• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

What the rebels wanted and the British repression

Explain why the rebels' perspective is hard to recover, analyse the rebels' vision of unity and their attack on symbols of oppression, describe their attempts at alternative power, and describe how the British suppressed the revolt.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why historians depend heavily on British sources for 1857 and what rebel sources survive.
  • Analyse the rebels' vision of unity, their grievances against British rule and their attempts to set up alternative authority.
  • Describe the laws, military campaigns and political strategies the British used to suppress the revolt.

As victors, the British recorded their own trials and heroism and dismissed the rebels as ungrateful and barbaric. Repression also silenced the rebels' voices: few could record their version, and most were sepoys and ordinary people who were not literate. Apart from some proclamations and ishtahars (notifications) and a few letters and petitions, historians depend heavily on British writings, which reveal officials' minds but tell us little of what the rebels wanted.

The vision of unity

Rebel proclamations repeatedly appealed to all sections, irrespective of caste and creed. Many were issued by Muslim princes or in their names, but took care to address Hindus' sentiments; the war was presented as one in which Hindus and Muslims had equally to gain or lose. The ishtahars looked back to the coexistence of communities under the Mughal Empire. The proclamation in Bahadur Shah's name called people to fight under the standards of both Muhammad and Mahavir. The textbook notes that religious divisions were hardly noticeable during the uprising despite British attempts to create them: in Bareilly in December 1857, the British spent Rs 50,000 to incite Hindus against Muslims, and the attempt failed.

The Azamgarh Proclamation (25 August 1857): grievances by group
Group addressedGrievance against British rulePromise under the Badshahi government
ZamindarsExorbitant revenue demands, auctions for arrears, costly litigation, humiliation in courts, taxes for schools, hospitals and roadsLight revenue, safe dignity and honour, absolute rule in their zamindaris
MerchantsBritish monopoly of valuable trade such as indigo and cloth; taxes, tolls and postagesTrade of every article by land and water opened to native merchants
Public servantsLittle respect, low pay, no influence; high posts reserved for EnglishmenSalaries of 200 to 300 rupees a month and high posts
ArtisansRuined by English goods; weavers, carpenters, blacksmiths, shoemakers out of workExclusive employment by kings, rajas and the rich
Pundits and fakirsThe Europeans described as enemies of both religionsA call to join the war

A surviving arzi (petition) of rebel sepoys explains that they had served the British loyally for generations but rose because the new cartridges and flour were believed to threaten their faith, and because comrades who refused the cartridges were imprisoned; they fought, they said, so that their religion would not be polluted.

Against the symbols of oppression

The proclamations rejected everything associated with firangi raj: annexations, broken treaties, land revenue settlements that dispossessed big and small landholders, and foreign commerce that ruined artisans and weavers. They expressed fear that the British meant to destroy caste and religion and convert people, and urged people to fight for their livelihood, faith, honour and identity, for the 'greater public good'. In many places the rebellion widened into attacks on allies of the British and local oppressors: rebels humiliated city elites, burnt account books and ransacked moneylenders' houses. The textbook sees in this a glimpse of an alternative, perhaps more egalitarian, vision, though the proclamations, aiming to unite all groups, did not articulate it.

The search for alternative power

Once British rule collapsed, rebels in Delhi, Lucknow and Kanpur tried to set up authority and administration: appointments, arrangements for land revenue and troops' pay, orders against looting, battle plans and chains of command. They harked back to the eighteenth-century Mughal world, a symbol of all that had been lost. These structures were mainly for war and mostly did not survive the British onslaught, but in Awadh, where resistance lasted longest, the Lucknow court was still planning counter-attacks in late 1857 and early 1858.

Repression

How the British suppressed the revolt

  1. Special laws, May-June 1857 North India put under martial law; military officers and even ordinary Britons empowered to try and punish suspects; ordinary trial suspended; rebellion to have one punishment, death.
  2. Two-pronged attack on Delhi Forces from Calcutta and from the largely peaceful Punjab; attempts began in early June, Delhi captured only in late September after heavy losses.
  3. Village-by-village reconquest The Gangetic plain was entirely hostile; in Awadh an official estimated three-fourths of adult men in rebellion; controlled only in March 1858.
  4. Breaking unity Big landholders promised their estates back; rebels dispossessed and the loyal rewarded; many landholders died fighting or in Nepal.

An officer reporting from rural Awadh described villagers who melted away before British troops and gathered again, in very large numbers with guns. The British realised they faced not a mere mutiny but an uprising with huge popular support.

Worked example 1: reading a proclamation

Analyse the Azamgarh Proclamation's method. Step 1: it addresses each group (zamindars, merchants, public servants, artisans, religious men) separately. Step 2: for each, it lists a specific British injury and a specific promise. Step 3: it frames the struggle as shared by Hindus and Muslims under a restored Badshahi government. Purpose: to build the broadest possible coalition. Limitation: it speaks for elites' and groups' interests and says little about a more egalitarian society.

Worked example 2: why were rebel sources so few?

List the reasons. (1) Most rebels were sepoys and ordinary people, not literate. (2) Repression killed or silenced many. (3) Victors controlled the archives and wrote the histories. (4) What survives (proclamations, ishtahars, arzis) was written to persuade. So historians must read British records against the grain and value the few rebel documents.

Ishtahar: a notification issued by rebel leaders in 1857 to spread their ideas and persuade people to join the revolt.

— Definition, in our own words

Key takeaways: rebel voices survive mainly in proclamations, ishtahars and arzis; British sources dominate. Rebels appealed to Hindu-Muslim unity under the Mughal name, and British efforts to divide them (Bareilly, Rs 50,000) failed. The Azamgarh Proclamation listed grievances of zamindars, merchants, public servants, artisans and religious men. Rebels attacked symbols of oppression and tried to restore an eighteenth-century order. The British used martial law, recaptured Delhi in September 1857, reconquered Awadh by March 1858 and divided landholders with promises.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The proclamation issued in Bahadur Shah's name appealed to people to fight under the standards of:

    1. Rama and Krishna
    2. Muhammad and Mahavir
    3. the Peshwa and the Nawab
    4. the Company and the Crown
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The proclamation appealed to people to fight under the standards of both Muhammad and Mahavir, reflecting the rebels' call for Hindu-Muslim unity.

  2. 2. In which city did the British spend Rs 50,000 in December 1857 to incite Hindus against Muslims, without success?

    1. Bareilly
    2. Lucknow
    3. Kanpur
    4. Delhi
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook notes this failed attempt in Bareilly in western Uttar Pradesh, as evidence that religious divisions were hardly noticeable during the uprising.

  3. 3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'Under the foreigners our cloth is undersold by machine-made goods and our looms stand idle; when the emperor's rule returns, kings and nobles will buy only from us.' Which section of the Azamgarh Proclamation does this most resemble?

    1. Regarding Zamindars
    2. Regarding Merchants
    3. Regarding Artisans
    4. Regarding Public Servants
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The section on artisans said English goods had thrown weavers and other craftsmen out of work and promised that under the Badshahi government they would be employed by kings, rajas and the rich.

  4. 4. Assertion (A): Historians' reconstructions of 1857 depend heavily on British writings. Reason (R): Few rebels could record their versions, most being sepoys and ordinary people who were not literate, and repression silenced their voices.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
    2. A is true, but R is false.
    3. A is false, but R is true.
    4. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book explains that the scarcity of rebel records, due to illiteracy and repression, makes reconstructions heavily dependent on British sources. R explains A.

  5. 5. When was Delhi finally recaptured by the British?

    1. Early June 1857
    2. Late September 1857
    3. March 1858
    4. June 1858
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Attempts began in early June 1857, but Delhi was captured only in late September. Awadh was brought under control in March 1858.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery