• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Economic consequences of globalisation

Explain what economic globalisation involves, why the movement of people lags behind other flows, why the same policies produce different results, and the main positions in the debate about its effects.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain economic globalisation and why the distribution of gains matters.
  • Describe the changes in flows of commodities, capital, ideas and people.
  • Compare the views of critics, advocates and moderate supporters of economic globalisation.

The economic side of globalisation shapes much of the debate about it. The textbook warns against defining it too narrowly as the work of international institutions such as the IMF and the WTO. Many other actors are involved, and a broader view asks about the distribution of economic gains: who gains most, who gains less, and who loses.

What economic globalisation involves

Economic globalisation usually involves greater economic flows among countries; some are voluntary, and some are forced by international institutions and powerful countries.

Economic flows under globalisation
FlowWhat has changed (as the textbook describes)
CommoditiesGreater trade across the globe; restrictions on imports have been reduced
CapitalRestrictions on movement of capital reduced; investors in rich countries can invest in other countries, including developing ones, for better returns
IdeasFlow across borders, for example the spread of the internet and computer-related services
PeopleHas not increased to the same degree; developed countries guard their borders with visa policies so that others cannot take their citizens' jobs

Another key point: the same policies do not lead to the same results everywhere. Governments in different parts of the world have adopted similar economic policies, but the outcomes have been vastly different. Again, context matters more than simple generalisations.

The debate

Positions on economic globalisation, as the textbook presents them

  • Concerned about social justice
    • Worried about state withdrawal
    • Benefits may go to a small section
    • Those dependent on state jobs and welfare may be impoverished
    • Call for institutional safeguards: social safety nets
  • Many movements and some economists
    • Safety nets insufficient or unworkable
    • Call for a halt to forced globalisation
    • Fear economic ruin for weaker countries and the poor
    • Some economists call it re-colonisation of the world
  • Advocates
    • Greater growth and well-being with deregulation
    • Trade lets each economy do what it does best
    • Globalisation is inevitable; unwise to resist
  • Moderate supporters
    • A challenge to be met intelligently
    • Accept it, but not uncritically

Whatever one's position, the textbook notes that one thing cannot be denied: globalisation has increased the momentum towards interdependence and integration between governments, businesses and ordinary people in different parts of the world.

Social safety net: institutional safeguards meant to protect the economically weak from the negative effects of globalisation, for example when the state withdraws from welfare.

— Key term in our words

Worked example 1: why capital moves (illustrative numbers)

Question: A made-up investor in a rich country can earn 2 per cent a year at home or 7 per cent a year by investing in a developing country. With ₹10,00,000 to invest for one year, how much more does she earn abroad, ignoring risks and costs? Working: at home, 2 per cent of ₹10,00,000 = ₹20,000. Abroad, 7 per cent of ₹10,00,000 = ₹70,000. Difference = ₹70,000 − ₹20,000 = ₹50,000. Point: when restrictions on capital are reduced, such differences in returns draw capital across borders, as the textbook describes. Real decisions also weigh risk, which is not included here.

Worked example 2: identifying the position

Question: Which position does each made-up statement reflect? (i) 'Open markets let every country specialise in what it does best, so everyone gains.' (ii) 'If the state cuts welfare, it must at least protect the poorest through special schemes.' (iii) 'This is nothing but a new colonisation of poor countries.' (iv) 'Let us engage with globalisation, but on our own terms.' Answer: (i) advocates; (ii) social justice view calling for safety nets; (iii) critics who call it re-colonisation; (iv) moderate supporters.

Key takeaways: economic globalisation involves more than the IMF and WTO; the key question is who gains and who loses. Flows of commodities, capital and ideas have increased, while movement of people remains restricted by visa policies. Similar policies have produced different results in different places. Views range from calls for safety nets, to calls to halt forced globalisation as re-colonisation, to advocates who see growth and inevitability, to moderates who would engage critically; but increased interdependence is undeniable.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Why, according to the chapter, has the movement of people not increased as much as other flows?

    1. Developed countries guard their borders with visa policies
    2. People do not want to travel
    3. There are no jobs anywhere
    4. Technology has stopped travel
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says developed countries have carefully guarded their borders with visa policies so that citizens of other countries cannot take away their citizens' jobs.

  2. 2. A broader understanding of economic globalisation, as the textbook suggests, requires us to look at:

    1. only the IMF and WTO
    2. only the number of factories
    3. the distribution of economic gains: who gains most, who gains less and who loses
    4. military spending
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says we should look at the distribution of economic gains, not only at international institutions.

  3. 3. Those concerned about social justice have emphasised the need for:

    1. more military alliances
    2. social safety nets to protect the economically weak
    3. ending all trade
    4. abolishing the state
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says they emphasise institutional safeguards or social safety nets to minimise globalisation's negative effects on the economically weak.

  4. 4. Which argument is made by advocates of economic globalisation?

    1. It is re-colonisation of the world
    2. It should be halted immediately
    3. Safety nets are unworkable
    4. It generates greater growth and well-being when there is deregulation
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Advocates argue that deregulation generates greater economic growth and well-being, that trade lets each economy do what it does best, and that globalisation is inevitable.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Similar economic policies have produced vastly different outcomes in different parts of the world. Reason (R): The consequences of globalisation depend on specific contexts.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because local contexts differ, the same set of policies does not lead to the same results everywhere, as the textbook stresses.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery