- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Sculpture, new religious traditions and the limits of what we see
Interpret Buddhist sculpture at Sanchi through texts and symbols, explain the rise of Mahayana Buddhism and Puranic Hinduism, describe early temples, and evaluate the problems of reading images.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Interpret stories and symbols in Sanchi sculpture and explain motifs drawn from popular traditions.
- Explain the development of Mahayana Buddhism, Vaishnavism and Shaivism, the Puranas and early temples.
- Explain why nineteenth-century scholars misread Indian sculpture and why text and image sometimes do not match.
Sculptures were carried off to Europe partly because people found them beautiful. But what did they mean to those who carved and venerated them? Historians combine images with texts, but the fit is not always easy.
Stories in stone
Like wandering storytellers who point to pictures on scrolls (charanachitras), sculptors told stories in stone. A panel on the northern gateway at Sanchi seems at first a rural scene with huts and trees, but art historians identify it as the Vessantara Jataka, about a generous prince who gave everything to a Brahmana and went to live in the forest with his family. Historians understand such sculpture by comparing it with texts.
Symbols of worship
| Symbol | What it stands for |
|---|---|
| Empty seat (under the tree) | The Buddha's meditation |
| Tree | An event in the Buddha's life: enlightenment while meditating under a tree |
| Stupa | The mahaparinibbana |
| Wheel | The first sermon, at Sarnath |
Many early sculptors did not show the Buddha in human form, so these sculptures cannot be read literally: the tree is not just a tree. Historians must know the traditions of those who made the art.
Popular traditions
- Shalabhanjika: a woman swinging from the gateway's edge holding a tree; from other literary traditions scholars realised it may represent a woman whose touch, by popular belief, made trees flower and bear fruit, an auspicious symbol. It shows that converts enriched Buddhism with pre-Buddhist and non-Buddhist beliefs.
- Animals: elephants, horses, monkeys and cattle, some from Jataka stories, others to create lively scenes; elephants could signify strength and wisdom.
- Woman with lotuses and elephants: identified by some as Maya, the Buddha's mother, by others as Gajalakshmi, goddess of good fortune; devotees may have seen both.
- Serpent: found on several pillars, from popular traditions not always recorded in texts. James Fergusson, unfamiliar with untranslated Buddhist literature and studying images alone, thought Sanchi a centre of tree and serpent worship.
Paintings survive best on cave walls, most famously at Ajanta (Maharashtra), which show Jataka stories, courtly life, processions, work and festivals, using shading for a three-dimensional effect.
New religious traditions
Early Buddhism and Mahayana
-
Older tradition
- Great importance to self-effort for nibbana
- The Buddha seen as a human who attained enlightenment by his own effort
- Called Hinayana ('lesser vehicle') by Mahayana followers
- Its followers called themselves theravadins, followers of the old, respected teachers (theras)
-
Mahayana ('great vehicle'), by the first century CE
- The idea of a saviour who could ensure salvation
- Bodhisattas: compassionate beings who used their merit to help others rather than attain nibbana
- Worship of images of the Buddha and Bodhisattas
The saviour idea also developed within traditions now considered part of Hinduism: Vaishnavism (Vishnu as principal deity) and Shaivism (Shiva as chief god), with growing emphasis on worship of a chosen deity through bhakti, a bond of love and devotion. Vaishnavism recognised ten avatars, forms Vishnu was believed to take to save the world when evil threatened; recognising local deities as forms of Vishnu helped create a more unified tradition. Shiva was symbolised by the linga and occasionally in human form. Sculptures used head-dresses, ornaments and ayudhas (weapons or auspicious objects held in the hands) to express ideas about deities. Their stories are in the Puranas, compiled by Brahmanas by about the middle of the first millennium CE, in simple Sanskrit verse meant to be read aloud to everybody, including women and Shudras, who had no access to Vedic learning. Much of their content grew from interaction among priests, merchants and ordinary travellers; Vasudeva-Krishna, for example, was an important deity of the Mathura region whose worship spread.
Building temples
As stupas took their present form, the first temples to house images were built. The early temple was a small square room, the garbhagriha, with one doorway; gradually a tall shikhara rose over the shrine, and walls were decorated with sculpture. Later temples added assembly halls, walls, gateways and water supply. Some temples were hollowed out of rock as artificial caves: the earliest caves were made in the third century BCE on Asoka's orders for Ajivika renouncers (as at Barabar), and the tradition culminated in the eighth century with the Kailashnatha temple at Ellora, carved from a single rock.
Can we 'see' everything?
Nineteenth-century European scholars were sometimes horrified by images with many arms and heads or human-animal forms. They judged Indian sculpture by Greek yardsticks, found it inferior, and prized Buddha and Bodhisatta images from the northwest (Taxila, Peshawar), made on Greek models where Indo-Greek kingdoms had existed: a strategy of using the familiar to understand the unfamiliar. Using texts is better, but text and image do not always match: a huge rock-cut panel at Mahabalipuram (Tamil Nadu) is read by some as the descent of the Ganga (a natural cleft may represent the river) and by others as Arjuna's penance to gain arms. Finally, many rituals and beliefs were never recorded in permanent form; the monuments are just the tip of the iceberg.
Worked example 1: decoding a panel
A panel shows people bowing to an empty seat beneath a tree, with no human figure of the Buddha. Interpret it. Working: early sculptors often showed the Buddha by symbols; the empty seat indicates his meditation and the tree his enlightenment under a tree. So the panel shows worship of the Buddha's enlightenment, not tree worship, which is exactly the mistake Fergusson made by studying images without the texts.
Worked example 2: Mahayana or older tradition?
A made-up inscription says: 'May the compassionate Bodhisatta, who stays in the world to help all beings, save my family.' Classify. Working: a saviour figure + a Bodhisatta who postpones release to help others + prayer for salvation = Mahayana. The older tradition stressed self-effort towards nibbana.
Garbhagriha: the small square inner room of an early temple housing the image; shikhara: the tall structure built above it.
Key takeaways: Sanchi's sculpture tells Jataka stories and uses symbols (seat, tree, stupa, wheel) for the Buddha; motifs like the shalabhanjika, Gajalakshmi and serpents came from popular traditions. By the first century CE Mahayana developed the saviour and Bodhisatta ideals; Vaishnavism and Shaivism stressed bhakti, with stories in the Puranas. Temples grew from the garbhagriha to shikharas and rock-cut wonders like Kailashnatha. Images can be misread when judged by foreign yardsticks or when texts do not match.
Check your understanding
-
1. In early Buddhist sculpture, the wheel symbolised:
- the Buddha's birth
- his meditation
- the first sermon at Sarnath
- the mahaparinibbana
Show answer
Answer: C. The wheel stood for the first sermon at Sarnath; the empty seat for meditation; the stupa for the mahaparinibbana.
-
2. Bodhisattas, in Mahayana Buddhism, were beings who:
- used their accumulated merit to help others instead of attaining nibbana and leaving the world
- rejected all images
- performed Vedic sacrifices
- were fatalists like the Ajivikas
Show answer
Answer: A. Bodhisattas were compassionate beings who accumulated merit but used it to help others rather than attain nibbana; worship of their images became important in Mahayana.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'The traveller reached a small square room with one doorway, where the image stood; above it rose a tall tower.' Which two temple features are described?
- Anda and harmika
- Mandapa and gopuram
- Chaitya and vihara
- Garbhagriha and shikhara
Show answer
Answer: D. The early temple was a small square room, the garbhagriha, with a single doorway; gradually a tall structure, the shikhara, was built over it.
-
4. Assertion (A): James Fergusson considered Sanchi a centre of tree and serpent worship. Reason (R): He was not familiar with Buddhist literature, most of which had not yet been translated, and studied the images on their own.
- A is true, but R is false.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is false, but R is true.
Show answer
Answer: B. The book says Fergusson reached his conclusion by studying images alone, without knowledge of the then untranslated Buddhist texts. R explains A.
-
5. The Puranas were written in simple Sanskrit verse and were meant to be:
- read only by priests in secret
- chanted only during royal sacrifices
- read aloud to everybody, including women and Shudras
- carved only on temple walls
Show answer
Answer: C. The Puranas, compiled by Brahmanas by about the middle of the first millennium CE, were meant to be read aloud to everyone, including women and Shudras who lacked access to Vedic learning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.