| Group | Main concern (as the textbook presents the case) |
|---|---|
| State government | Capital investment and employment from steel plants |
| Tribal population | Displacement from their homes and loss of livelihood |
| Environmentalists | Pollution from mining and industry |
| Central government | Blocking industry would set a bad example and discourage investment in the country |
How a democracy should decide a development question
- Identify the interests Industry, local communities, environment, nation
- Take expert advice Economists, environmentalists, mining experts
- Weigh groups and generations Present against future; one group against another
- Political decision By people's representatives, approved by the people
Development decisions weigh one group's interests against another's and the present against the future; experts advise, but in a democracy the final decision is political.
The development debate after Independence
-
Broad agreement
- Development means economic growth AND social and economic justice
- It cannot be left to businessmen, industrialists and farmers alone
- The government must play a key role
-
Contested questions
- Is a centralised planning body needed for the whole country?
- Should the government itself run key industries and businesses?
- How much weight should justice get when it conflicts with growth?
- The third challenge was economic development for all; the book says success here was more limited.
- Development involves conflicting interests, as the Orissa iron-ore case shows.
- Experts advise, but development decisions must finally be political.
- There was agreement on growth with justice and a key role for government, but disagreement on the form of that role.