Revision notes

Chapter 12 Framing the Constitution: The Beginning of a New Era: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

A tumultuous time and the making of the Constituent Assembly

Key figures in the Constituent Assembly of 300 members
PersonRole
Jawaharlal NehruMoved the Objectives Resolution and the resolution on the National Flag: a horizontal tricolour of saffron, white and dark green in equal proportion with a navy-blue wheel at the centre
Vallabh Bhai PatelWorked mostly behind the scenes, helping draft several reports and reconciling opposing views
Rajendra PrasadPresident of the Assembly, steering discussion and ensuring all could speak
B.R. AmbedkarLawyer and economist, earlier a political opponent of the Congress; on Gandhiji's advice joined the Union Cabinet as law minister; Chairman of the Drafting Committee; guided the Draft Constitution through the Assembly
K.M. Munshi and Alladi Krishnaswamy AiyarLawyers from Gujarat and Madras on the Drafting Committee, giving crucial inputs
B.N. Rau (civil servant)Constitutional Advisor; prepared background papers on other countries' political systems
S.N. Mukherjee (civil servant)Chief Draughtsman; put complex proposals into clear legal language

The Constituent Assembly was not elected by universal franchise: provincial legislatures, elected in 1945-46, chose its members, and the Congress made up 82 per cent of them after the League's boycott.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: the Constitution (in force 26 January 1950) was framed from December 1946 to November 1949 amid Partition violence, refugees and the princely states question. Provincial legislatures chose the Assembly; the League boycotted it, leaving the Congress with 82 per cent, though members held diverse views and public opinion mattered. Nehru, Patel, Prasad, Ambedkar, Munshi and Krishnaswamy Aiyar led, assisted by B.N. Rau and S.N. Mukherjee.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The vision of the Constitution and the will of the people

Was the Assembly free of British control? Two views

  • Somnath Lahiri (Communist member)
    • Saw the dark hand of British imperialism over the debates
    • The British were still in India; Nehru's interim government worked under the Viceroy and London
    • Called the Assembly British-made, working British plans
    • Urged members to declare independence and fight British imperialism together
  • Jawaharlal Nehru
    • Admitted nationalists had wanted a different kind of Assembly and that the British had a hand in its birth
    • But governments are the expression of the will of the people, not State Papers
    • The Assembly met because of the strength of the people behind it
    • It must fulfil the passions in the hearts of the masses
Colonial constitutional Acts compared with the Constitution
FeatureActs of 1909, 1919, 1935Constitution of 1946-49
Who made itEnacted by the colonial government; not directly debated or formulated by IndiansDebated and framed by Indians in the Constituent Assembly
FranchiseEven in 1935, limited to no more than 10 to 15 per cent of adults; no universal adult franchiseVote for every adult Indian
ResponsibilityExecutive partly responsible to provincial legislatures in 1919, almost entirely in 1935, but within colonial rule and answerable to a British-appointed GovernorAn independent, sovereign Republic
Outcome1937 elections under the 1935 Act: Congress in power in eight of 11 provincesA new constitutional order

Objectives Resolution (13 December 1946): India an independent sovereign republic; justice, equality and freedom for citizens; adequate safeguards for minorities, backward and tribal areas, and Depressed and Other Backward Classes.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: Nehru's Objectives Resolution set the Constitution's ideals and drew on world revolutions without copying them, aiming to fuse liberal democracy with socialist economic justice. Lahiri saw British influence over the Assembly; Nehru answered that its strength came from the will of the people. Ideals of democracy and justice grew from nineteenth-century reform and the national movement. Unlike the colonial Acts of 1909, 1919 and 1935, made by the British with a narrow franchise, the Constitution was framed by Indians for a sovereign republic.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Defining rights: minorities, tribals, depressed castes and women

Arguments against separate electorates in the Assembly

  • A British device to divide
    • Most nationalists saw them as deliberately introduced by the British
    • R.V. Dhulekar: the English played their game under cover of safeguards
  • Linked to Partition and violence
    • Sardar Patel called them a poison in the body politic that turned community against community and led to Partition
    • He asked whether any free country had separate electorates
  • Harmful to minorities themselves
    • G.B. Pant: suicidal for minorities, isolating them permanently and denying them an effective voice
    • He accepted that democracy is judged by the confidence of all sections and that the majority must understand minorities
  • Citizens, not communities
    • Pant: 'it is the citizen that must count'; no divided loyalties
    • Communities could have cultural rights, but politically all must act as equal members of one State
What the Constituent Assembly finally recommended for the depressed castes
RecommendationNote
Abolition of untouchabilitySocial discrimination could not be erased by law alone; attitudes had to change
Hindu temples thrown open to all castesAddressed exclusion from temple entry
Reservation of seats in legislaturesFor the lowest castes
Reservation of jobs in government officesFor the lowest castes

The Assembly rejected separate electorates but recommended abolishing untouchability, opening Hindu temples to all castes, and reserving seats in legislatures and government jobs for the lowest castes.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: Pocker Bahadur argued for separate electorates; Patel, Pant, Dhulekar and others opposed them as divisive and harmful to minorities, stressing citizenship; by 1949 most Muslim members agreed. Ranga defined minorities economically; Jaipal Singh sought reserved seats for tribals; depressed caste members stressed social disabilities. The Assembly recommended abolishing untouchability, temple entry and reservations; women like Hansa Mehta sought justice rather than privileges.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The powers of the State: Centre and states

Division of powers in the Draft Constitution

  • Union List
    • Preserve of the Central Government
    • Many more items than in other federations
  • State List
    • Vested with the states
  • Concurrent List
    • Shared responsibility of Centre and states
    • More items than the provinces wanted
  • Other central powers
    • Control of minerals and key industries
    • Article 356: Centre could take over a state administration on the Governor's recommendation
Fiscal federalism in the Constitution, as the textbook describes it
ArrangementExamples
Centre keeps all proceedsCustoms duties, Company taxes
Centre shares with statesIncome tax, excise duties
Assigned wholly to statesEstate duties
Levied and collected by states themselvesLand and property taxes, sales tax, tax on bottled liquor

Union List for the Centre, State List for the states, Concurrent List shared; with Article 356 and control over key resources, the Constitution leaned towards the Union.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: the Draft Constitution had Union, State and Concurrent lists, with more Union and Concurrent items than in other federations, central control of minerals and key industries, Article 356, and fiscal arrangements that left states dependent. Santhanam and others argued that overcentralisation would weaken both Centre and states. Ambedkar, Ayyangar, Sharma and Nehru wanted a strong Centre to stop violence and plan development. After Partition, the Constitution favoured the Union.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The language of the nation, universal franchise and secularism

Voices in the language debate

  • R.V. Dhulekar (United Provinces)
    • Early on demanded Hindi as the language of constitution-making; said those who did not know Hindustani were unworthy members
    • On 13 September 1949 wanted Hindi declared the National, not merely Official, Language
    • Called Hindi's adoption the consummation of a historic process
    • The President told him he was not advancing his case by speaking like this
  • G. Durgabai (Madras)
    • A once agreed question had become controversial
    • Non-Hindi areas felt the Hindi campaign would block other languages' influence on composite culture
    • Strong opposition in the south, which feared harm to provincial languages
    • She had taught Hindi in the south on Gandhiji's call; now feared Hindustani's inclusive character was being eroded
  • Voices for accommodation
    • Shankarrao Deo (Bombay): support for Hindi must not raise suspicions and fears
    • T.A. Ramalingam Chettiar (Madras): go with caution; fears, even if unjustified, must be allayed; mutual adjustment, no forcing
Features of secularism in the Constitution, as the textbook describes them
FeatureWhat it means
Equal treatmentAll religions guaranteed equal treatment by the State and the right to maintain charitable institutions
Distance from religionNo compulsory religious instruction in State-run schools and colleges; religious discrimination in employment made illegal
Space for reformA legal space for social reform within communities, used to ban untouchability and change personal and family laws
OverallNo absolute separation of State and religion, but a judicious distance between them

Indian secularism, as the textbook describes it: equal treatment of all religions, the State keeping a judicious distance from them, and legal space for social reform within communities, rather than absolute separation.

— Summary, in our own words

Key takeaways: Gandhiji wanted composite Hindustani, but Hindi and Urdu grew apart along communal lines. Dhulekar pressed for Hindi as national language; Durgabai and others voiced non-Hindi fears; Deo and Chettiar urged accommodation. The compromise made Hindi in Devanagari the official language, with English for fifteen years and regional languages for provinces. Universal adult franchise was an unprecedented act of faith. Secularism was built through Articles 25-28, 29-30 and 14, 16, 17, with judicious distance rather than total separation.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery