- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Sanchi and the background: sacrifices, questions and debates
Explain how Sanchi survived with the help of the Bhopal rulers, describe the Vedic sacrificial tradition and the new questions of the Upanishads, and explain the debates among many schools of thought.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why the stupa at Sanchi survived and who helped preserve it.
- Describe the sacrificial tradition of the Rigveda and the new questions raised in the Upanishads.
- Explain how debates among schools of thought worked, and describe the Ajivikas and Lokayatas as the textbook presents them.
This chapter covers about a thousand years of ideas: how philosophers tried to understand their world, and how their ideas were compiled in oral and written texts and expressed in architecture and sculpture. The focus is on Buddhism, but Buddhism grew in dialogue with other traditions. Sources include Buddhist, Jaina and Brahmanical texts, monuments and inscriptions, and above all the stupa at Sanchi.
A glimpse of Sanchi
Sanchi lies on a hilltop near Bhopal (Madhya Pradesh). Nineteenth-century Europeans were very interested in it: the French sought permission from Shahjehan Begum, Nawab of Bhopal (ruled 1868-1901), to take away the best-preserved eastern gateway for a museum in France, and some Englishmen wanted the same. Both were satisfied with plaster-cast copies, and the original stayed at the site. Shahjehan Begum and her successor Sultan Jehan Begum funded preservation; Sultan Jehan funded the site museum, the guesthouse where John Marshall wrote his volumes on Sanchi, and their publication, and Marshall dedicated the volumes to her. The complex also survived by luck, escaping railway contractors, builders and collectors. Today it is a testimony to restoration and preservation by the Archaeological Survey of India.
The background: a turning point
The mid-first millennium BCE is often seen as a turning point in world history: thinkers such as Zarathustra in Iran, Kong Zi in China, Socrates, Plato and Aristotle in Greece, and Mahavira and Gautama Buddha in India tried to understand existence and the relation between humans and the cosmic order. In the Ganga valley, new kingdoms and cities were developing and social and economic life was changing (Chapters 2 and 3), and thinkers tried to understand these changes too.
The sacrificial tradition
Among older traditions was the early Vedic tradition of the Rigveda, compiled between c. 1500 and 1000 BCE: hymns praising deities, especially Agni, Indra and Soma, chanted during sacrifices in which people prayed for cattle, sons, health and long life. These hymns were in Vedic Sanskrit, taught orally to men of priestly families.
How the practice of sacrifice changed
- Collective sacrifices At first, sacrifices were performed collectively.
- Household sacrifices Later (c. 1000-500 BCE onwards) some were performed by heads of households for the domestic unit.
- Royal sacrifices Elaborate rites such as the rajasuya and ashvamedha were performed by chiefs and kings, who depended on Brahmana priests.
New questions and debates
Ideas in the Upanishads (c. sixth century BCE onwards) show curiosity about the meaning of life, life after death and rebirth, and whether rebirth was due to past actions. Thinkers sought the nature of ultimate reality; others, outside the Vedic tradition, asked whether there was a single ultimate reality at all. People also began to question the significance of sacrifice.
Buddhist texts mention as many as 64 sects or schools of thought. Teachers travelled, trying to convince one another and laypeople. Debates took place in the kutagarashala ('a hut with a pointed roof') or in groves where mendicants halted. If a philosopher convinced a rival, the rival's followers became his disciples, so support for a sect could grow or shrink. Many teachers, including Mahavira and the Buddha, questioned the authority of the Vedas and stressed individual agency: men and women could strive for liberation. The book contrasts this with the Brahmanical position as it presents it, in which a person's existence was thought to be shaped by birth in a specific caste or gender.
| Tradition | Teacher named in the Sutta Pitaka | Usual description | Core idea as reported |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ajivikas | Makkhali Gosala | Fatalists | Everything is predetermined; pleasure and pain cannot be altered in the course of samsara |
| Lokayatas | Ajita Kesakambalin | Materialists | A human is made of four elements that return to nature at death; there is nothing after death, and gifts and sacrifice are pointless |
Their own texts have not survived, so we know them only through the works of others, here a Buddhist text recounting what King Ajatasattu told the Buddha. That is a serious problem: we hear rivals describe them, not their own words.
Worked example 1: why Sanchi survived
List the reasons. (1) Plaster-cast copies satisfied French and English demands, so the gateway stayed. (2) The Begums of Bhopal funded preservation, the museum, the guesthouse and Marshall's publication. (3) Luck: it escaped railway contractors, builders and collectors. (4) Later, the ASI restored and preserved it. A good answer combines wise decisions with good fortune, as the book does.
Worked example 2: describing a tradition through its rivals
Is it fair to call Makkhali Gosala a 'fatalist'? Reasoning: (1) the label comes from others' accounts, since Ajivika texts are lost; (2) the reported view, that pleasure and pain cannot be changed and fool and wise alike reach the end of sorrow, does fit 'predetermined'; (3) but a rival may simplify or distort. Conclusion: the label is the usual description, but historians should remember its source.
The new thinkers of the sixth century BCE questioned the authority of the Vedas and stressed individual agency: men and women could strive for liberation through their own efforts.
Key takeaways: Sanchi survived through plaster casts, the Bhopal Begums' funding and luck. The Rigveda (c. 1500-1000 BCE) praised Agni, Indra and Soma in sacrificial hymns; sacrifice moved from collective to household and royal forms. The Upanishads raised questions of life, death and rebirth. Buddhist texts mention 64 schools; debates were held in kutagarashalas; Ajivikas and Lokayatas are known only through others' texts.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which ruler of Bhopal funded the museum at Sanchi and the publication of John Marshall's volumes?
- Shahjehan Begum
- Sultan Jehan Begum
- Rani Lakshmibai
- Begum Hazrat Mahal
Show answer
Answer: B. Sultan Jehan Begum, Shahjehan Begum's successor, funded the museum, the guesthouse where Marshall worked and the publication of his volumes, which he dedicated to her.
-
2. The Rigveda, according to the textbook, was compiled between:
- About 600 and 300 BCE
- About 2600 and 1900 BCE
- About 1500 and 1000 BCE
- About 200 BCE and 200 CE
Show answer
Answer: C. The book dates the Rigveda's compilation between c. 1500 and 1000 BCE. Its hymns praise Agni, Indra and Soma.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'There is no next world. When a person dies, the earth in him goes back to earth and the air to air; offerings help nobody.' Which tradition's ideas, as reported in Buddhist texts, does this resemble?
- The Lokayatas
- The Ajivikas
- The Jainas
- The Mahayana Buddhists
Show answer
Answer: A. Ajita Kesakambalin of the Lokayata tradition, usually described as materialists, is reported as saying humans are made of four elements that return to nature and that gifts and sacrifice are empty.
-
4. Assertion (A): Support for any particular sect could grow and shrink over time. Reason (R): If a philosopher convinced a rival in debate, the rival's followers also became his disciples.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Show answer
Answer: D. The book links the rise and fall of sects to debates: winning a debate brought the loser's followers too. R explains A.
-
5. Elaborate sacrifices such as the rajasuya and ashvamedha were performed by:
- heads of all households
- chiefs and kings, who depended on Brahmana priests
- Buddhist monks
- Jaina nuns
Show answer
Answer: B. More elaborate sacrifices were performed by chiefs and kings, who relied on Brahmana priests to conduct the rituals; household sacrifices were simpler.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.