Revision notes

Chapter 6 The Crisis of Democratic Order: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Background to the Emergency: political and economic strains, 1971-1974

Competing views in the early 1970s (as the textbook reports them)

  • The Congress's position
    • The Court's stand went against democracy and parliamentary supremacy
    • The Court was a conservative institution
    • It obstructed pro-poor welfare programmes
  • Opposition parties' position
    • Politics was becoming too personalised
    • Governmental authority was being turned into personal authority
The 1969 split had sharpened divisions between Indira Gandhi and her opponents.
Economic strains of the early 1970s
ProblemWhat the textbook says
Bangladesh crisisAbout eight million (80 lakh) refugees came into India, followed by war with Pakistan; a heavy strain on the economy
Aid stoppedAfter the war the US government stopped all aid to India
Oil pricesOil prices rose manifold internationally, raising prices of all commodities
InflationPrices rose by 23 per cent in 1973 and 30 per cent in 1974
Industry and jobsIndustrial growth was low; unemployment was very high, especially in rural areas
Salary freezeTo cut expenditure the government froze its employees' salaries, causing dissatisfaction
Monsoon failureMonsoons failed in 1972-1973; food grain output fell by 8 per cent

From economic strain to protest

  1. Refugees, war and loss of aid Strain on resources
  2. Oil price rise and monsoon failure Prices up 23% (1973) and 30% (1974)
  3. Hardship and unemployment Salary freeze adds to discontent
  4. General dissatisfaction Opposition organises protests effectively

Inflation, as used here: a general rise in the prices of goods over time; according to the textbook, prices in India rose 23 per cent in 1973 and 30 per cent in 1974.

  • Party competition became bitter; government-judiciary tensions grew; each side saw the other's stand as a threat to democracy.
  • Economic strains: about 80 lakh refugees, war, US aid stopped, oil price rise, inflation of 23% (1973) and 30% (1974), monsoon failure and an 8% fall in food grain output (textbook).
  • Student unrest and Naxalite activity increased.
  • General dissatisfaction let opposition parties organise protests effectively.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

The Gujarat and Bihar movements, JP and the railway strike

Total revolution (Sampoorna Kranti): JP's call for change in the social, economic and political spheres to establish what he regarded as true democracy.

How the Bihar movement grew (textbook sequence)

  1. March 1974 Students protest over prices, scarcity, unemployment, corruption
  2. JP invited to lead Conditions: non-violence and a national scope
  3. Demand and call Dismissal of Bihar government; total revolution
  4. Spread Bandhs, gheraos, strikes; JP seeks to extend it nationally
  5. 1975 march to Parliament One of the largest rallies in the capital

How different actors saw the agitations (as the textbook presents them)

  • Movement and supporters
    • Protest against prices, scarcity, unemployment and corruption
    • JP: total revolution for true democracy
    • Opposition projected JP as an alternative
  • Government and critics
    • Seen as anti-Congress, aimed at Indira Gandhi's leadership
    • Indira Gandhi: motivated by personal opposition to her
    • Criticism of JP's ideas and of mass-agitation politics
  • Gujarat (from January 1974): student agitation, President's rule, elections in June 1975, Congress defeated.
  • Bihar (from March 1974): JP led on condition of non-violence and national scope; called for total revolution.
  • Railway strike (May 1974, led by George Fernandes): declared illegal, ended after twenty days without settlement.
  • Opposition projected JP as an alternative; Indira Gandhi saw the movement as personal opposition to her.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Conflict with the judiciary and the declaration of Emergency

The conflict between Parliament and the judiciary
QuestionSupreme Court's answer (as summarised in the textbook)
Can Parliament abridge Fundamental Rights?No
Can Parliament curtail the right to property by amendment?Parliament cannot amend the Constitution so as to curtail rights
Can Parliament abridge Fundamental Rights to give effect to Directive Principles?The Court rejected this provision too

Basic structure (Kesavananda Bharati, 1973): Parliament can amend the Constitution, but not in a way that alters its basic features.

Ten days in June 1975 (textbook sequence)

  1. 12 June Allahabad High Court declares the election invalid
  2. 24 June Supreme Court grants a partial stay
  3. 25 June Opposition rally at Ramlila grounds; JP calls for nationwide satyagraha
  4. Night of 25 June PM recommends Emergency; President Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed issues proclamation
  5. After midnight Electricity to major newspaper offices cut
  6. Early 26 June Many opposition leaders and workers arrested
  7. 6 a.m., 26 June Cabinet informed at a special meeting
  • Three constitutional disputes led to the Kesavananda Bharati ruling (1973) on basic features.
  • The 1973 appointment of Justice A.N. Ray, superseding three judges, was controversial.
  • 12 June 1975: Allahabad High Court (Justice Jagmohan Lal Sinha) invalidated the election on Raj Narain's petition; 24 June: partial stay.
  • 25 June 1975: Emergency under Article 352 on the ground of internal disturbance; Cabinet informed at 6 a.m. on 26 June.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The Emergency in practice and its lessons

Consequences of the Emergency (as listed in the textbook)

  • Political activity
    • Agitation stopped abruptly
    • Strikes banned; protests and public agitations disallowed
    • Many opposition leaders jailed
  • Press
    • Freedom of the press suspended
    • Prior approval needed for all material: press censorship
  • Organisations
    • RSS and Jamait-e-Islami banned, citing fear of social and communal disharmony
  • Rights and courts
    • Fundamental Rights suspended, including the right to move the courts
    • Extensive preventive detention

Habeas corpus: a court order requiring a detained person to be produced before the court so that the legality of the detention can be examined.

What the Emergency showed, according to the textbook

  • Lessons learnt
    • It is extremely difficult to do away with democracy in India; normal functioning resumed quickly
    • Internal emergency now only on 'armed rebellion', on written advice of the Union Cabinet
    • Greater awareness of civil liberties; courts more active; civil liberties groups formed
  • Issues still unresolved
    • The right balance between routine government and continuous protest
    • Limits of the right to protest
    • Police and administration turned into political instruments (Shah Commission Report)
  • Strikes and protests banned, leaders jailed, press censored, RSS and Jamait-e-Islami banned, Fundamental Rights suspended.
  • Preventive detention was used widely; in April 1976 the Supreme Court accepted the government's plea on habeas corpus, a judgment the book calls one of its most controversial.
  • Resistance included blank spaces in newspapers and returned awards, but open defiance was rare.
  • Lessons: democracy proved hard to remove; emergency provisions were tightened; civil liberties gained importance; police and administration remained vulnerable to political pressure.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Politics after the Emergency: 1977, the Janata government and 1980

The 1977 verdict
Result, 1977 Lok SabhaAccording to the textbook
Congress154 seats; vote share below 35 per cent
Janata Party and allies330 of 542 seats
Janata Party alone295 seats: a clear majority
North IndiaCongress lost every seat in Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Delhi, Haryana and Punjab; one seat each in Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh
ElsewhereCongress retained many seats in Maharashtra, Gujarat and Orissa and virtually swept the southern states

Reasons for the regional pattern (as the textbook explains)

  • Uneven impact of the Emergency Forced relocation, displacement and forced sterilisations were concentrated in the northern states
  • Long-term change in the north Middle castes were moving away from the Congress; the Janata Party became their platform

From Emergency to 1980 (textbook sequence)

  1. January 1977 Elections announced; leaders released
  2. March 1977 Congress defeated; Janata Party wins a clear majority
  3. Janata government Desai PM; power struggle; split; majority lost in under 28 months
  4. Charan Singh government Lasts about 4 months after Congress withdraws support
  5. January 1980 Congress wins 353 seats and returns to power

Two lessons the textbook draws: voters severely punish governments seen as anti-democratic (1977), and governments seen as unstable and quarrelsome (1980).

  • Elections were announced in January 1977 and held in March; the Janata Party formed under JP's leadership.
  • Congress: 154 seats, under 35 per cent votes; Janata and allies 330 of 542; Janata alone 295 (textbook).
  • The north voted against the Congress, the south largely did not; 1977 was not only about the Emergency.
  • The Janata government fell within 28 months; in January 1980 the Congress won 353 seats.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery