• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Second Plan, rapid industrialisation and its critics

Describe the Second Plan's strategy of heavy industry under P.C. Mahalanobis, the Avadi resolution, the role of tariffs and the public sector, and the problems and criticisms the textbook records.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Contrast the strategy of the Second Plan with that of the First.
  • Explain the role of the Avadi resolution, protective tariffs and the public sector.
  • List the problems and criticisms of the industrialisation strategy given in the textbook.

If the First Plan preached patience, the Second Plan wanted speed. This lesson explains the turn towards heavy industry, the political decision behind it, and the difficulties it created.

The Second Plan and heavy industry

The Second Five Year Plan stressed heavy industries. It was drafted by a team of economists and planners led by P.C. Mahalanobis, a scientist and statistician who founded the Indian Statistical Institute in 1931 and supported rapid industrialisation and an active public sector. The Second Plan aimed at quick structural transformation by making changes in all possible directions at the same time.

First and Second Plans compared

  • First Plan (1951-56)
    • Approach: patience, 'hasten slowly'
    • Focus: agriculture, dams, irrigation
    • Land reforms as key
    • Associated with K.N. Raj's argument
  • Second Plan (from 1956)
    • Approach: quick structural transformation
    • Focus: heavy industries
    • Public sector in key industries
    • Led by P.C. Mahalanobis

The Avadi resolution

Before the Second Plan was finalised, the Congress, at its session at Avadi near the then Madras city, passed an important resolution declaring the 'socialist pattern of society' as its goal. This was reflected in the Second Plan. (Chapter 2 showed how this declaration created a dilemma for the Socialist Party.)

Protection and the public sector

The government imposed substantial tariffs on imports to protect domestic industries. This protected environment helped both public and private sector industries grow. As savings and investment were rising in this period, many key industries such as electricity, railways, steel, machinery and communication were developed in the public sector. The textbook calls this push for industrialisation a turning point in India's development.

Protective tariff: a tax on imports that makes foreign goods dearer, so that domestic industries can grow in a sheltered market.

The logic of the Second Plan strategy

  1. Goal: socialist pattern of society Avadi resolution of the Congress
  2. Heavy industry first Quick structural transformation
  3. Protective tariffs Shield domestic industry from imports
  4. Public sector in key industries Electricity, railways, steel, machinery, communication

Problems and criticisms

The textbook's account of the difficulties
Problem or criticismExplanation in the textbook
Foreign exchangeIndia was technologically backward and had to spend scarce foreign exchange buying technology abroad
Risk of food shortageIndustry attracted more investment than agriculture, so food shortages loomed
Balancing sectorsPlanners found it very difficult to balance industry and agriculture
Urban biasCritics said plan strategies from this time showed an unmistakable urban bias
Wrong prioritySome felt industry was wrongly given priority over agriculture
Wrong kind of industrySome wanted agriculture-related industries rather than heavy ones

The Third Plan (from 1961), according to the book, was not significantly different from the Second, so these debates continued.

Worked example 1: how a tariff protects (illustrative numbers)

Suppose (made-up) an imported machine costs ₹10,000 and an Indian-made one costs ₹11,000. With no tariff, buyers prefer the import. Now a 20 per cent tariff is imposed on the import. Working: tariff = 20 per cent of ₹10,000 = ₹2,000. Imported price = 10,000 + 2,000 = ₹12,000. The Indian machine at ₹11,000 is now cheaper, so domestic producers can sell and grow. This is the protective effect the textbook describes.

Worked example 2: tracing a criticism

Explain how heavy-industry priority could lead to a food shortage. Working: Step 1, investment is limited. Step 2, the Second Plan directed more of it to industry than to agriculture. Step 3, farming received less for irrigation and inputs than it needed. Step 4, food production could lag behind a growing population. This is why the textbook says the possibility of food shortage 'loomed large'.

Key takeaways

  • The Second Plan, led by P.C. Mahalanobis, stressed heavy industry and quick structural transformation.
  • The Congress's Avadi resolution made the 'socialist pattern of society' its goal; this shaped the Plan.
  • Protective tariffs helped industry; key industries were developed in the public sector, a turning point.
  • Problems: foreign exchange costs, food shortage risk, balancing sectors; critics alleged urban bias and wrong priorities.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The Second Five Year Plan was drafted under the leadership of:

    1. P.C. Mahalanobis
    2. K.N. Raj
    3. Sukumar Sen
    4. Rammanohar Lohia
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Second Plan, which stressed heavy industries, was drafted by a team of economists and planners led by P.C. Mahalanobis.

  2. 2. The Congress declared the 'socialist pattern of society' as its goal at its session held at:

    1. Nagpur
    2. Avadi, near Madras
    3. Haripura
    4. Karachi
    Show answer

    Answer: B. At its session at Avadi near the then Madras city, the Congress declared the socialist pattern of society as its goal, and this was reflected in the Second Plan.

  3. 3. Why did the government impose substantial tariffs on imports during the Second Plan?

    1. To reduce the role of the public sector
    2. To increase imports of food
    3. To protect domestic industries
    4. To pay foreign debts
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The tariffs were imposed to protect domestic industries; this protected environment helped both public and private sector industries to grow.

  4. 4. Which criticism of the plan strategy is recorded in the textbook?

    1. It neglected industry entirely
    2. It gave too much land to industrialists
    3. It ended all public sector units
    4. It showed an unmistakable urban bias
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Critics said the plan strategies from this time showed an unmistakable urban bias; others felt industry was wrongly prioritised over agriculture.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The push for industrialisation in the Second Plan created the risk of food shortages. Reason (R): India was technologically backward and had to spend foreign exchange to buy technology.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both statements are true, but R does not explain A. The food-shortage risk arose because industry attracted more investment than agriculture. The foreign-exchange problem is a separate difficulty of the strategy.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery