- Foundation
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
The powers of the State: Centre and states
Explain the three lists, Article 356 and fiscal federalism in the Draft Constitution, the arguments of Santhanam and others for the states, the case for a strong Centre, and why the Constitution leaned towards the Union.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the Union, State and Concurrent lists, Article 356 and the division of taxes in the Draft Constitution.
- Explain K. Santhanam's arguments for reallocating powers to the states.
- Explain the case for a strong Centre and why the Constitution showed a bias towards the Union.
One of the most vigorously debated topics was the respective rights of the Central Government and the states. Nehru argued for a strong Centre: now that Partition was settled, he wrote to the Assembly's President, a weak central authority could not ensure peace, coordinate vital matters or speak for the whole country internationally.
The Draft Constitution's design
Division of powers in the Draft Constitution
-
Union List
- Preserve of the Central Government
- Many more items than in other federations
-
State List
- Vested with the states
-
Concurrent List
- Shared responsibility of Centre and states
- More items than the provinces wanted
-
Other central powers
- Control of minerals and key industries
- Article 356: Centre could take over a state administration on the Governor's recommendation
| Arrangement | Examples |
|---|---|
| Centre keeps all proceeds | Customs duties, Company taxes |
| Centre shares with states | Income tax, excise duties |
| Assigned wholly to states | Estate duties |
| Levied and collected by states themselves | Land and property taxes, sales tax, tax on bottled liquor |
'The centre is likely to break'
K. Santhanam of Madras most eloquently defended the states. A reallocation of powers, he argued, would strengthen not only the states but also the Centre: there was an 'obsession' that piling powers on the Centre made it strong, but an overburdened Centre could not function well; relieving it of some functions would make it stronger. The proposed allocation would cripple the states: most taxes except land revenue went to the Centre, so how could provinces fund development? He would rather have a frankly unitary system than one in which states had to beg the Centre for money to educate their people or build roads, and he predicted that provinces would rise in 'revolt against the Centre'. Many from the provinces echoed him and fought for fewer items on the Union and Concurrent lists; a member from Orissa warned that 'the Centre is likely to break' from excessive centralisation. Sir A. Ramaswamy Mudaliar of Mysore cautioned against assuming that those wanting a strong Centre were better patriots than those asking for closer scrutiny.
'What we want today is a strong Government'
- Ambedkar wanted a strong and united Centre, much stronger than under the Government of India Act of 1935.
- Many members, recalling riots and violence, said the Centre must be strengthened to stop the communal frenzy.
- Gopalaswami Ayyangar declared the Centre should be made as strong as possible.
- Balakrishna Sharma of the United Provinces argued that only a strong Centre could plan for the country's well-being, mobilise resources, establish proper administration and defend against foreign aggression.
Before Partition, the Congress had agreed to considerable provincial autonomy, partly to assure the Muslim League that the Centre would not interfere in provinces it governed. After Partition, most nationalists changed position: that political pressure was gone; a unitary system already existed from colonial rule; and the violence of the times pushed towards centralisation, to forestall chaos and to plan economic development. The textbook concludes that the Constitution showed a distinct bias towards the rights of the Union over its constituent states.
Worked example 1: following the money (illustrative figures)
Made-up figures: suppose a state's own taxes (land, property, sales tax, liquor) raise Rs 40 crore, and it receives a share of income tax and excise from the Centre of Rs 25 crore. Its total = 40 + 25 = Rs 65 crore. If its schools, roads and health need Rs 90 crore, the gap is 90 - 65 = Rs 25 crore, which it must request from the Centre. This is the dependence Santhanam feared when he said states would have to come to the Centre asking for a dole.
Worked example 2: why did views change after Partition?
Trace the change. Before Partition: autonomy for provinces was a concession to keep the League within one India. After Partition: (1) the League's demand no longer applied; (2) colonial rule had already left a unitary structure; (3) riots and refugees made a strong authority seem necessary for order; (4) planning economic development needed central coordination. Result: the Union and Concurrent lists grew, and the Constitution leaned towards the Centre.
Union List for the Centre, State List for the states, Concurrent List shared; with Article 356 and control over key resources, the Constitution leaned towards the Union.
Key takeaways: the Draft Constitution had Union, State and Concurrent lists, with more Union and Concurrent items than in other federations, central control of minerals and key industries, Article 356, and fiscal arrangements that left states dependent. Santhanam and others argued that overcentralisation would weaken both Centre and states. Ambedkar, Ayyangar, Sharma and Nehru wanted a strong Centre to stop violence and plan development. After Partition, the Constitution favoured the Union.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article gave the Centre the power to take over a state administration on the recommendation of the Governor?
- Article 14
- Article 17
- Article 356
- Article 25
Show answer
Answer: C. The book states that Article 356 gave the Centre this power. Articles 14 and 17 relate to equality and Article 25 to freedom of religion.
-
2. Under the fiscal arrangements described in the textbook, which tax was assigned wholly to the states?
- Customs duties
- Company taxes
- Estate duties
- Income tax
Show answer
Answer: C. Estate duties were assigned wholly to the states; the Centre kept customs and Company taxes and shared income tax and excise with the states.
-
3. Read this source (written for this lesson): 'Load every power on the Centre and it will stagger; give the provinces money and duties of their own, and the Centre too will be stronger.' Whose argument does this resemble?
- B.R. Ambedkar
- K. Santhanam
- Balakrishna Sharma
- Gopalaswami Ayyangar
Show answer
Answer: B. K. Santhanam argued that an overburdened Centre could not function effectively and that transferring some functions to the states would make the Centre stronger.
-
4. Assertion (A): After Partition, most nationalists changed their position and favoured a strong Centre. Reason (R): The earlier pressure to assure the Muslim League of provincial autonomy was gone, and the violence of the times pushed towards centralisation.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A.
- A is false, but R is true.
- A is true, but R is false.
- Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Show answer
Answer: D. The book explains the shift by the end of the pressure for decentralisation after Partition and the need to forestall chaos and plan development. R explains A.
-
5. Which of these taxes could the states levy and collect on their own, according to the textbook?
- Customs duties
- Sales tax
- Company taxes
- Estate duties shared with the Centre
Show answer
Answer: B. States could levy land and property taxes, sales tax and the tax on bottled liquor. Customs and Company taxes went wholly to the Centre.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.