• Foundation
  • About 17 min
  • 5 practice questions

The Emergency in practice and its lessons

Describe what the Emergency meant in practice (censorship, bans, suspension of rights, preventive detention, the 1976 habeas corpus judgment, constitutional amendments), acts of resistance, and the lessons the textbook draws.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • List the main consequences of the Emergency for rights, the press and the courts.
  • Describe the constitutional changes made during the Emergency.
  • State the lessons of the Emergency and the issues the textbook says remain unresolved.

The Emergency lasted about eighteen months. This lesson describes how it worked in practice and what lessons the textbook draws from it.

Immediate consequences

Consequences of the Emergency (as listed in the textbook)

  • Political activity
    • Agitation stopped abruptly
    • Strikes banned; protests and public agitations disallowed
    • Many opposition leaders jailed
  • Press
    • Freedom of the press suspended
    • Prior approval needed for all material: press censorship
  • Organisations
    • RSS and Jamait-e-Islami banned, citing fear of social and communal disharmony
  • Rights and courts
    • Fundamental Rights suspended, including the right to move the courts
    • Extensive preventive detention

Preventive detention and the courts

Preventive detention means arresting and detaining people not because they have committed an offence but on the apprehension that they may. The government used preventive detention laws to make large-scale arrests, and arrested political workers could not challenge their arrest through habeas corpus petitions. The government even claimed it need not tell arrested persons the reasons. Several High Courts ruled that courts could still hear a habeas corpus petition during the Emergency, but in April 1976 a constitution bench of the Supreme Court overruled them and accepted the government's plea. The textbook says this meant the government could take away the right to life and liberty during the Emergency, that it closed the doors of the judiciary to citizens, and that it is regarded as one of the Supreme Court's most controversial judgments.

Habeas corpus: a court order requiring a detained person to be produced before the court so that the legality of the detention can be examined.

Dissent and resistance

There were acts of resistance. Political workers not arrested in the first wave went underground and organised protests. Newspapers such as the Indian Express and the Statesman left blank spaces where news had been censored; magazines such as Seminar and Mainstream closed down rather than submit. Many journalists were arrested, and underground newsletters and leaflets bypassed censorship. Kannada writer Shivarama Karanth and Hindi writer Fanishwarnath Renu returned their national awards in protest. The textbook adds that, by and large, such open defiance was rare.

Constitutional changes

  • An amendment declared that elections of the Prime Minister, President and Vice-President could not be challenged in court (made in the background of the Allahabad ruling).
  • The Forty-second Amendment made many changes; one extended the duration of legislatures from five to six years, intended to be permanent.
  • During an emergency elections could be postponed by one year, so after 1971, elections effectively needed to be held only in 1978 instead of 1976.

Lessons of the Emergency

What the Emergency showed, according to the textbook

  • Lessons learnt
    • It is extremely difficult to do away with democracy in India; normal functioning resumed quickly
    • Internal emergency now only on 'armed rebellion', on written advice of the Union Cabinet
    • Greater awareness of civil liberties; courts more active; civil liberties groups formed
  • Issues still unresolved
    • The right balance between routine government and continuous protest
    • Limits of the right to protest
    • Police and administration turned into political instruments (Shah Commission Report)

The textbook notes that some observers think India ceased to be democratic during the Emergency, but that normal democratic functioning resumed within a short time. It records that, according to the Shah Commission Report, the administration and police became vulnerable to political pressures, a problem that did not vanish after the Emergency.

Worked example 1: what changed in the emergency provisions

Compare the 1975 provision with the position after the rectification the textbook describes. Working: 1975: an internal emergency could be proclaimed on the ground of 'internal disturbance', and the Cabinet was informed after the proclamation. After rectification: 'internal' emergency only on the ground of armed rebellion, and the advice to the President must be given in writing by the Union Cabinet. Both changes narrow the power and make it harder to use without collective responsibility.

Worked example 2: counting the extended term

Show why elections were 'due' in 1978 rather than 1976. Working: last Lok Sabha election: 1971. Normal five-year term: 1971 + 5 = 1976. With the term extended to six years by the Forty-second Amendment: 1971 + 6 = 1977; with the one-year postponement allowed during an emergency, 1977 + 1 = 1978. This matches the textbook. In fact, as lesson 5 shows, elections were called for March 1977.

Key takeaways

  • Strikes and protests banned, leaders jailed, press censored, RSS and Jamait-e-Islami banned, Fundamental Rights suspended.
  • Preventive detention was used widely; in April 1976 the Supreme Court accepted the government's plea on habeas corpus, a judgment the book calls one of its most controversial.
  • Resistance included blank spaces in newspapers and returned awards, but open defiance was rare.
  • Lessons: democracy proved hard to remove; emergency provisions were tightened; civil liberties gained importance; police and administration remained vulnerable to political pressure.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Preventive detention, as explained in the textbook, means:

    1. punishing a person after conviction by a court
    2. arresting a person on the apprehension that he or she may commit an offence
    3. detaining a person for a traffic offence
    4. arresting only foreign nationals
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Under preventive detention, people are arrested not because they have committed an offence but on the apprehension that they may commit one.

  2. 2. Which two writers does the textbook mention as returning their awards in protest against the Emergency?

    1. Amrita Pritam and Faiz Ahmed Faiz
    2. Saadat Hasan Manto and Kaifi Azmi
    3. Shivarama Karanth and Fanishwarnath Renu
    4. Ramachandra Guha and Rajni Kothari
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Kannada writer Shivarama Karanth (Padma Bhushan) and Hindi writer Fanishwarnath Renu (Padma Shri) returned their awards in protest.

  3. 3. After the changes the textbook describes, on what ground alone can an 'internal' emergency be proclaimed?

    1. Economic crisis
    2. Internal disturbance
    3. Armed rebellion
    4. Defeat of the government in Parliament
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The ambiguities were rectified: an internal emergency can now be proclaimed only on the ground of armed rebellion, and the Union Cabinet's advice must be in writing.

  4. 4. The Forty-second Amendment changed the duration of legislatures:

    1. from four to five years
    2. from six to five years
    3. from five to seven years
    4. from five to six years
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Among its many changes, the Forty-second Amendment extended the duration of legislatures from five to six years, intended to be permanent.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The April 1976 habeas corpus judgment is regarded as one of the Supreme Court's most controversial judgments. Reason (R): It overruled the High Courts and accepted the government's plea, closing the doors of the judiciary to detained citizens during the Emergency.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: by accepting that detentions could not be challenged during the Emergency, the judgment meant the government could take away the right to life and liberty, which is why the book calls it controversial.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery