- Foundation
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Government in the states and challenges to legislatures
Compare the union and state governments, explain the Union, State and Concurrent Lists, and discuss challenges to the working of legislatures and how citizens can help.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the Union, State and Concurrent Lists with examples.
- Compare the structure of the union and state governments, including unicameral and bicameral state legislatures.
- Describe challenges to the functioning of legislatures and ways citizens can strengthen them.
India's federal system has governments at two main levels above the local one: the Union (centre) and the states. Each has a legislature and an executive. This lesson compares them and then asks a frank question: how well are our legislatures working?
Who makes laws on what?
The Constitution has three lists of subjects. The Union List has subjects on which only Parliament can make laws. The State List has subjects on which only state legislatures can make laws. The Concurrent List has subjects on which both can make laws; but if Parliament makes a law on a Concurrent subject, the state must follow it. Education is on the Concurrent List, which is why the RTE Act applies across India. Subjects like education and environmental policy need cooperation between the Union and the states, showing that federalism is interdependent.
Division of law-making powers
- Union List Only Parliament makes laws.
- State List Only state legislatures make laws.
-
Concurrent List
Both can make laws; a Union law prevails.
- Example: education (the RTE Act applies all over India)
Union and state: parallel structures
The state structure mirrors the Union structure. MLAs in a state assembly make laws on State List and Concurrent List subjects, much as MPs make laws on Union List and Concurrent List subjects.
| Feature | Union | State |
|---|---|---|
| Constitutional head | President, elected by an electoral college | Governor, appointed by the President |
| Real executive authority | Prime Minister | Chief Minister |
| Who leads the government | Leader of the majority party or coalition in the Lok Sabha | Leader of the majority party or coalition in the Vidhan Sabha |
| Council of Ministers | Selected by the Prime Minister; collectively responsible to the Lok Sabha | Selected by the Chief Minister; collectively responsible to the Vidhan Sabha |
| Legislature | Bicameral: Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha | Unicameral (Vidhan Sabha) or bicameral (Vidhan Sabha and Vidhan Parishad) |
| Presiding officer of lower house | Speaker | Speaker |
| Term of lower house | 5 years | 5 years |
| Money bills begin in | Lok Sabha only | Vidhan Sabha only |
State legislatures can be unicameral (one house, the Vidhan Sabha or Legislative Assembly) or bicameral (also a Vidhan Parishad or Legislative Council). According to the textbook, the states with two houses are Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Telangana and Uttar Pradesh; the rest have one.
Concurrent List: subjects on which both Parliament and state legislatures can make laws; if both do, the law made by Parliament prevails.
Challenges to legislatures
Legislatures make laws, oversee administration, approve budgets and provide a forum to discuss policies and public grievances. But they face challenges: absenteeism of members, non-cooperative conduct, weaker debates, and disruptions, including of Question Hour. Parliament usually meets in three sessions a year: the Budget, Monsoon and Winter sessions. Each session has sittings, usually about six hours a day. Productivity in Parliament means the hours a house actually worked compared with the hours scheduled. When debates are disrupted, sessions are cut short and bills wait for years, people's trust suffers. Concern has also been raised that many representatives face criminal cases and that some debates are angry or one-sided.
| Lok Sabha | Sessions | Sittings |
|---|---|---|
| 1st (1952-1957) | 14 | 677 |
| 2nd (1957-1962) | 16 | 567 |
| 10th (1991-1996) | 16 | 423 |
| 13th (1999-2004) | 14 | 356 |
Worked example 1: reading the table
Compare the 1st and 13th Lok Sabhas. Both had 14 sessions, but sittings fell from 677 to 356, a drop of 677 − 356 = 321 sittings, nearly half (321 ÷ 677 is about 47 per cent). Average sittings per session: 677 ÷ 14 ≈ 48 for the 1st Lok Sabha, and 356 ÷ 14 ≈ 25 for the 13th. Conclusion: over these decades Parliament met far less often, leaving less time for debating laws and questioning the government.
Worked example 2: productivity (made-up figures)
Suppose a house was scheduled to sit for 120 hours in a session but actually worked 78 hours because of disruptions. Productivity = 78 ÷ 120 × 100 = 65 per cent. The 42 lost hours (120 − 78) could have been used for debates, questions and examining bills. Measuring productivity this way helps citizens judge how well their representatives use Parliament's time.
What citizens can do
Democracy grows stronger when citizens stay informed and engaged: asking questions, sharing views, joining public discussions (including the online consultations government departments hold while making policies) and engaging constructively with representatives. Young people and new voices entering public life, and technology that makes it easier to follow governance, can help. As future voters, your choices and participation will help make legislatures serve everyone.
Key takeaways
- The Union, State and Concurrent Lists divide law-making; on Concurrent subjects a Union law prevails.
- States mirror the Union: Governor (appointed by the President) and Chief Minister; Vidhan Sabha, and in some states a Vidhan Parishad.
- Challenges include absenteeism, disruptions and fewer sittings; productivity compares hours worked with hours scheduled.
- Informed, engaged citizens help legislatures work better.
Check your understanding
-
1. On which subjects can both Parliament and state legislatures make laws?
- Union List subjects
- State List subjects
- Concurrent List subjects
- No subjects
Show answer
Answer: C. The Concurrent List has subjects for both, such as education. If Parliament legislates on them, its law prevails.
-
2. Who is the constitutional head of a state, and how is that person chosen?
- The Chief Minister, elected by voters
- The Governor, appointed by the President
- The Speaker, elected by MLAs
- The President, elected by MLAs
Show answer
Answer: B. The Governor is the constitutional (nominal) head of a state and is appointed by the President; the Chief Minister is the real executive authority.
-
3. According to the textbook, which of these states has a bicameral legislature?
- Kerala
- Punjab
- Gujarat
- Bihar
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook lists Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Karnataka, Maharashtra, Telangana and Uttar Pradesh as bicameral; the others named are unicameral.
-
4. A house was scheduled for 150 hours but worked 90 hours. What was its productivity? (Made-up figures.)
- 60 per cent
- 40 per cent
- 90 per cent
- 150 per cent
Show answer
Answer: A. Productivity = hours worked ÷ hours scheduled × 100 = 90 ÷ 150 × 100 = 60 per cent.
-
5. Assertion (A): The RTE Act applies all over India.
Reason (R): Education is on the Concurrent List, and a law made by Parliament on a Concurrent subject must be followed by the states.- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
- Both A and R are false
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
Show answer
Answer: D. Because education is a Concurrent subject and Parliament made the RTE law, states are bound to follow it, so it applies across India.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.