• Foundation
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Why the Soviet Union disintegrated and what changed in world politics

Analyse the causes of the Soviet collapse, including the differing views the textbook presents, and explain its three broad consequences for world politics.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the internal economic and political weaknesses behind the collapse.
  • Present the two views on nationalism as the most immediate cause, as the textbook frames them.
  • Describe the three enduring consequences of the end of the Second World.

How did the second most powerful country in the world break up so quickly? The textbook treats this as a question worth asking not only about the USSR but about any political system, since this was not the first, and may not be the last, system to collapse. Some answers are fairly clear; others, it says honestly, are controversial and will be settled better by future historians.

Cause 1: internal weaknesses that failed people's aspirations

There is no doubt, according to the textbook, that the internal weaknesses of Soviet political and economic institutions, which failed to meet people's aspirations, were responsible for the collapse. Years of economic stagnation caused severe consumer shortages, and a large part of Soviet society began to doubt and question the system openly.

  • Economic burden: much of the economy's resources went into maintaining a nuclear and military arsenal and developing the satellite states in eastern Europe and within the Soviet system (especially the five Central Asian republics).
  • Awareness of the West: ordinary citizens learned more about the economic advance of the West. After years of being told their system was better, the reality of backwardness came as a political and psychological shock.
  • Administrative and political stagnation: the Communist Party had ruled for over 70 years without being accountable. People were alienated by slow, stifling administration, rampant corruption, a system unable to correct its mistakes, unwillingness to allow openness, and centralised authority in a vast land. Party bureaucrats enjoyed more privileges than ordinary citizens, and the government lost popular backing.

Cause 2: reforms that unleashed uncontrollable forces

Gorbachev diagnosed the problems accurately, so why did reform fail? The most basic answer the textbook offers is that loosening the system set in motion forces and expectations that few predicted and that became almost impossible to control. One section felt he was moving too slowly and was disappointed; another, mainly party members and those served by the system, felt he was moving too fast and eroding their power and privileges. In this tug of war Gorbachev lost support on all sides, and even his supporters became disillusioned.

The tug of war over Gorbachev's reforms

  • Reformers in a hurry
    • Wanted faster change
    • Benefited too slowly or not as hoped
    • Became impatient and disappointed
  • Party members and beneficiaries
    • Felt change was too fast
    • Saw power and privileges eroding
    • Opposed the reforms
  • Result
    • Gorbachev lost support on all sides
    • Public opinion divided
    • Even supporters disillusioned

Cause 3: nationalism, the final and most immediate cause

The rise of nationalism and the desire for sovereignty within various republics, including Russia, the Baltic republics (Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania), Ukraine and Georgia, proved to be the final and most immediate cause. The textbook presents two views:

  • View 1: nationalist feelings were at work throughout Soviet history, so there would have been an internal struggle with or without reform, given the size, diversity and growing problems of the USSR. The textbook calls this a 'what-if' of history, but not an unreasonable one.
  • View 2: Gorbachev's reforms speeded up and intensified nationalist dissatisfaction until the rulers could no longer control it.

The textbook notes an irony. During the Cold War many expected nationalist unrest to be strongest in Central Asia, given its ethnic and religious differences and economic backwardness. Instead it was strongest in the more 'European' and prosperous parts: Russia, the Baltic area, Ukraine and Georgia, where people felt they were paying too high a price to keep the more backward areas in the Union.

Consequences: three enduring changes

Consequences of the disintegration

  • End of Cold War confrontations
    • Ideological dispute over socialism versus capitalism ended
    • Called for an end to the arms race
    • Hope of a new peace
  • Change in power relations
    • The US became the sole superpower: a unipolar system
    • Capitalism the dominant world economic system
    • World Bank and IMF became powerful advisers
    • Liberal democracy seen as the best way to organise politics
  • Emergence of new countries
    • Baltic and east European states sought the EU and NATO
    • Central Asian states kept ties with Russia and built ties with the West, US, China
    • Many new players with their own interests

On power relations, the textbook says the end of the Cold War left two possibilities: the remaining superpower could dominate in a unipolar system, or several countries or groups could become important players in a multipolar system. As it turned out, the US became the sole superpower.

Bipolarity: a world order organised around two rival power centres. Its end left the US as the sole superpower, a unipolar order.

— Key idea in our words

Worked example 1: a source-based question

Source (written for this lesson): 'Shops were empty, the queues were long, and people now knew from radio and visitors how the other half of Europe lived.' Question: Which cause of the Soviet collapse does this reflect? Reasoning: empty shops point to economic stagnation and consumer shortages; knowledge of 'the other half of Europe' points to citizens' growing awareness of the West's prosperity. Answer: internal economic weakness combined with the political and psychological shock of seeing Soviet backwardness.

Worked example 2: unipolar or multipolar?

Question: Explain why the end of the Cold War produced a unipolar rather than a multipolar world. Reasoning: Step 1, the textbook says two outcomes were possible: one superpower dominating, or several powers sharing influence. Step 2, with the USSR gone, only the US remained a superpower. Step 3, its power and prestige made capitalism the dominant economic system and liberal democracy the favoured political model, and institutions like the World Bank and IMF advised the new states. Answer: because no other power could match the US once the USSR dissolved, the US became the sole superpower.

Key takeaways: internal weaknesses, an unbearable military and bloc burden, awareness of the West and an unaccountable party hollowed out support for the system. Gorbachev's reforms unleashed forces he could not control. Nationalism, strongest in the European and prosperous republics, was the final and most immediate cause; the textbook presents two views on its role. The consequences were the end of the Cold War, a unipolar US-led order with capitalism and liberal democracy dominant, and many new countries.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, the final and most immediate cause of the Soviet disintegration was:

    1. The rise of nationalism and the desire for sovereignty in the republics
    2. The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan
    3. Pressure from the United Nations
    4. The building of the Berlin Wall
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The chapter says the rise of nationalism and the desire for sovereignty within republics such as Russia, the Baltic states, Ukraine and Georgia proved to be the final and most immediate cause.

  2. 2. Nationalist dissatisfaction, the textbook notes, turned out to be strongest in:

    1. the Central Asian republics
    2. the east European satellite states only
    3. the more European and prosperous parts such as Russia, the Baltics, Ukraine and Georgia
    4. Siberia
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Ironically, it was strongest in the more European and prosperous parts, whose people felt they paid too high a price to keep backward areas in the Union, not in Central Asia as many had expected.

  3. 3. Why did Gorbachev lose support on all sides?

    1. He refused to make any reforms
    2. Some felt he moved too slowly while party members felt he moved too fast
    3. He was removed by a UN resolution
    4. He allied with China against the West
    Show answer

    Answer: B. In the 'tug of war', impatient reformers felt he was too slow and party members and beneficiaries felt he was too fast, so he lost support from both and divided public opinion.

  4. 4. Which of these is a consequence of the end of the Cold War given in the chapter?

    1. The return of a bipolar world
    2. The US lost its superpower status
    3. The Warsaw Pact grew stronger
    4. The World Bank and IMF became powerful advisers to the post-communist countries
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says institutions like the World Bank and IMF became powerful advisers since they gave loans for the transition to capitalism. The world became unipolar, not bipolar, with the US as sole superpower.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The Soviet economy could not cope with a huge economic burden. Reason (R): Much of its resources went into nuclear and military arsenals and into developing satellite states in eastern Europe and the Central Asian republics.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says spending on the military arsenal and on satellite and Central Asian states created a burden the system could not cope with.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery