• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ideas of development: modernisation, two models, left and right

Explain the idea of development as modernisation on the Western pattern, the two models before India in 1947, the meaning of left and right, and the debate between industry and agriculture.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the modernisation idea of development and why it was questioned.
  • Compare the liberal-capitalist and socialist models of development.
  • Define left and right as the textbook uses the terms.

Saying that 'everyone wants development' hides a deeper disagreement: development means different things to different people. This lesson looks at the ideas of development that shaped India's choices in the first decade after Independence.

Development means different things

The textbook gives an example: development means one thing to an industrialist planning a steel plant, another to an urban consumer of steel, and another to the Adivasi living in the region. So any discussion of development is bound to produce contradictions, conflicts and debates.

Development as modernisation

In the first decade after Independence it was common, as it still is, to treat the West as the standard for measuring development. Development meant becoming modern, and modern meant becoming more like the industrialised Western countries; experts and ordinary people alike thought this way. It was believed that every country would pass through modernisation as the West had: the breakdown of traditional social structures and the rise of capitalism and liberalism. Modernisation was also linked to growth, material progress and scientific rationality. This idea allowed people to classify countries as developed, developing or underdeveloped.

Modernisation view of development: becoming like the industrialised West, through the decline of traditional structures, the rise of capitalism and liberalism, growth, material progress and scientific rationality.

Two models before India

Models of modern development available in 1947

  • Liberal-capitalist model
    • Followed in much of Europe and the US
    • Market and private enterprise lead
    • Very few supporters in India at the time
  • Socialist model
    • Followed in the USSR
    • State plans and directs the economy
    • Admired by leaders of the CPI, the Socialist Party and leaders like Nehru in the Congress
As described in the textbook

The textbook explains that this preference reflected a broad consensus formed during the national movement. Nationalist leaders were clear that free India's government would have to do much more than the narrow commercial functions of the colonial government, and that poverty alleviation and redistribution were primarily the government's responsibility.

Left and right

Left and right: positions on social change and the state's role in redistribution
TermMeaning, as the textbook defines it
LeftFavours state control of the economy and prefers state regulation over free competition
RightBelieves free competition and the market economy alone ensure progress, and that government should not intervene unnecessarily

These terms describe where parties and groups stand on social change and on the role of the state in economic redistribution.

Industry or agriculture first?

Even within the consensus there were debates. For some, industrialisation was the preferred path. For others, the priority was agriculture, and especially the alleviation of rural poverty. This debate runs through the rest of the chapter.

Debates about development in the first decade

  • What development means
    • Different for industrialist, consumer and Adivasi
  • Which model
    • Liberal-capitalist
    • Socialist
  • Role of the state
    • Left: state control
    • Right: free market
  • Which sector first
    • Industrialisation
    • Agriculture and rural poverty

Worked example 1: placing a view on the left-right scale

Classify these made-up statements. (a) 'The government should own steel plants and regulate prices.' (b) 'Private firms competing freely will bring progress; the state should stay out.' Working: (a) prefers state control and regulation, so it is a left position. (b) relies on free competition and minimal intervention, so it is a right position, using the textbook's definitions.

Worked example 2: reading the consensus

Why did very few Indian leaders in 1947 support American-style capitalist development? Working: Step 1, the national movement had built a consensus that poverty alleviation and redistribution were the government's job. Step 2, the colonial government's narrow commercial role was seen as inadequate. Step 3, the Soviet model's state-led growth impressed leaders across the CPI, the Socialists and Nehru. So a model that left development mainly to private actors had little support.

Key takeaways

  • Development means different things to different groups, so it generates debate.
  • The modernisation view took the industrialised West as the standard.
  • Two models were available: liberal-capitalist (Europe, US) and socialist (USSR); the Soviet model impressed many Indian leaders.
  • Left favours state control; right favours free markets; there was also a debate between industry-first and agriculture-first.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the modernisation view described in the textbook, being 'modern' meant:

    1. returning to village self-sufficiency
    2. becoming more like the industrialised countries of the West
    3. rejecting science and technology
    4. following only religious traditions
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book says development was about becoming more modern, and modern meant becoming more like the industrialised West, with growth, material progress and scientific rationality.

  2. 2. Which group does the textbook say was impressed by the Soviet model of development?

    1. Only industrialists
    2. Only the British administrators
    3. Leaders of the CPI, the Socialist Party and leaders like Nehru in the Congress
    4. No Indian leaders
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Many were deeply impressed by the Soviet model, including leaders of the Communist Party of India, the Socialist Party and leaders like Nehru within the Congress.

  3. 3. As the textbook defines it, a 'right' position on the economy:

    1. prefers state regulation over free competition
    2. favours state ownership of all land
    3. rejects any economic growth
    4. believes free competition and the market economy alone ensure progress
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The right refers to those who believe free competition and the market economy ensure progress and that government should not unnecessarily intervene.

  4. 4. Which debate within the national consensus does the chapter mention?

    1. Whether India should have a monarchy
    2. Whether to join the cold war
    3. Whether to abolish the Constitution
    4. Whether industrialisation or agriculture and rural poverty should be the priority
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book says that for some, industrialisation was the preferred path, while for others the development of agriculture and alleviation of rural poverty came first.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Nationalist leaders expected the government of free India to do far more in the economy than the colonial government had done. Reason (R): They saw poverty alleviation and social and economic redistribution primarily as the government's responsibility.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: since poverty removal and redistribution were seen as the government's job, its role had to go well beyond the narrow commercial functions of colonial rule.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery