- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Leaders, followers, rumours and prophecies
Explain how leaders emerged in 1857, describe Shah Mal and Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah, and explain the rumours and prophecies that spread and why people believed them in the context of British policies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why rebels turned to pre-British rulers for leadership, and identify other kinds of leaders.
- Describe the careers of Shah Mal and Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah.
- Describe the main rumours and prophecies of 1857 and explain, in the context of British policies, why they were believed.
Fighting the British needed leadership and organisation. Sometimes rebels turned to those who had been leaders before the British conquest; elsewhere new leaders rose from among ordinary people and religious figures.
Leaders and followers
| Place | Leader | How leadership came |
|---|---|---|
| Delhi | Bahadur Shah | First reacted with horror and rejection; agreed to be nominal leader only after sepoys entered the court, realising he had few options |
| Kanpur | Nana Sahib, successor to Peshwa Baji Rao II | Sepoys and townspeople gave him no choice but to lead |
| Jhansi | The rani | Forced by popular pressure to assume leadership |
| Arrah (Bihar) | Kunwar Singh, a local zamindar | Also pressed into leadership |
| Lucknow (Awadh) | Birjis Qadr, young son of Nawab Wajid Ali Shah | Hailed as leader by the populace, celebrating the fall of British rule |
Not all leaders were from courts. Ordinary men and women and religious figures carried the message: at Meerut, reports spoke of a fakir on an elephant whom sepoys visited; in Lucknow, after annexation, religious leaders and self-styled prophets preached the end of British rule. Local leaders urged peasants, zamindars and tribals to revolt: Shah Mal in pargana Barout (Uttar Pradesh), and Gonoo, a tribal cultivator of Singhbhum in Chotanagpur, who led the Kol tribals. After the rebellion collapsed in 1858, Nana Sahib escaped to Nepal, adding to his legend.
Two rebels of 1857
Shah Mal and Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah
-
Shah Mal
- From a Jat cultivator clan with kin across chaurasee des (84 villages) in pargana Barout
- Prosperous villagers resented high, inflexible revenue and loss of land to traders and moneylenders
- Moved by night from village to village mobilising headmen and cultivators
- Rebels attacked moneylenders and government buildings, destroyed a bridge and dug up roads
- Supplied the sepoys in Delhi; cut communication between British headquarters and Meerut
- Acknowledged as Raja; ran a 'hall of justice' in an English officer's bungalow; killed in battle in July 1857
-
Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah
- Educated in Hyderabad; became a preacher young
- In 1856 went from village to village preaching jehad against the British
- Travelled in a palanquin with drumbeaters, so called Danka Shah
- Stopped from preaching in Lucknow (1856); jailed in Faizabad (1857)
- Elected leader by the mutinous 22nd Native Infantry
- Fought at the Battle of Chinhat, where British forces under Henry Lawrence were defeated; many believed him invincible
Rumours and prophecies
- Greased cartridges: the cartridges of the new Enfield rifles were rumoured to be greased with cow and pig fat, so that biting them would corrupt caste and religion. The British tried to explain otherwise, but the rumour spread across North India's sepoy lines. Its origin can be traced: Captain Wright reported that in January 1857 at the Dum Dum magazine, a 'low-caste' khalasi refused water by a Brahmin sepoy retorted that the sepoy would soon lose caste by biting such cartridges. The textbook says we do not know the report's veracity.
- Bone dust in flour: a rumour that the British had mixed the bone dust of cows and pigs into flour sold in markets, as part of a conspiracy to destroy caste and religion; people refused to touch the atta.
- Conversion: fear that the British wanted to convert Indians to Christianity.
- Prophecy: British rule would end on the centenary of the Battle of Plassey, 23 June 1857.
- Chapattis: reports of chapattis passed from village to village at night, each watchman told to make five more for the next village. Their purpose was unclear then and now, but people read them as an omen of upheaval.
Why did people believe the rumours?
The textbook argues that the power of rumours cannot be understood by checking whether they were true; we must see what they reveal about people's fears and convictions. Rumours circulate when they resonate with deeper suspicions. From the late 1820s, under Governor General Lord William Bentinck, the British pursued policies to 'reform' Indian society: Western education, ideas and institutions; English-medium schools, colleges and universities; laws abolishing sati (1829) and permitting remarriage of Hindu widows. On pleas such as misgovernment and refusal to recognise adoption, they annexed Awadh, Jhansi and Satara and other states, imposing their own administration, laws and land revenue systems. To many in North India it seemed that everything they held sacred, from kings and customs to landholding and revenue patterns, was being replaced by an impersonal, alien and oppressive system, a perception aggravated by Christian missionaries. In such uncertainty rumours spread swiftly.
Worked example 1: analysing a rumour
Take the bone-dust rumour. Step 1: was it true? The textbook does not treat it as fact. Step 2: what fear did it express? That the British were secretly destroying caste and religion. Step 3: why was it credible? Recent laws on social customs, annexations, new revenue systems and missionary activity made such intentions seem plausible to many. Conclusion: the rumour is evidence of anxieties, not of a real conspiracy.
Worked example 2: why destroy roads and bridges?
Shah Mal's men dug up metalled roads and destroyed a bridge. Give two reasons from the text: (1) military, to prevent government forces from entering the area; (2) symbolic, because bridges and roads were seen as symbols of British rule. Both reasons show the rebellion as an attack on the colonial order itself.
Rumours circulate only when they resonate with the deeper fears and suspicions of people; historians study them to understand those fears, not only to test their truth.
Key takeaways: rebels often pressed former rulers into leadership: Bahadur Shah, Nana Sahib, the Rani of Jhansi, Kunwar Singh, Birjis Qadr. Local leaders like Shah Mal and Gonoo, and religious figures like Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah, also led. Rumours of greased cartridges and adulterated flour, fears of conversion, the Plassey centenary prophecy and circulating chapattis moved people, because British reforms and annexations from the 1820s made them believable.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who became the leader of the Kol tribals of Singhbhum during 1857?
- Shah Mal
- Kunwar Singh
- Gonoo
- Birjis Qadr
Show answer
Answer: C. Gonoo, a tribal cultivator of Singhbhum in Chotanagpur, became a rebel leader of the Kol tribals; Shah Mal led villagers of pargana Barout.
-
2. Maulvi Ahmadullah Shah was popularly called Danka Shah because:
- he played the drum in the army
- he travelled with drumbeaters in front of his palanquin
- he was a drum-maker
- he won the battle of Chinhat with drums
Show answer
Answer: B. He moved in a palanquin with drumbeaters in front and followers behind, so he was called Danka Shah, the maulvi with the drum.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'At midnight a stranger handed our watchman a flat bread and told him to make five more and send them to the next village. No one knew why, but everyone said great changes were coming.' Which phenomenon of 1857 does this describe?
- The distribution of chapattis from village to village
- The greased cartridge rumour
- The Azamgarh Proclamation
- The Summary Settlement
Show answer
Answer: A. Reports spoke of chapattis distributed at night from village to village; their purpose was unclear, but people read them as an omen of upheaval.
-
4. Assertion (A): Rumours spread rapidly in North India in 1857. Reason (R): British reforms, annexations and missionary activity made people fear that all they held sacred was being destroyed.
- A is true, but R is false.
- A is false, but R is true.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Show answer
Answer: D. The book explains that rumours resonated with fears created by British policies from the 1820s onwards and by missionaries; R explains A.
-
5. The prophecy that British rule would end in 1857 was linked to the centenary of:
- the Battle of Plassey
- the Battle of Buxar
- the Subsidiary Alliance
- the abolition of sati
Show answer
Answer: A. The prophecy said British rule would end on the centenary of the Battle of Plassey, 23 June 1857.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.