- Foundation
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Communalism, secularism and democracy: the debates of the 1980s and 1990s
Describe, strictly as the textbook does, the formation of the BJP, the idea of Hindutva as its believers state it, the Shah Bano case, and the course of the Ayodhya dispute to the Supreme Court verdict of 9 November 2019, presenting each view with its source.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the formation of the BJP in 1980 and the changes in its ideology given in the textbook.
- Explain the Shah Bano case and the different reactions to it that the textbook records.
- Outline the stages of the Ayodhya dispute and its legal resolution, as stated in the textbook.
The textbook identifies a visible rise of politics based on religious identity in this period, which led to a debate about secularism and democracy. This is a sensitive topic. In this lesson every statement of fact is taken from the textbook and every evaluation is credited to the person or group who made it. The lesson does not take sides.
The formation of the BJP
After the Emergency, the Bharatiya Jana Sangh merged with the Janata Party (Chapter 6). After the Janata Party fell and broke up, supporters of the former Jana Sangh formed the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in 1980. According to the textbook, it first adopted a broader platform, embracing 'Gandhian Socialism' along with cultural nationalism, but did not do well in the 1984 election. After 1986 it began to emphasise nationalism as the core of its ideology and pursued the politics of 'Hindutva' for political mobilisation.
The textbook explains Hindutva as popularised by Vinayak Damodar Savarkar as the basis of Indian nationhood: to be an Indian, one must accept India as one's fatherland (pitrubhu) and holy land (punyabhu). It reports that believers in Hindutva argue that a strong nation can be built on a united national culture and that, in India's case, Hindutva can provide this base. This is a description of a belief as its holders state it, not an endorsement or a criticism.
The Shah Bano case
The book names two developments around 1986 as central to the BJP's politics. The first was the Shah Bano case (1985): a 62-year-old divorced Muslim woman sought maintenance from her former husband, and the Supreme Court ruled in her favour. The textbook records several reactions:
Reactions to the Shah Bano case, as recorded in the textbook
- Orthodox Muslims Saw the Court's order as interference in Muslim Personal Law
- The government On the demand of some Muslim leaders, passed the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986, which nullified the judgment
- Opponents of the Act Many women's organisations, many Muslim groups and most intellectuals opposed the government's action
- The BJP Criticised the government's action as an unnecessary concession and 'appeasement' of the minority community
The Ayodhya dispute
The second development was the Ayodhya issue. The textbook describes it as rooted in the country's socio-cultural and political history, involving different perspectives of various stakeholders, and concerning both the birthplace of Shri Ram, a deeply revered religious site, and legal ownership of the site. It records that a three-dome structure was built at the site in 1528, and that the issue developed into a prolonged legal battle.
| Year | Stage of the dispute, as stated in the textbook |
|---|---|
| 1528 | A three-dome structure built at the site |
| 1949 | The structure sealed because court proceedings had begun |
| 1986 | The Faizabad (now Ayodhya) district court ordered the structure unlocked, allowing worship; tensions over ownership rose between communities |
| 1992 | The structure was demolished; some critics contended this was a substantial challenge to the principles of Indian democracy |
| 9 November 2019 | A constitutional bench of the Supreme Court gave a 5-0 verdict resolving the dispute |
The textbook says that both communities wanted a fair resolution, with Hindus feeling that their concerns about the birthplace were overlooked and Muslims seeking assurance of their possession. It says that through court hearings, mediation attempts, popular movements and finally the 5-0 verdict of 9 November 2019, the issue was resolved. The verdict allotted the disputed site to the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Teertha Kshetra Trust for construction of a temple and directed the government to allot an appropriate site for a mosque to the Sunni Central Waqf Board. The textbook presents the verdict as an example of resolving conflict through due process of law, based on evidence such as archaeological excavations and historical records, and it quotes the judgment's statement that the Constitution treats all faiths as equal before the law.
The textbook's general point: in a multi-religious democratic society, conflicts are bound to arise, and they are meant to be resolved through the due process of law.
Worked example 1: separating fact from evaluation
Sort these statements about the Shah Bano case. (a) The Supreme Court ruled in favour of Shah Bano. (b) The 1986 Act nullified the judgment. (c) The government's action was 'appeasement'. Working: (a) and (b) are facts reported by the textbook. (c) is an evaluation, which the textbook attributes to the BJP. A careful answer reports (c) as 'the BJP criticised the action as appeasement', not as a fact. The same method applies to all contested topics.
Worked example 2: building a timeline
Put these in order and give years: unlocking of the structure; formation of the BJP; Supreme Court verdict on Ayodhya; Shah Bano judgment; sealing of the structure. Working: sealing, 1949; BJP formed, 1980; Shah Bano judgment, 1985; unlocking, 1986; Supreme Court verdict, 9 November 2019.
Key takeaways
- The BJP was formed in 1980; after 1986 it emphasised nationalism and Hindutva, as the textbook states.
- Shah Bano (1985): the Court ruled for her; the 1986 Act nullified the ruling; reactions differed, as the textbook records.
- Ayodhya: structure built 1528, sealed 1949, unlocked 1986, demolished 1992; resolved by a 5-0 Supreme Court verdict on 9 November 2019.
- On sensitive topics, report facts as facts and attribute every evaluation to its source.
Check your understanding
-
1. In which year was the Bharatiya Janata Party formed, according to the textbook?
- 1951
- 1980
- 1977
- 1986
Show answer
Answer: B. After the Janata Party fell and broke up, supporters of the former Jana Sangh formed the BJP in 1980.
-
2. What did the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986 do, according to the textbook?
- It upheld the Supreme Court's judgment
- It nullified the Supreme Court's judgment in the Shah Bano case
- It created the Mandal Commission
- It ended the Ayodhya dispute
Show answer
Answer: B. On the demand of some Muslim leaders, the government passed the 1986 Act, which nullified the Supreme Court's judgment in favour of Shah Bano.
-
3. Which of these groups does the textbook record as opposing the government's 1986 Act?
- Only the Supreme Court
- Only foreign governments
- Many women's organisations, many Muslim groups and most intellectuals
- No group opposed it
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook says the government's action was opposed by many women's organisations, many Muslim groups and most of the intellectuals; the BJP also criticised it.
-
4. What did the Supreme Court's 5-0 verdict of 9 November 2019 provide, according to the textbook?
- The site was divided equally between three parties
- The site was made a protected monument with no construction
- The case was sent back to the district court
- The disputed site was allotted to a trust for a temple, and the government was directed to allot an appropriate site for a mosque to the Sunni Central Waqf Board
Show answer
Answer: D. The verdict allotted the disputed site to the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi Teertha Kshetra Trust and directed the government to allot an appropriate site for a mosque to the Sunni Central Waqf Board.
-
5. Assertion (A): The three-dome structure at Ayodhya was sealed in 1949. Reason (R): The structure was sealed because of the onset of court proceedings.
- Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
- Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
- A is true, but R is false
- A is false, but R is true
Show answer
Answer: A. Both are true and R explains A: the textbook says the prolonged legal battle led to the structure being sealed in 1949 due to the onset of court proceedings.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.