religious meaning to unusual objects: jewelled terracotta female figurines were called mother goddesses; stone men in a standard seated posture, like the 'priest-king', were classed similarly; the Great Bath and fire altars at Kalibangan and Lothal were seen as ritual structures. Seals with ritual scenes or plant motifs suggested nature worship; the one-horned 'unicorn' seems a mythical, composite creature. A seated cross-legged figure in a 'yogic' posture, sometimes with animals, was called 'proto-Shiva', and conical stones were classed as lingas. Such readings assume later traditions mirror earlier ones, moving from the known to the unknown. That works for querns and pots but is speculative for symbols. The Rigveda (compiled c. 1500-1000 BCE) names a god Rudra, a name later used for Shiva, but the Rigvedic Rudra is neither Pashupati nor a yogi, so the seal does not match; some scholars suggest a shaman instead. One early excavator even thought small stone cones could equally have been gamesmen in board games.

Worked example 1: why Cunningham missed Harappa

Chain of reasoning: (1) his guides were texts and Chinese pilgrims' accounts; (2) Harappa was on neither; (3) he believed Indian history began with Ganga valley cities; (4) so a seal older than that had no place in his framework. Lesson: a researcher's framework decides what evidence seems meaningful.

Worked example 2: dating by layers

In a made-up mound, layer 1 (top) has iron tools, layer 2 is sterile, layer 3 has Harappan seals. Which is oldest, and what does layer 2 mean? Working: generally the lowest is oldest, so layer 3 is earliest; a sterile layer shows a period of abandonment between the two occupations. Note the book's caution that layers are not exactly horizontal, which is why Marshall's uniform horizontal digging mixed finds.

Stratigraphy is the study of the layers of a mound; generally the lowest layers are the oldest. Following the layers, not fixed horizontal units, keeps each find in its context.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: Cunningham's text-based framework hid Harappa's age; Sahni and Banerji's seals led Marshall to announce the civilisation in 1924. Marshall ignored stratigraphy; Wheeler (from 1944) followed it. Finds are classified by material and function using analogy, context and indirect evidence. Readings of Harappan religion (mother goddess, proto-Shiva, lingas) remain speculative, and many questions, including gender, literacy and the relationship with Vedic people, are open.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In which year did John Marshall announce the discovery of a new civilisation in the Indus valley?

    1. 1875
    2. 1921
    3. 1924
    4. 1944
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Marshall made the announcement in 1924, after seals found by Sahni at Harappa and Banerji at Mohenjodaro. 1875 is Cunningham's report, 1921 Sahni's excavation and 1944 Wheeler's appointment.

  2. 2. What was the main weakness of Marshall's excavation method?

    1. He dug in uniform horizontal units, ignoring stratigraphy
    2. He used Chinese pilgrims' accounts to locate sites
    3. He only excavated burials
    4. He refused to record everyday objects
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Marshall excavated along regular horizontal units, so artefacts from different layers were grouped together and their context was lost. Using pilgrims' accounts was Cunningham's approach.

  3. 3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'The seated figure has animals around it. A later god of the same name as a Rigvedic deity is called lord of animals, but the Rigvedic deity himself is never shown this way.' What problem of interpretation does this illustrate?

    1. That the Rigveda was compiled before the Harappan civilisation
    2. That seals were used only for trade
    3. That terracotta figurines were toys
    4. That reading earlier evidence through later traditions can be speculative
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The 'proto-Shiva' reading assumes later traditions parallel earlier ones. The book notes that Rudra in the Rigveda is neither Pashupati nor a yogi, so the match is uncertain; moving from the known present to the unknown past is more speculative for religious symbols.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Valuable Harappan artefacts found intact are accidental rather than typical finds. Reason (R): Usually only broken or useless objects were thrown away, and the rest was recycled.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    2. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Since useful things were kept or recycled, intact valuables survive only when lost or hoarded and never retrieved. That is why the book calls them accidental rather than typical; R explains A.

  5. 5. Who took over as Director-General of the ASI in 1944 and insisted on following the stratigraphy of the mound?

    1. Daya Ram Sahni
    2. Rakhal Das Banerji
    3. R.E.M. Wheeler
    4. S.R. Rao
    Show answer

    Answer: C. R.E.M. Wheeler, an ex-army brigadier, became Director-General in 1944 and corrected Marshall's method by following the mound's stratigraphy.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery