• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Justice, law and the judiciary

Explain why justice matters, how laws aim at justice, why unjust laws are repealed, and the difference between substantive and procedural justice, and describe the judiciary's place among the three organs of government.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the link between law and justice and the role of the judiciary.
  • Give examples of unjust laws in India and abroad and explain why they were repealed.
  • Distinguish between substantive justice and procedural justice.

Think of a time someone was unfair to you. You probably wanted the wrong put right - an apology, a punishment or compensation. The other person probably wanted a chance to explain. A good justice system has to satisfy both needs. The Preamble to our Constitution promises every citizen social, economic and political justice, and the judiciary is the institution that makes sure disputes are decided fairly, according to law.

The judiciary: one of three pillars

Government has three organs: the legislature (makes laws), the executive (carries them out) and the judiciary (settles disputes and interprets laws). The judiciary is independent of the other two, so it can decide cases fairly. It also checks that laws passed by the legislature stay within the framework of the Constitution, and that the executive does not overstep its role.

The three organs of government

  • Legislature
    • Makes laws
  • Executive
    • Implements laws
  • Judiciary
    • Settles disputes
    • Checks that laws and actions follow the Constitution
    • Independent of the other two

Law and justice

As societies grew larger, governments were given the power to run them through laws and to enforce those laws. Laws are general rules that regulate people's activities and set consequences for breaking them: a fine, compensation to the person harmed, or even imprisonment. The judicial system is the arrangement through which a person with a grievance can complain, and both sides can present their views, so that justice is done within the law and the Constitution.

Unjust laws are repealed

A law can itself be unjust. After independence, many colonial-era laws were found to be discriminatory and against the principles of a democracy. According to the textbook, the government has repealed over 1,500 such laws. Examples include the Criminal Tribes Act, 1871, which labelled certain communities as criminals by birth, and the Vernacular Press Act, 1878, which restricted the freedom of the press.

Other countries had unjust laws too. The Jim Crow laws in parts of the United States barred African Americans and other people of colour from facilities reserved for white people, such as water fountains, pools and restaurants; they were ended in the 1960s. Under apartheid in South Africa, people were divided by law on the basis of race; those laws were repealed in 1991. Such laws denied people a life with dignity.

Worked example 1: is this law just?

Suppose a law said that everyone born in a certain community is a criminal. Step 1: Does it judge people by what they did, or by birth? By birth. Step 2: Does it treat equal people equally? No. Step 3: Does it respect dignity? No. Conclusion: it is unjust - this was the problem with the Criminal Tribes Act, 1871, which is why it was repealed.

Two aspects of justice

Substantive justice is about the outcome: is the final decision fair, just and reasonable? Procedural justice is about the process: does every person involved get a full opportunity to be heard before the court decides? As a rule, every person is presumed innocent until proved guilty.

Two aspects of justice

  • Substantive justice
    • Looks at the final result
    • Asks: is the decision fair and reasonable?
    • Example: the right person compensated
  • Procedural justice
    • Looks at the process
    • Every side gets a full hearing
    • Innocent until proved guilty

Presumption of innocence: every accused person is treated as innocent until proved guilty, and must be heard before a decision is taken.

Worked example 2: applying the two aspects

A teacher finds a broken window and punishes the first student she sees, without asking anything. Later it turns out that student did break it. Substantive: the outcome happened to land on the right person. Procedural: the student was never heard, so the process was unfair. Lesson: a just system needs both a fair outcome and a fair process; being right by luck is not justice.

Key terms
TermMeaning
LawA general rule made by government, with consequences for breaking it
JudiciaryThe independent organ that settles disputes according to law
Substantive justiceFairness of the outcome
Procedural justiceFairness of the process; full hearing for all

Key takeaways: The Constitution promises social, economic and political justice. Laws aim at justice, but unjust laws - such as the Criminal Tribes Act and Vernacular Press Act in India, Jim Crow laws in the US and apartheid laws in South Africa - had to be repealed. Justice needs both a fair outcome (substantive) and a fair process (procedural). The independent judiciary checks that laws and government actions follow the Constitution.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which kinds of justice does the Preamble promise to all citizens?

    1. Only political justice
    2. Social, economic and political justice
    3. Only economic justice
    4. Religious and military justice
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Preamble to the Constitution promises all citizens social, economic and political justice.

  2. 2. Why was the Criminal Tribes Act, 1871, repealed?

    1. It labelled certain communities as criminals by birth, which is against justice and democracy
    2. It was too lenient
    3. It concerned only foreign citizens
    4. It was about the press
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Judging people as criminals by birth is discriminatory and inconsistent with the principles of a democratic republic, so the law was repealed.

  3. 3. Procedural justice means that:

    1. only the outcome matters
    2. the judge decides without hearing anyone
    3. every person involved gets a full opportunity to be heard before a decision
    4. the accused is presumed guilty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Procedural justice concerns a fair process: each side is fully heard, and every person is presumed innocent until proved guilty.

  4. 4. Which organ of government checks that laws passed by the legislature are within the framework of the Constitution?

    1. The executive
    2. The police
    3. The Election Commission
    4. The judiciary
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The independent judiciary ensures that laws stay within the Constitution and that the executive does not overstep its role.

  5. 5. The Jim Crow laws in parts of the United States:

    1. prevented people of colour from using facilities reserved for white people
    2. protected freedom of the press
    3. set up Lok Adalats
    4. gave equal rights to all
    Show answer

    Answer: A. These laws segregated public facilities such as water fountains, pools and restaurants by race; they were ended in the 1960s.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The Supreme Court of India

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery