• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Shock therapy and the transition to capitalism

Define shock therapy, list its features, and explain its economic, social and political consequences in Russia, Central Asia and eastern Europe as the textbook describes them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define shock therapy and identify who influenced the model.
  • List its main features: privatisation, free trade, opening up and new trade links.
  • Evaluate its consequences, including the economic recovery after 2000.

The collapse of communism was followed in most post-communist countries by a painful transition from an authoritarian socialist system to a democratic capitalist system. The model followed in Russia, Central Asia and eastern Europe, influenced by the World Bank and the IMF, came to be called shock therapy. Its intensity and speed varied from country to country, but its direction and features were similar.

Features of shock therapy

  • Total shift to capitalism: every structure built in the Soviet period was to be rooted out.
  • Private ownership was to become the dominant form of property; state assets were to be privatised and corporate ownership introduced immediately.
  • Collective farms were to be replaced by private farming and capitalism in agriculture.
  • No 'third way': the transition ruled out any path other than state-controlled socialism or capitalism.
  • External orientation: a sudden and complete switch to free trade; free trade and foreign direct investment (FDI) were to be the engines of change; openness to foreign investment, financial deregulation and currency convertibility.
  • New trade links: the old trade alliances within the Soviet bloc were broken up; each state was linked directly to the West rather than to its neighbours, and gradually absorbed into the Western economic system.

Shock therapy: the sudden, complete move from a state-controlled socialist economy to a market capitalist one, through rapid privatisation, free trade and opening to foreign capital, as advised by the World Bank and IMF.

— Definition in our words

Economic consequences

The textbook's verdict is blunt: shock therapy in the 1990s did not lead people to the promised utopia of mass consumption. Generally, it brought ruin to the economies and disaster on the people of the region.

  • In Russia, the large state-controlled industrial complex almost collapsed as about 90 per cent of its industries were put up for sale to private individuals and companies.
  • Because restructuring was left to market forces rather than government-directed industrial policy, entire industries virtually disappeared. This was called 'the largest garage sale in history': valuable industries were undervalued and sold at throwaway prices.
  • Citizens were given vouchers to take part in the sales, but most sold them on the black market because they needed money.
  • The ruble lost value dramatically, and inflation was so high that people lost all their savings.
  • The collective farm system disintegrated, leaving people without food security; Russia began importing food.
  • Russia's real GDP in 1999 was below what it was in 1989. The old trading structure broke down with nothing in its place. A photo caption in the book adds that about half of Russia's 1,500 banks and financial institutions went bankrupt.

Social and political consequences

  • The old welfare system was systematically destroyed; withdrawal of subsidies pushed large sections into poverty.
  • The middle classes were pushed to the margins, and academic and intellectual manpower disintegrated or migrated.
  • A mafia emerged in most of these countries and controlled many economic activities.
  • Privatisation created new disparities: rich and poor regions, and great inequality between people, unlike the earlier system.
  • Democratic institutions got less attention than economic change. Constitutions were drafted in a hurry; most, including Russia's, created a strong executive president who made elected parliaments relatively weak.
  • In Central Asia presidents had great powers and several became very authoritarian; the textbook's example is the presidents of Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan, who appointed themselves first for ten years and then extended it for another ten, allowing no dissent.
  • An independent judiciary and judicial culture were yet to be established in most of these countries.

How shock therapy hurt ordinary people in Russia

  1. Rapid sale of state industries About 90 per cent put up for sale, at throwaway prices
  2. Industries and jobs disappear No government-directed industrial policy to manage the change
  3. Ruble falls, inflation soars Savings wiped out
  4. Subsidies and welfare withdrawn Large sections pushed into poverty
  5. Inequality and mafia power New rich and poor; middle class and intellectuals marginalised

Revival after 2000

Most of these economies, especially Russia's, began reviving around 2000, ten years after independence. The main reason was the export of natural resources such as oil, natural gas and minerals. The textbook names Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Russia, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan as major oil and gas producers; other countries gained rent from oil pipelines crossing their territory. Some manufacturing also restarted.

Worked example 1: evaluating shock therapy

Question: Meera, a made-up economist, argues that a slower, government-guided transition would have hurt ordinary Russians less than shock therapy did. Use the chapter to assess her view. Building the answer: Part 1, define it and name the World Bank and IMF influence. Part 2, list features: privatisation, private farming, free trade, FDI, currency convertibility, new links with the West. Part 3, judge it with evidence from the chapter: industries sold at throwaway prices, lost savings, food insecurity, real GDP in 1999 below 1989, poverty, inequality, weak democratic institutions. A balanced conclusion: the textbook's evidence suggests a sudden, market-only transition caused great hardship; a gradual change with government-guided industrial policy and protection of welfare might have reduced the damage. Students may argue either way if they support their view with these facts.

Worked example 2: interpreting a phrase

Question: Why was the Russian sell-off called 'the largest garage sale in history'? Reasoning: at a garage sale, household items are sold off cheaply and quickly. Here, valuable state industries were undervalued and sold at throwaway prices, on a huge scale (about 90 per cent of industries put up for sale). Answer: the phrase captures both the scale and the cheapness of the sale of public assets.

Key takeaways: shock therapy, influenced by the World Bank and IMF, meant rapid privatisation, private farming, free trade, FDI, currency convertibility and new links with the West, with no 'third way'. In Russia it brought collapse of industry, a falling ruble, lost savings, food imports, a real GDP in 1999 below 1989, poverty, inequality and mafia power, while democracy was neglected under strong presidents. Recovery came from about 2000 through oil, gas and mineral exports.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The model of transition to capitalism called 'shock therapy' was influenced mainly by:

    1. the Warsaw Pact
    2. the Non-Aligned Movement
    3. the World Bank and the IMF
    4. the Commonwealth of Independent States
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says the transition model in Russia, Central Asia and eastern Europe was influenced by the World Bank and the IMF and came to be known as shock therapy.

  2. 2. Which was NOT a feature of shock therapy?

    1. A gradual 'third way' mixing socialism and capitalism
    2. Replacing collective farms with private farming
    3. Privatisation of state assets
    4. Currency convertibility and openness to FDI
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Shock therapy ruled out any alternative or 'third way' other than state-controlled socialism or capitalism. The other three were among its features.

  3. 3. According to the textbook, Russia's real GDP in 1999 was:

    1. double its 1989 level
    2. the same as in 1989
    3. the highest in Europe
    4. below its 1989 level
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter states that Russia's real GDP in 1999 was below what it was in 1989, one sign of the economic damage of shock therapy.

  4. 4. The economic revival of most post-Soviet economies from about 2000 came mainly from:

    1. the return of collective farms
    2. exports of natural resources such as oil, gas and minerals
    3. aid from the Warsaw Pact
    4. new space industries
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says the main reason for revival was the export of natural resources like oil, natural gas and minerals; some countries also earned rent from pipelines.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Elected parliaments in most post-Soviet states were relatively weak. Reason (R): Constitutions drafted in a hurry gave a strong executive president the widest possible powers.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: hurried constitutions created strong executive presidents, which rendered elected parliaments relatively weak, as the chapter notes for Russia and others.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery