- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Accountability and checks and balances
Explain how Parliament holds the executive accountable through Question Hour, committees and the budget, compare the legislature and the executive, and describe how the judiciary checks both.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain executive accountability (Question Hour, committees) and financial accountability (the budget).
- Compare the roles of the legislature and the executive.
- Explain the separation of powers and how the judiciary checks the other organs.
Power without questions can be misused. India's Constitution makes sure that those who govern must explain themselves. This lesson shows how Parliament questions the government, controls its money, and how the courts check both.
Executive accountability
The Prime Minister and the Council of Ministers implement laws, run the government and take day-to-day decisions according to the Constitution and laws. They are answerable to the Lok Sabha. One key tool is Question Hour, usually the first hour of a sitting, when MPs ask ministers about government policies and activities, and ministers must justify their actions. Committees of Parliament, often with members from different parties, also call officials of ministries to explain and answer questions. A Standing Committee, for example, studies a ministry's work, makes recommendations and then examines the government's reply on what action it took.
Accountability: the duty of the government to explain and justify its actions and decisions to the people's representatives, for example by answering questions in Parliament.
Financial accountability
Parliament approves and monitors government spending through the annual budget and examines how money is distributed among ministries. The government must give Parliament timely and accurate information. Why does Parliament watch spending so closely? Because the government spends public money, raised from the people through taxes.
Legislature and executive compared
| Aspect | Legislature (Parliament) | Executive |
|---|---|---|
| Composition | The President, the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha | The President, the Vice President and the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister |
| Main role | Makes laws and oversees the executive | Enforces the laws made by the legislature |
| Bills | Members can introduce some bills | Introduces most bills |
| Questions | Checks the executive by asking questions and seeking explanations | Gives information and explanations on its decisions |
| Money | Sanctions all government expenses | Prepares and implements the budget approved by Parliament |
The judiciary and checks and balances
The judiciary interprets and applies the law, including settling disputes, through a system of courts. It is the custodian of the Constitution: it checks that laws passed by Parliament do not violate the Constitution, and it can step in if the executive breaks the Constitution while implementing laws. It also safeguards Fundamental Rights.
Together these arrangements show the separation of powers, each organ with its own job, and a system of checks and balances, each organ able to check the others, so that no one organ becomes too powerful.
Checks and balances among the three organs
- Legislature Makes laws; questions the executive and approves its spending.
- Executive Implements laws; must answer to the legislature.
- Judiciary Checks that laws and actions follow the Constitution.
Then back to step 1: Legislature
Worked example 1: reading a committee report
Suppose a Standing Committee on Health recommends (similar to the report extract shown in the textbook) that the health ministry persuade states to set up special departments for a health programme. The ministry replies that health is a state subject, so creating such departments is for state governments, but it has urged them to do so. Reading it: who reports to whom? The ministry reports to the committee. What is reviewed? How the programme is organised in states. What is shown? The executive must explain its action to Parliament, and federal limits (state subjects) shape what the Union can do.
Worked example 2: what if one organ had all power?
Imagine a government that made laws, carried them out and judged disputes about them, with no one to question it. It could pass a law limiting free speech, enforce it harshly and then rule in its own favour in court. Citizens would have no protection. With separation of powers, Parliament could question the law, the courts could strike down a law that violates Fundamental Rights, and the executive would have to follow the courts. This is why checks and balances protect citizens' rights.
Key takeaways
- Ministers are answerable to the Lok Sabha through Question Hour and parliamentary committees.
- Parliament approves and monitors spending through the annual budget, because it is public money.
- The legislature makes laws and oversees; the executive enforces laws and introduces most bills.
- The judiciary is custodian of the Constitution; separation of powers and checks and balances stop any organ becoming too powerful.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is Question Hour?
- The hour when the President addresses Parliament
- Usually the first hour of a sitting, when MPs ask ministers about government policies and actions
- The time when bills are signed
- An hour for judges to question MPs
Show answer
Answer: B. Question Hour lets MPs question ministers, who must justify their actions; it is a key tool of executive accountability.
-
2. Why does Parliament keep a close watch on government spending?
- Because the government spends public money raised from the people
- Because MPs pay for government projects
- Because the judiciary prepares the budget
- Because spending is decided by the President alone
Show answer
Answer: A. Government money comes from the people through taxes, so their representatives must approve and monitor how it is spent.
-
3. Which organ prepares and implements the budget approved by Parliament?
- The judiciary
- The Rajya Sabha alone
- The Election Commission
- The executive
Show answer
Answer: D. The executive prepares and implements the budget; the legislature sanctions government expenses.
-
4. Which statement best describes the role of the judiciary?
- It introduces most bills
- It runs government departments
- It checks that laws and government actions follow the Constitution
- It elects the Prime Minister
Show answer
Answer: C. The judiciary is the custodian of the Constitution, interpreting laws, resolving disputes and checking that laws and actions respect the Constitution.
-
5. Assertion (A): India has a system of checks and balances among the legislature, executive and judiciary.
Reason (R): It ensures that no one organ becomes too powerful.- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
Show answer
Answer: A. Each organ checks the others, which is the purpose of the system: to prevent any organ from becoming too powerful and to protect citizens' rights.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.