- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Conflict with the judiciary and the declaration of Emergency
Explain the constitutional disputes between Parliament and the judiciary, the Allahabad High Court judgment of 12 June 1975, and how and under which Article the Emergency was declared on 25 June 1975.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- State the three constitutional issues and the Kesavananda Bharati ruling.
- Explain why the 1973 appointment of the Chief Justice was controversial.
- Describe the events of 12-26 June 1975 and the legal basis of the Emergency.
The confrontation between the government and the judiciary reached its climax in June 1975. This lesson explains the constitutional background and the declaration of the Emergency, following the textbook closely.
Three constitutional issues
| Question | Supreme Court's answer (as summarised in the textbook) |
|---|---|
| Can Parliament abridge Fundamental Rights? | No |
| Can Parliament curtail the right to property by amendment? | Parliament cannot amend the Constitution so as to curtail rights |
| Can Parliament abridge Fundamental Rights to give effect to Directive Principles? | The Court rejected this provision too |
This crisis culminated in the Kesavananda Bharati case (1973), in which the Court held that the Constitution has certain basic features that Parliament cannot amend.
Basic structure (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973): Parliament can amend the Constitution, but not in a way that alters its basic features.
Supersession of judges
Right after the 1973 ruling the post of Chief Justice fell vacant. The practice had been to appoint the senior-most judge, but the government set aside the seniority of three judges and appointed Justice A.N. Ray. The textbook says this became politically controversial because all three superseded judges had ruled against the government's stand. People close to the Prime Minister began speaking of the need for a judiciary and bureaucracy 'committed' to the vision of the executive and legislature. The climax was the High Court ruling on Indira Gandhi's election.
The Allahabad High Court judgment
On 12 June 1975, Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha of the Allahabad High Court declared Indira Gandhi's election to the Lok Sabha invalid, on an election petition by Raj Narain, a socialist leader who had contested against her in 1971. The petition alleged that she had used the services of government servants in her campaign. Legally she was no longer an MP and could not remain Prime Minister unless re-elected within six months. On 24 June the Supreme Court gave a partial stay: until her appeal was decided she could remain an MP but could not take part in Lok Sabha proceedings.
Crisis and response
Ten days in June 1975 (textbook sequence)
- 12 June Allahabad High Court declares the election invalid
- 24 June Supreme Court grants a partial stay
- 25 June Opposition rally at Ramlila grounds; JP calls for nationwide satyagraha
- Night of 25 June PM recommends Emergency; President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed issues proclamation
- After midnight Electricity to major newspaper offices cut
- Early 26 June Many opposition leaders and workers arrested
- 6 a.m., 26 June Cabinet informed at a special meeting
Opposition parties led by JP pressed for Indira Gandhi's resignation and held a massive demonstration at Delhi's Ramlila grounds on 25 June 1975. JP announced a nationwide satyagraha and asked the army, police and government employees not to obey 'illegal and immoral orders', which, the book says, also threatened to bring government to a standstill. The government's response was to declare that there was a threat of internal disturbances and to invoke Article 352, which then allowed an emergency on grounds of external threat or internal disturbance. The textbook notes that, technically, this was within the government's powers.
What an emergency does
- The federal distribution of powers is practically suspended, and power is concentrated in the Union government.
- The government can curtail or restrict any or all Fundamental Rights.
- The Constitution treats an emergency as an extraordinary condition in which normal democratic politics cannot function, so it grants special powers.
Worked example 1: following the legal chain
Explain why the High Court verdict created a crisis for the Prime Minister. Working: Step 1, the verdict made her election invalid. Step 2, a minister who is not an MP can stay in office only if elected within six months. Step 3, the Supreme Court's partial stay let her remain an MP but barred her from Lok Sabha proceedings. Step 4, the opposition demanded resignation and planned mass satyagraha. The government answered with an emergency on the ground of internal disturbance.
Worked example 2: a question the textbook raises
The book notes that the Cabinet was informed only after the proclamation, arrests and press measures. Frame the constitutional issue without taking a political side. Working: in a parliamentary system the President acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers; here the Cabinet was informed after the fact. The textbook later records that the rules were changed so that advice to proclaim an emergency must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet (lesson 4).
Key takeaways
- Three constitutional disputes led to the Kesavananda Bharati ruling (1973) on basic features.
- The 1973 appointment of Justice A.N. Ray, superseding three judges, was controversial.
- 12 June 1975: Allahabad High Court (Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha) invalidated the election on Raj Narain's petition; 24 June: partial stay.
- 25 June 1975: Emergency under Article 352 on the ground of internal disturbance; Cabinet informed at 6 a.m. on 26 June.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which case held that Parliament cannot amend the basic features of the Constitution?
- The Raj Narain case
- The Kesavananda Bharati case
- The habeas corpus case of 1976
- The privy purse case
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the conflict culminated in the Kesavananda Bharati case of 1973, in which the Court held there are basic features Parliament cannot amend.
-
2. Why did the appointment of Justice A.N. Ray as Chief Justice in 1973 become controversial?
- He was not a judge of the Supreme Court
- He was appointed by the opposition
- The seniority of three judges who had ruled against the government was set aside
- He had been elected to Parliament
Show answer
Answer: C. The practice was to appoint the senior-most judge; the government superseded three judges, all of whom had given rulings against the government's stand.
-
3. On what ground did the Allahabad High Court declare Indira Gandhi's election invalid?
- That she was under age
- That she was not a citizen
- That the votes were counted twice
- That she had used the services of government servants in her campaign
Show answer
Answer: D. The election petition by Raj Narain challenged her election on the ground that she had used the services of government servants in her campaign.
-
4. Under which Article was the Emergency of 1975 declared?
- Article 356
- Article 51
- Article 368
- Article 352
Show answer
Answer: D. On 25 June 1975 the government declared a threat of internal disturbances and invoked Article 352, which allowed an emergency on grounds of external threat or internal disturbance.
-
5. Assertion (A): During an emergency, the federal distribution of powers remains practically suspended. Reason (R): Once an emergency is proclaimed, all powers are concentrated in the hands of the Union government.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: concentrating power in the Union government is exactly what suspends the normal federal division of powers during an emergency.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.