• Foundation
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

India and globalisation, and resistance to globalisation

Trace India's experience from colonial times through protectionism to the 1991 reforms, and explain the arguments of critics on the left and the right, global anti-globalisation movements, and resistance in India, as the textbook presents them.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe India's economic path from colonialism to protectionism to the 1991 reforms.
  • Compare the critiques of globalisation from the left and the right.
  • Describe anti-globalisation movements worldwide and in India, with the textbook's examples.

Flows of capital, commodities, ideas and people go back several centuries in Indian history. This lesson follows India's recent experience of globalisation and then the resistance to it, worldwide and in India. The views below are presented as the textbook frames them.

India's path

India and globalisation

  1. Colonial period India exports primary goods and raw materials and consumes finished goods
  2. After independence: protectionism Make things ourselves; restrict imports so domestic producers learn
  3. Problems of protectionism Health, housing and primary education neglected; sluggish growth
  4. 1991: economic reforms Response to a financial crisis and desire for higher growth; deregulation of trade and foreign investment

The textbook's verdict on the reforms is cautious: it may be too early to say how good they have been, and the ultimate test is not high growth rates but making sure the benefits of growth are shared so that everyone is better off.

Protectionism: a policy of restricting imports so that a country's own producers can develop. India followed it after independence and began deregulating trade and foreign investment in 1991.

— Key term in our words

Critics on the left and the right

Two critiques of globalisation

  • From the left
    • A phase of global capitalism that makes the rich richer and fewer, and the poor poorer
    • Weakening of the state reduces its capacity to protect the poor
  • From the right
    • Politically: fear of a weaker state
    • Economically: return to self-reliance and protectionism in some areas
    • Culturally: fear that traditional culture and age-old values will be harmed

Anti-globalisation movements

  • Anti-globalisation movements themselves take part in global networks, allying with like-minded groups in other countries.
  • Many are not opposed to globalisation as such but to a specific programme of globalisation, which they see as a form of imperialism.
  • In 1999, at the WTO Ministerial Meeting in Seattle, there were widespread protests alleging unfair trading practices by economically powerful states and arguing that the developing world's interests were not given enough importance.
  • The World Social Forum (WSF) is a global platform bringing together human rights activists, environmentalists, labour, youth and women activists opposed to neo-liberal globalisation. Its first meeting was in Porto Alegre, Brazil, in 2001; its fourth was in Mumbai in 2004.

Resistance in India

Resistance to globalisation in India
Source of resistanceForm it has taken (as the textbook describes)
Left-wingProtests against economic liberalisation through political parties and forums such as the Indian Social Forum
Trade unions and farmers' organisationsProtests against the entry of multinationals
Opposition to patentsConsiderable opposition to the patenting of certain plants, such as neem, by American and European firms
Political rightObjections mainly to cultural influences: foreign TV channels on cable networks, celebration of Valentine's Day, and westernisation of dress among students

The textbook adds that social movements help people make sense of the world around them and find ways to deal with matters that trouble them.

Worked example 1: left or right critique?

Question: Classify each made-up statement as closer to the left or the right critique described in the textbook. (i) 'Globalisation weakens the state so it can no longer protect poor workers.' (ii) 'We should protect certain industries and become self-reliant again.' (iii) 'Foreign festivals and fashions are eroding our traditions.' (iv) 'This phase of capitalism makes a few people richer and the poor poorer.' Answer: (i) left; (ii) right (economic self-reliance and protectionism); (iii) right (cultural); (iv) left. Note: both sides fear a weaker state, for different reasons.

Worked example 2: why oppose a patent?

Question: Why might patenting of a plant like neem by foreign firms provoke opposition in India? Reasoning: Step 1, neem's uses are part of long-standing traditional knowledge in India. Step 2, a patent gives a firm exclusive rights over a product or process. Step 3, critics fear that knowledge developed over generations could be claimed and profited from by outside firms. Conclusion: this is why the textbook records considerable opposition; it illustrates resistance to a specific programme of globalisation rather than to all global exchange.

Key takeaways: India moved from colonial exporter of raw materials, to post-independence protectionism with sluggish growth and neglected social sectors, to the 1991 reforms; the textbook says the real test is whether growth benefits everyone. Critics on the left see a capitalism that widens inequality and weakens the state's ability to protect the poor; critics on the right worry about the state, self-reliance and culture. Anti-globalisation movements, themselves globally networked, protested at Seattle (1999) and meet in the World Social Forum (Porto Alegre 2001, Mumbai 2004). In India, resistance has come from the left, trade unions, farmers, opponents of plant patents such as on neem, and the right on cultural grounds.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. India began its programme of economic reforms, deregulating trade and foreign investment, in:

    1. 1947
    2. 1991
    3. 1971
    4. 2004
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says that in 1991, in response to a financial crisis and the desire for higher growth, India embarked on economic reforms.

  2. 2. According to the textbook, the ultimate test of India's economic reforms is:

    1. high growth rates alone
    2. the size of exports
    3. the number of foreign companies
    4. making sure the benefits of growth are shared so everyone is better off
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The chapter says the ultimate test is not high growth rates so much as ensuring that the benefits of growth are shared.

  3. 3. The first meeting of the World Social Forum was held in:

    1. Porto Alegre, Brazil, in 2001
    2. Seattle in 1999
    3. Mumbai in 2004
    4. Rio de Janeiro in 1992
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook says the first WSF meeting was organised in Porto Alegre, Brazil, in 2001; the fourth was held in Mumbai in 2004.

  4. 4. Which is an objection the textbook attributes to critics of globalisation on the political right in India?

    1. Patenting of neem
    2. Entry of multinationals into farming
    3. Celebration of Valentine's Day and foreign TV channels
    4. Liberalisation of the banking sector
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The chapter says resistance from the political right has objected particularly to cultural influences such as foreign TV channels, Valentine's Day and westernised dress among students.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Many anti-globalisation movements are not opposed to globalisation as such. Reason (R): They oppose a specific programme of globalisation, which they see as a form of imperialism.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says many such movements object to a particular programme they see as imperialist, not to the idea of globalisation itself.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Globalisation

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery