• Foundation
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

A new consensus and the future of democratic politics

Explain the four elements of the broad consensus that the textbook says emerged among most parties, how popular movements keep raising new issues, and the book's conclusion about democracy in India.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the four elements of the new consensus described in the textbook.
  • Explain how coalition politics shifted parties from ideology towards power sharing.
  • Explain the textbook's closing view of popular movements and democracy.

The period after 1989 is sometimes described as the decline of the Congress and the rise of the BJP. The textbook asks students to look more carefully: alongside intense competition, a broad agreement has emerged among most parties on several crucial issues. This lesson explains that consensus and the book's conclusion.

Reading the competition

The textbook's charts invite students to compare the electoral fortunes of the Congress and the BJP since 1989. It notes that the votes of these two parties together added up to more than half of all votes in most elections after 1989, except in 1996, 2004 and 2009, and that politics in the 1990s was divided between a coalition led by the BJP and one led by the Congress, with some parties outside both.

Four elements of the new consensus

The broad consensus among most parties (textbook)

  • 1. New economic policies Most parties support them, believing they lead to prosperity and economic power, though many groups oppose them
  • 2. Claims of backward castes All parties now support reservations for backward classes in education and jobs, and a share of power for OBCs
  • 3. Role of state-level parties The distinction between state and national parties is becoming less important; state parties share power nationally
  • 4. Pragmatism over ideology Coalitions focus on power sharing; alliances form without ideological agreement

On the fourth element, the textbook gives an example: most parties in the NDA did not agree with the BJP's Hindutva ideology, yet they formed a government together and stayed in power for a full term. This shows coalition politics shifting focus from ideological differences to power-sharing arrangements.

The new consensus, as the textbook describes it: agreement among most parties on economic reforms, on the claims of backward castes, on the role of state parties, and on pragmatic, power-sharing alliances.

From dominance to competitive consensus

The book's arc, from Chapter 2 to Chapter 8

  1. One-party dominance The Congress system after 1952
  2. Challenges and restoration 1967 to 1971
  3. Crisis and change The Emergency and 1977
  4. Coalition era From 1989
  5. Competitive politics with implicit agreement The new consensus

The textbook concludes that India has moved from Congress dominance to more competitive politics, but politics based on a certain implicit agreement among the main actors. Even as parties act within this consensus, popular movements and organisations are identifying new forms and pathways of development. Issues like poverty, displacement, minimum wages, livelihood and social security are being put on the agenda by people's movements, and questions of justice and democracy are raised in terms of class, caste, gender and region. The book says we cannot predict the future of democracy, but democratic politics is here to stay in India and will unfold through a continuous churning of these factors.

Worked example 1: identifying the element

Classify each made-up observation under one of the four elements. (a) Parties that disagree on cultural questions agree to share ministries. (b) A party from one state holds important posts in the central government. (c) Rival parties all promise to continue market-oriented reforms. (d) Every major party backs reservation for backward classes. Working: (a) is element 4, pragmatism over ideology. (b) is element 3, role of state-level parties. (c) is element 1, economic policies. (d) is element 2, claims of backward castes.

Worked example 2: does consensus end debate?

Use the textbook's conclusion to answer. Working: Step 1, the consensus is among most parties. Step 2, the book notes that many groups still oppose the new economic policies. Step 3, people's movements keep raising issues such as displacement, wages and social security. So consensus among parties narrows party differences but does not end public debate; new questions come from outside the party system.

Key takeaways

  • Behind intense competition, most parties broadly agree on four points, according to the textbook.
  • These are: new economic policies, claims of backward castes, the role of state parties, and pragmatic alliances.
  • Coalitions shifted the focus from ideology to power sharing; the NDA is the book's example.
  • Popular movements keep raising issues of poverty, displacement, wages and justice; democratic politics is here to stay.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which of these is NOT one of the four elements of the new consensus described in the textbook?

    1. Agreement to abolish coalition governments
    2. Acceptance of the claims of backward castes
    3. Acceptance of the role of state-level parties
    4. Agreement on new economic policies
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The four elements are agreement on economic policies, acceptance of backward castes' claims, acceptance of state-level parties' role, and pragmatism over ideology. Abolishing coalitions is not one of them.

  2. 2. What example does the textbook give of pragmatism over ideology in coalition politics?

    1. The Congress and the BJP formed a joint government
    2. Most NDA parties did not agree with the BJP's Hindutva ideology yet governed together for a full term
    3. All parties merged into one
    4. The Left joined the NDA government
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The book says most NDA parties did not share the BJP's Hindutva ideology but formed a government and stayed in power for a full term, showing focus on power sharing.

  3. 3. In which three elections did the combined vote of the Congress and the BJP NOT exceed half of all votes, according to the textbook?

    1. 1989, 1991 and 1998
    2. 1999, 2014 and 2019
    3. 1996, 2004 and 2009
    4. 1984, 1989 and 1991
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook notes that since 1989 the two parties' combined vote usually exceeded fifty per cent, except in 1996, 2004 and 2009.

  4. 4. According to the textbook's conclusion, who is putting issues like poverty, displacement and minimum wages on the political agenda?

    1. Only the Election Commission
    2. Only the courts
    3. Only foreign governments
    4. People's movements
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The book says that while parties act within the consensus, people's movements are putting issues like poverty, displacement, minimum wages, livelihood and social security on the agenda.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The textbook says the distinction between state-level and national-level parties is fast becoming less important. Reason (R): State-level parties have shared power at the national level and played a central role in national politics.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: because state parties have shared power at the Centre in coalition governments, the old line between state and national parties has blurred.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery