Revision notes

Chapter 3 Politics of Planned Development: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Development as a political question

Interests in the Orissa iron-ore case
GroupMain concern (as the textbook presents the case)
State governmentCapital investment and employment from steel plants
Tribal populationDisplacement from their homes and loss of livelihood
EnvironmentalistsPollution from mining and industry
Central governmentBlocking industry would set a bad example and discourage investment in the country

How a democracy should decide a development question

  1. Identify the interests Industry, local communities, environment, nation
  2. Take expert advice Economists, environmentalists, mining experts
  3. Weigh groups and generations Present against future; one group against another
  4. Political decision By people's representatives, approved by the people

Development decisions weigh one group's interests against another's and the present against the future; experts advise, but in a democracy the final decision is political.

The development debate after Independence

  • Broad agreement
    • Development means economic growth AND social and economic justice
    • It cannot be left to businessmen, industrialists and farmers alone
    • The government must play a key role
  • Contested questions
    • Is a centralised planning body needed for the whole country?
    • Should the government itself run key industries and businesses?
    • How much weight should justice get when it conflicts with growth?
  • The third challenge was economic development for all; the book says success here was more limited.
  • Development involves conflicting interests, as the Orissa iron-ore case shows.
  • Experts advise, but development decisions must finally be political.
  • There was agreement on growth with justice and a key role for government, but disagreement on the form of that role.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Ideas of development: modernisation, two models, left and right

Modernisation view of development: becoming like the industrialised West, through the decline of traditional structures, the rise of capitalism and liberalism, growth, material progress and scientific rationality.

Models of modern development available in 1947

  • Liberal-capitalist model
    • Followed in much of Europe and the US
    • Market and private enterprise lead
    • Very few supporters in India at the time
  • Socialist model
    • Followed in the USSR
    • State plans and directs the economy
    • Admired by leaders of the CPI, the Socialist Party and leaders like Nehru in the Congress
As described in the textbook
Left and right: positions on social change and the state's role in redistribution
TermMeaning, as the textbook defines it
LeftFavours state control of the economy and prefers state regulation over free competition
RightBelieves free competition and the market economy alone ensure progress, and that government should not intervene unnecessarily

Debates about development in the first decade

  • What development means
    • Different for industrialist, consumer and Adivasi
  • Which model
    • Liberal-capitalist
    • Socialist
  • Role of the state
    • Left: state control
    • Right: free market
  • Which sector first
    • Industrialisation
    • Agriculture and rural poverty
  • Development means different things to different groups, so it generates debate.
  • The modernisation view took the industrialised West as the standard.
  • Two models were available: liberal-capitalist (Europe, US) and socialist (USSR); the Soviet model impressed many Indian leaders.
  • Left favours state control; right favours free markets; there was also a debate between industry-first and agriculture-first.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The consensus on planning and the Planning Commission

Why planning gained support worldwide (as the textbook explains)

  • Great Depression The experience of economic collapse in Europe
  • Reconstruction The inter-war reconstruction of Japan and Germany
  • Soviet growth Spectacular growth against heavy odds in the USSR in the 1930s and 1940s

Bombay Plan (1944): a joint proposal by a section of big industrialists for a planned economy in which the state would take major initiatives in industrial and economic investment.

The Planning Commission at a glance
FeatureAccording to the textbook
Set upMarch 1950
HowBy a simple resolution of the Government of India; it was not created by the Constitution
RoleAdvisory; its recommendations took effect only when the Union Cabinet approved them
ChairpersonThe Prime Minister
ImportanceBecame the most influential and central machinery for deciding India's path of development
LaterReplaced by NITI Aayog (National Institution for Transforming India), which came into existence on 1 January 2015

From consensus to machinery

  1. Consensus Development cannot be left to private actors
  2. Support from left to right Including industrialists' Bombay Plan, 1944
  3. Planning Commission Set up March 1950 by government resolution
  4. Five Year Plans The Commission's chosen method
  • There was consensus that the government must plan development.
  • Planning gained world support from the Great Depression, reconstruction of Japan and Germany, and Soviet growth.
  • The Bombay Plan (1944) by industrialists also supported a planned, state-led economy.
  • The Planning Commission (March 1950, by resolution, advisory, chaired by the Prime Minister) was replaced by NITI Aayog on 1 January 2015, according to the textbook.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Five Year Plans and the First Plan (1951-1956)

Plan and non-plan budget, as the textbook explains
Part of the budgetWhat it covers
Non-plan budgetRoutine items, spent year by year
Plan budgetSpent over five years according to the priorities fixed by the plan

Planning in the first two decades (textbook)

  1. First Plan document Released December 1951; widely discussed
  2. Second Plan, 1956 Excitement with planning at its peak
  3. Third Plan, 1961 Enthusiasm continued somewhat
  4. Fourth Plan due, 1966 Novelty gone; acute economic crisis; 'plan holiday'

First Plan: focus on agriculture, irrigation and land reforms, with the cautious approach summed up as 'hasten slowly'.

The logic of the savings problem

  1. Goal Raise national income
  2. Requirement Save more, to invest more
  3. Constraint 1 Spending already very low; cannot be cut
  4. Constraint 2 Low capital stock relative to employable people
  5. Result (textbook) Savings rose modestly, then fell from early 1960s to early 1970s
  • A Five Year Plan sets five-year priorities; budgets split into plan and non-plan parts.
  • First Plan document: December 1951; excitement peaked in 1956; 'plan holiday' when the Fourth Plan was due in 1966.
  • First Plan (1951-56): agriculture, dams, irrigation (Bhakra Nangal) and land reforms; K.N. Raj's 'hasten slowly'.
  • Raising savings was hard because spending was low and capital stock small.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

The Second Plan, rapid industrialisation and its critics

First and Second Plans compared

  • First Plan (1951-56)
    • Approach: patience, 'hasten slowly'
    • Focus: agriculture, dams, irrigation
    • Land reforms as key
    • Associated with K.N. Raj's argument
  • Second Plan (from 1956)
    • Approach: quick structural transformation
    • Focus: heavy industries
    • Public sector in key industries
    • Led by P.C. Mahalanobis

Protective tariff: a tax on imports that makes foreign goods dearer, so that domestic industries can grow in a sheltered market.

The logic of the Second Plan strategy

  1. Goal: socialist pattern of society Avadi resolution of the Congress
  2. Heavy industry first Quick structural transformation
  3. Protective tariffs Shield domestic industry from imports
  4. Public sector in key industries Electricity, railways, steel, machinery, communication
The textbook's account of the difficulties
Problem or criticismExplanation in the textbook
Foreign exchangeIndia was technologically backward and had to spend scarce foreign exchange buying technology abroad
Risk of food shortageIndustry attracted more investment than agriculture, so food shortages loomed
Balancing sectorsPlanners found it very difficult to balance industry and agriculture
Urban biasCritics said plan strategies from this time showed an unmistakable urban bias
Wrong prioritySome felt industry was wrongly given priority over agriculture
Wrong kind of industrySome wanted agriculture-related industries rather than heavy ones
  • The Second Plan, led by P.C. Mahalanobis, stressed heavy industry and quick structural transformation.
  • The Congress's Avadi resolution made the 'socialist pattern of society' its goal; this shaped the Plan.
  • Protective tariffs helped industry; key industries were developed in the public sector, a turning point.
  • Problems: foreign exchange costs, food shortage risk, balancing sectors; critics alleged urban bias and wrong priorities.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery